Does anyone take Vit K2 to help with bones? - PMRGCAuk

PMRGCAuk

20,319 members38,053 posts

Does anyone take Vit K2 to help with bones?

Francesbarbara profile image
21 Replies

I have had a slightly raised calcium level for more than 20 years. Consultant is not perturbed, as it never 'spikes' and is tested regularly. I do not take calcium along with Pred for the above reason. I understand that vit K2 helps to put calcium into bones and not leave it in blood vessels etc. When I asked my Dr, he said he could not prescribe it, as NICE have not approved it but he seemed happy for me to purchase a supplement myself. Has anyone any experience of this?. My Dexa scan was VG.

Written by
Francesbarbara profile image
Francesbarbara
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
21 Replies
andfio profile image
andfio

Yes my husband takes it just as a precaution no idea how true it is or works but meant to stop calcium plaques in arteries and our doctor said yes go ahead hope this helps

SheffieldJane profile image
SheffieldJane

I take vit K2 for the reasons you give. I buy my own for the reasoning you give. I find Heron very, very good on bone health. You may wish to look at her posts on the subject. I have refused Alendronic Acid and similar and try to take the appropriate supplements and have a calcium rich diet.

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer

Many on here take Vitamin K2 Mk alongside their calcium supplements-but not prescribed .

Plenty of choice online and in health shops/chemists.

Bcol profile image
Bcol

I take Vit K2.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador

It is a supplement so not prescribable - vit D is one of the very few along with vit B12. HeronNS is the proponent for vit K2 and has researched it widely.

Francesbarbara profile image
Francesbarbara in reply to PMRpro

Thank you so much to everyone who has replied with such helpful info. and no negatives. This is what makes this forum so special. I'll get some Vit K2 tomorrow.

Sharitone profile image
Sharitone

I take it on the grounds that: some people think it will get the Ca to the right place, which is a huge bonus; it's not going to do any harm; and it's very cheap!

singingloud profile image
singingloud

I take it with my vitamin D and calcium. My dexa scan improved. I also do not take it close to my prednisone. Take one dose at lunch and one dose at dinner.

Broseley profile image
Broseley

My GP and my pharmacist hadn't even heard of it. So I went ahead anyway and bought some K2 based on the advice on here and research online. I have taken it daily since starting on calcium.

pmr_nikola profile image
pmr_nikola

instead of supplements you could try natural sources. Fermented soybeans

(natto en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natt%...

is very rich in K2 ,could be found in Japanese deli. Taste may be hard to get use to at first, but some spicy mustard covers it well.

Exflex profile image
Exflex

I’ve asked various medics (doctors and others) about K2 they just shrug their shoulders. If it’s so good for ‘directing’ calcium to where it’s needed and away from where it’s not, why do those in the medical profession know so little about K2. That’s what concerns me.

Francesbarbara profile image
Francesbarbara in reply to Exflex

Yes, I too have wondered about their lack of knowledge. However, when I realise how little my GP surgery knows about PMR, which is something they must come across quite frequently, perhaps I shouldn't be surprised. For those that are interested in this subject there is a book called 'Vit K2 and the Calcium Paradox.'. A Canadian author, her science is quite compelling.

Oh-my profile image
Oh-my

I take a small amount of vit K2 supplement which is from natural sources (fermented chickpeas) as a top up but I also make kefir which has some K2 and also your body will make some from vit K if you eat plenty of spinach etc. Like all these things it is most likely to help if your diet is insufficient which I suspect probably doesn't apply to most of us - but no harm in trying

Francesbarbara profile image
Francesbarbara in reply to Oh-my

Thank you - we eat lots of spinach, but fermented beans, chickpeas are something we have not yet tried.

readingbooks profile image
readingbooks

For several years now ( PMR )I have been taking a combined capsule of K2 120 mcg and Vit D 3 1000 iu available as a supplement OTC .

RachelJDH profile image
RachelJDH

I was on the normal calcium/vitamin D but was getting an irritated bladder. On advice on this site I now take a 400.g vitamin D and a K2 tablet together and no calcium. To be honest I don't know if this helps with bones but my bladder irritation has gone but I have no idea if k2 and vitamin D makes a difference. I suspect you would have to take it long term for any measurable difference. The good news is I have no bad side effects which I count as a victory..😀

Missus835 profile image
Missus835

Yes. I take K2(MK7). I buy it over the counter. HeronNS posted a really good link on K2.

Francesbarbara profile image
Francesbarbara in reply to Missus835

Thank you - she has sent me the link. Excellent article.

sassykitty profile image
sassykitty

My rheumatologist has me on D3 and K2

HeronNS profile image
HeronNS

You might find this post helpful.

healthunlocked.com/american...

Francesbarbara profile image
Francesbarbara in reply to HeronNS

Thank you very much for giving me access to this article, which I have now read twice. It is certainly one to keep, as it covers so much ground and may be a surprise to many people.

You may also like...

Does anyone take Boron for their bones

dose of supplements you take. Calcium was listed, which I don't take but as I have high calcium...

BONES Calcium Vit D magnesium Vit k2

anyone out there saw an improvement in Dexa scan with the above mentioned vitamins. I am beginning...

Vit K2

Please help with direction on the best form of Vit K2 for PMR folks... MK4 or MK7. Also grateful for

Dexascan shows bone deterioration. Not keen on adcal so looking at Vit D3 supplement. Need to avoid K2.

one. As a starter I want to purchase 'clean' vit D3 alone -(no K2 supplement because of warfarin)...

If I'm taking Fosamax should I still be taking my K2 and Calcium?

take my K2 and calcium. Is this okay or should I stop the supplement? My last bone scan showed a...