Thyroid UK
82,921 members97,961 posts

Has anyone found some Brazil nuts in supermarket packets taste of chemical?

Who buys supermarket packs of 'organic' Brazil nuts for selenium?

Across however many packs, have you tasted what you think is weedkiller, sterilising fluid or chlorine - you can imagine the smell of those chemicals (not that you taste it of course) but SOME nuts are tainted and leaves the taste in mouth, after spitting them out and washing mouth out.

I want to know what the contamination is as the supermarket is in denial.

Their view is "rancid nuts" and I can assure you it is NOT THAT!

40 Replies
oldestnewest

I think it probably is rancid nuts. They grow wild in the forest, so little chance of pesticides being used.

Of course they may be treated after collection. But the supermarket probably doesn't know what happens to the nuts before they reach them.

2 likes
Reply

Thank you - I can tell if a nut is off or rancid and they are meant to be organic and most definitely there is a chemical taste to the odd one or some seems most packs.

Reply

Better to take selenium as a supplement. That way you mostly know what you are getting. Not all brazil nuts contain selenium. It depends on the soil the tree is growing in. Plants do not need selenium and they pick it up if it is in the soil.

Canadian lentils grown in Saskatchewan contain considerable amounts of selenium because they are grown in soil that is rich in selenium.

3 likes
Reply

I can't for some reason take tablet form, hence why swapped to brazil nuts. It is very worrying.

I know they vary in selenium, so only do couple at a time.

Thank u :-)

Reply

Why can't you take the tablets?

Clams, mussels, oysters all contain selenium as well. Plus zinc which is good too.

Lentils from Canada: Saskatchewan soil contains too much selenium for cattle probably because the sod has been removed by the way farming is conducted. Not good. But anyway, here's a Pubmed article about the selenium content of the lentils 99% of Canadian lentils are grown in Saskatchewan. They are a major export item. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/189...

Chances are lentils purchased in England are imported from Canada. Check the label.

Reply

>Clams, mussels, oysters all contain selenium as well. Plus zinc which is good too.

And B12! :-)

O Canada! sainsburys.co.uk/shop/gb/gr...

Reply

Yup. Canada grows good lentils. We even have those French Du Puy lentils which are very nice because they don't break up once cooked.

Reply

I can't do seafood or shellfish either LOL.

Thanks for the link :-)

Reply

the link was about lentils.

Reply

Thank you yes. sorry, was very tired, didn't explain :-)

I wasn't sure if lentils was on the good or bad list, so to speak. I know I didn't like them as a child and were hard to swallow back then but appreciate have to eat things we wouldn't normally and I have cut things out too :)

Reply

If you buy decorticated lentils, after they are cooked there's no 'solid' pieces. And you can always use a blender to make a soup. Thin or thick, depending on what you are able to swallow. Or you can make it into a thick paste like mayonnaise. Add them to a smoothie. Lentils are a very adaptable food item.

1 like
Reply

I have noticed some nuts taste of soap.

1 like
Reply

Hmm....at least someone tastes something that isn't nut flavour - thank you :-)

Reply

I buy mine from a well known supermarket beginning with S. They taste lovely, and they are the only ones I've found that state on the packet that they contain selenium

Lu

1 like
Reply

You are free to mention supermarket names.

Restrictions are on the basis of spam or prescription medicines - not genuine personal experience.

Funnily enough, I couldn't see Selenium mentioned on Sainsbury' web site. And was it their ordinary ones or their SO organic ones? Do they actually state a numeric content or just general comment?

2 likes
Reply

They aren't the organic ones. Orange and see through bag (sainsburys colours) Front of bag they say 'high in selenium' and on the nutrition values, under Vitamins and minerals it says selenium 250ug per 100g (455% of rda) or 75ug per 30g serving (139% of rda)

Lu

2 likes
Reply

Thank you. Someone in Sainsbury' knows some customers are buying them for that reason, I guess. Obviously doesn't mean other suppliers' products don't have selenium but we are always going to be unsure if they do not declare.

2 likes
Reply

Green SO Organic has selenium on pack

1 like
Reply

So Organic state on the pack source of selenium or words to effect :)

1 like
Reply

A useful amount of selenium and B12 in Sainsbury's sardines, too, with one option canned in water.

5 likes
Reply

Need to get B12 up probably as last tested couple years back mid range and not tested since.

Reply

Bet it COULD be the same I have had issues from across several packs bought at different times - BUT another store mixed nuts had same sort of thing ages back.

Reply

you can buy raw organic brazil nuts online. I am not sure how raw they actually are but they are normally not treated the way supermarket nuts are. If you do a google search you will find a few companys that sell them

2 likes
Reply

Thank you :)

1 like
Reply

I chomped through 5 kilos from Bolivia via, ahem, the Amazon.

2 likes
Reply

Hahaha that is quite something ;-)

I am careful but wish there was simple and cheap non invasive test so we know how much we need etc - I think there are some tests for various and you find it omits one thing you want testing but does another vice versa. So where I was iodine deficient - by taking selenium that could have been why couldn't take it - ie side effects maybe. I need another iodine test but all I can focus on is keeping roof over head but not to have too much of anything.

Reply

Moderation in most things, but aiming for a surfeit of joy might be the best policy.

Some Amazon reviews complained about a short date on the nuts, but I worked out I could finish my bag well within its stated date by eating three nuts a day, and they tasted better than snack-size packs from supermarkets.

I gave up bulk-buying when Morrisons had a long-term offer (since ceased) on 50 g packs of nuts, so walnuts and unsalted pistachios were added to my store of sunflower and pumpkin seeds. Of those, sunflower seeds are a good source of selenium, with 21% of RDA from a 1 ounce serving.

1 like
Reply

Ahh thank you - I may need to get more adventurous but hard with things not eaten before... the odd seed in bread when used to eat it... but never got head round so to speak... must be bolder LOL

Reply

I buy organic nuts but because of the cost I imagine they are not a best selling item, they can lie on the shelves for longer than maybe non-organic nuts. This is something I have noticed, often the sell by dates are not good. Even in Holland and Barratt recently I went to buy organic dried fruit which of course was a little more expensive than non-organic, the sell by date was this month, not a good way to purchase. I have noticed a tainted smell occasionally and put it down to rancidity.

Reply

There are often rancid or mouldy tasting ones..not good but this is like Fisons or Miltons (picture smell of)....

Reply

I just figured I'd got a rancid nut among the good ones. Strange how it's always just an odd nut in the bag that tastes odd and bitter rather than the entire bag.

1 like
Reply

I think the nuts are probably old and rancid and what you are tasting is rancid oil. Nuts deteriorate fast and organic ones can't be sprayed with anything to stop them going off. Wel all interpret tastes in different ways. Brazil nuts are boiled to remove the shells so perhaps they are boiled in chlorinated water

1 like
Reply

I wondered if it was chlorine as that was one of the things I considered it tasted like the smell of...

Reply

Hi I have been eating nuts for over 50 years. For the last 10 years from Sainsburys organic Mr Jack. Once only I had a pack of nuts that tasted old and rancid so I return them directly to the manufacturers and received lots of goodies back. Sometimes a bad bunch of nuts gets into production by mistake. Hope this helps.

2 likes
Reply

Exact same thing just happened to me with organic brazil nuts it is definitely a strong chemical taste, unlike anything I've tasted before in how definitively strong and obviously chemical it was. I wouldn't say it was a milder taste like chlorine but a sharp poisonous/toxic/metallic taste. Perhaps enough to turn me off them for good

Reply

Sam e thing has just happened to me ...yuk!! I bought Mt pack of Brazil nuts from Aldo.The second one I tasted was awful. Tasted of a chemical that burned the inside of my mouth.I quickly spat it into a napkin and repeatedly washed my mouth out with fresh water..The chemical tasted and smelled very strong of what I can only describe as weedkiller..not that I make a habit out of tasting weedkiller but I'm sure you get my drift...ooo scary.

Reply

I just ate a Brazil nut tonight & instantly spit it out! It tastes just like raid bug spray smells. Blech!! I'm glad I'm not the only one who's experienced this. I wonder what caused it? The other nuts tasted fine.

Reply

It might help if everyone identified the product they are finding unpleasant.

I suggest posting the branding on the packet, the packet size, any information about country of origin, best before date. If there is a "bad batch", then we might find that they are all from one country, and with a narrow window of best before dates - or something like that.

Might well be worth reporting to consumer protection people as they will get reports from all over and be in a much better place to identify the actual problem.

Reply

Yes, Helvella, your advice is wise re: reporting to Consumer Protection.

I eat Brazil nuts on a regular basis and usually at least one nut in every 500grm bag of shelled nuts has a highly toxic chemical taste. It is just as others have described and it’s very worrying as it does taste like the smell of a plant insecticide / fungicide.

I have to state ,emphatically,that this is absolutely not the taste of a rancid nut.

The taste that I describe is like that of a chemical that has entered the nut. It is not a ‘natural’ oxidisation of oils taste.

Many years ago , I bought a bar of chocolate from a petrol station. This chocolate tasted like the smell of the petrol. I believe that the fats in the chocolate had absorbed some of the petrol, or exhaust fumes, that were around the petrol station .

Perhaps the oils in a shelled Brazil nut have the same propensity? Perhaps the nuts are stored in areas where there are chemical / fertiliser / insecticide emissions ?

I wonder why it’s only maybe just one nut in a bag that tastes like this ?

I’m very wary when I eat Brazil nuts now, and I’ve warned my family about them. I may stop eating them, and just opt for Selenium supplements and the foods that contain it.

Consumer Protection , here we come!

1 like
Reply

Not forgetting about your concerns, Storm.

I think they are very valid!

Reply