Dutasteride Black Box Warning Label i... - Prostate Cancer N...

Prostate Cancer Network

5,258 members3,324 posts

Dutasteride Black Box Warning Label is Inappropriate.

janebob99 profile image
9 Replies

This plot that I made goes back to the original paper by Thompson et al. (2003), that was the basis for slapping the Black Box Warning Label on Dutasteride prescriptions.

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/128...

There are some important points that should be considered:

(1) Thompson only studied Finesteride, not Dutasteride;

(2) The absolute difference in % of men who have high-grade prostate cancer (GS = 8, 9, 10) is very small (only 1%), as shown in the plot: 6% for men on Finesteride and 5% for Placebo. That's within the noise and is not statistically significant.

(3) Thompson et al. speculated in their paper that the large shrinkage of the prostate (~25%) when on Finesteride may cause an error (a "bias") that "affects the evidence".

It is true that the probability of a random biopsy needle hitting a tumor increases as the prostate volume decreases, (assuming that the number of tumors remains the same before and after Finesteride). That factor is called a "detection bias".

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17848668/

After Thompson et al. was published, doctors and researchers have written papers/comments that the black box warning label on Finesteride and Dutasteride should be removed.

I agree!!

Bob Watson

Written by
janebob99 profile image
janebob99
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
9 Replies
Justfor_ profile image
Justfor_

No catastrophising on the other side of the pond.

janebob99 profile image
janebob99 in reply toJustfor_

What do you mean?

Justfor_ profile image
Justfor_ in reply tojanebob99

No silly warnings on the Avodart box, apart from: "To be used by men only".

janebob99 profile image
janebob99 in reply toJustfor_

Gosh, maybe they removed the label! I will investigate. Thanks!

janebob99 profile image
janebob99 in reply tojanebob99

I checked ChatGPT, and you are correct. There is no warning in the UK for high-grade PCa. Only in the USA. Good catch !

lancer82801 profile image
lancer82801

To me this is a problem that should at least be discussed prior to treatment

Video for your information
j-o-h-n profile image
j-o-h-n

Blimey, It may be on the left side........... Yanks on the right side.........

Good Luck, Good Health and Good Humor.

j-o-h-n

RodriguezJ profile image
RodriguezJ

Hi Bob Watson! Thanks for the insightful analysis. Let's break it down further.

First, it’s crucial to note that the study by Thompson et al. (2003) focused specifically on Finasteride, not Dutasteride. While these drugs are similar in their action, they inhibit different types of 5-alpha-reductase, which might affect their safety and efficacy profiles differently.

Second, the absolute difference in the percentage of men with high-grade prostate cancer (Gleason Score 8, 9, 10) is indeed very small—only 1%. As you correctly pointed out, this is within the margin of statistical noise and is not statistically significant.

Third, the issue of prostate volume reduction with Finasteride is also important. A significant reduction in prostate size (~25%) could indeed introduce a detection bias, as the probability of a biopsy needle hitting a tumor increases when the prostate volume decreases, assuming the number of tumors remains constant. This factor could potentially skew the results, which the original authors acknowledged.

After the publication of Thompson et al., many doctors and researchers have written papers and comments suggesting that the black box warning on Finasteride and Dutasteride should be reconsidered.

Also use only trustworthy and reliable pharmacies to avoid counterfeit meds and unscrupulous sellers, here is one of the really trusted pharmacies of our time - world-delivery-service.com

I agree with you!! Thank you for your contribution to this discussion!

janebob99 profile image
janebob99 in reply toRodriguezJ

Thank you for the positive feedback! I appreciate it. I agree with everything you have said.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Finesteride

I was proscribed Tansulosin and Finesteride upn receiving my stage 2 porstate cancer diagnosis. I...
Eadgbe profile image

Testosterone Therapy Does Not Increase the Risks of Prostate Cancer Recurrence or Death After Definitive Treatment for Localized Disease

In the largest observational study so far, Sarkar et al. reported that men in the US Veterans...
Tall_Allen profile image

What ADT duration would you use?

Hello All, Would you please give your opinions on the proper ADT duration for me? Gleason 4+5=9,...
A0007720 profile image

Focal Ablation doesn't work (again)

Cryo joins HIFU, FLA, and IRE as substandard focal thermoablation therapies. Aker et al. reported...
Tall_Allen profile image

Moderation team

Bethishere profile image
BethishereAdministrator
Number6 profile image
Number6Administrator
Darryl profile image
DarrylPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.