Question about iodine: If next statement is true... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,644 members161,422 posts

Question about iodine

Justiina profile image
2 Replies

If next statement is true, (why wouldn't it be?), how taking iodine will replace other halogens ?

"Fluoride and iodine are both halogens. Fluoride, the negative ion of the element fluorine, easily displaces iodine in the body because it is much lighter and therefore more reactive. In fact, the activity of any one of the halogens (Iodine 126.70, Bromine 79.90, Chlorine 35.45, Fluorine 18.99 are the most common) is inversely proportional to its atomic weight. In other words, one halogen can displace another one of a higher atomic weight but cannot displace one of lower weight."

Or do you have to flood your system by ridiculous amount of iodine or is it something else that starts the process of other halogens pushing out?

I am not planning on having a party drinking tons loads of iodine :P I am just trying to understand all this.

Written by
Justiina profile image
Justiina
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
2 Replies
diogenes profile image
diogenesRemembering

A bit of chemistry. In the body, the halogens (except iodine bound as thyroxine or T3) exist almost entirely as electrically charged ions. All of them from fluoride to iodide can be represented as F-, Cl- etc - that is the atoms have one electric negative charge. They attract but do not bind to positively charged ions like sodium (Na+). There is no displacement as such, merely a loose interchanging attraction dance between the negative ions and positive ones.One halogen can only be displaced by a higher concentration of another. The atomic weights don't come into it. So e.g. high iodide can displace low fluoride and vice versa. Same with all other pairs.

Justiina profile image
Justiina in reply to diogenes

Thanks! You read a little bit here and then little bit there and end up having no clue.

You may also like...

Question regarding Iodine

concerned about the iodine. I take 2 tablets daily which equates to 0.0088350mg of iodine. Does...

Not sure about taking iodine

to take iodine and a lot to solve this. So I'm taking capsules which contain 400mcg iodine, 200mcg

The iodine question

pondering on iodine supplementation. The b-complex I used it buy have changed the formula to add...

Tests ordered! Iodine question

saves me some money. I have been reading about iodine and how even without thyroid being involved it

Iodine, To take or not to take that is the question?

(scroll down to the bottom for the comments) on Iodine....