HCl Pills: Do most of us take HCl pills... - Pernicious Anaemi...

Pernicious Anaemia Society

32,672 members24,065 posts

HCl Pills

topher2018 profile image
13 Replies

Do most of us take HCl pills since our pareital cells that produce acid have been destroyed? I assume everyone with PA has difficulty just popping out to a restaurant to eat correct?

Written by
topher2018 profile image
topher2018
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
13 Replies
fbirder profile image
fbirder

I prefer to use lime juice. About 40 ml in a glass of orange or tonic water seems to do the job. I do have a bottle of betaine.HCl for when I go out to eat as it’s a lot less fussy.

Sita505USA profile image
Sita505USA in reply tofbirder

Please expand on this. I know nothing about this. I have had intestinal surgeries and taken PPIs in the past. Do not have a diagnosis yet. Have fatigue and neurological symptoms. I know absorption is an issue. Do these

things have to do with low stomach acid? Thanks, Sita

fbirder profile image
fbirder in reply toSita505USA

Pernicious Anaemia is misnamed. It’s basic cause is an autoimmune attack on Gastric Parietal Cells. The result is Autoimmune Metaplastic Gastric Atrophy.

There are two main effects. The GPCs make Intrinsic Factor - a protein that is needed to get B12 from the gut to the blood. They also make stomach acid. Some people with AMGA find that they get nasty gut effects (gas, bloating, diarrhoea) that can be reduced by taking additional acid with large meals.

Do a search for some of my posts for more info than you probably want.

Sita505USA profile image
Sita505USA in reply tofbirder

Many thanks!!

Bebster profile image
Bebster in reply tofbirder

As a matter of interest do you take your lime juice before, during or after the meal?

fbirder profile image
fbirder in reply toBebster

I try to simulate what happens naturally. So I’ll wait until I’m about halfway through the meal then I’ll drink the lime juice with the rest of it, leaving a good dollop to wash down the last mouthful.

Bebster profile image
Bebster in reply tofbirder

Interesting, thanks!

cdragin profile image
cdragin

I'm curious about this. I never even heard of it until about a week ago. I have zero digestive difficulties (although I belch like a colonel for some reason) so it never occurred to me that I need to take anything.

topher2018 profile image
topher2018 in reply tocdragin

Well my understanding is that if you have PA it means you have killed off all the pareital cells that are in a normal stomach. Since pareital cells make acid as well as intrinsic factor, without them you won’t be producing acid normally required for digestion. So it seems likely that people with PA would have digestive issues. I do. So I was wondering what others are doing. I ordered HCl pills with pepsin today. I will try them and report back.

Portia1974 profile image
Portia1974 in reply tocdragin

The belching itself can, I understand, be a sign of the low stomach acid being described here.

JanD236 profile image
JanD236

Yes I take HCL & pepsin and I feel much better for taking them. If I forget I quickly become bloated and constipated and it can take me a couple of days to feel better again.

I’m certain I don’t have sufficient stomach acid. I’ve been positive for both gastric parietal cell and intrinsic factor antibodies over the last few years. In addition, I had a severe allergic reaction to eating a peach a few months before I was diagnosed with PA. The allergy specialist explained that my true allergy is to birch tree pollen and peach protein is bio identical to that. He thought I had insufficient stomach acid to digest the peach proteins which caused my immune system to go haywire when they arrived undigested in my gut.

Exhaustion and stomach/gut problems were my major symptoms of PA.

I was also helped by taking a few courses of a probiotic called Symprove for a couple of years.

At the moment I’m just trying out a papaya extract tablet from Holland & Barrett which contains the digestive enzymes protease and amalayse. It was reported on the TV programme ‘Food explained’ that they may help people with stomach issues.

topher2018 profile image
topher2018

Here is an article title that seems to indicate that at least one person had PA but was able to produce acid.

annals.org/aim/article-abst...

fbirder profile image
fbirder in reply totopher2018

I’ve not read he whole thing, but I’m not too sure on how reliable a diagnosis of PA would have been 85 years ago.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

HCl Pills Helping Me

I started taking HCl pills yesterday and they are helping. Still have some pain on right side...
topher2018 profile image

HCL - advice please

I have PA and Hashimotos. I knew that I would have low or no HCL because of the PA but only read...
ren41 profile image

Gastrin & Betaine hcl

Hi everyone, this may be wishful thinking but is it possible Betaine hcl switches off the Gastrin...
Helliborous profile image

HCL or DGL?

I've basically had some version of a stomach ache for two months. It might be gastritis, so I my...
Galixie profile image

Desiccated liver pills

Hi, have any of you taken desiccated liver pills to help with Vitamin B 12 deficiency?
Hambledonia profile image

Moderation team

See all
Gambit62 profile image
Gambit62Administrator
Foggyme profile image
FoggymeAdministrator
taka profile image
takaAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.