"Water weight": Hope you guys following... - Low-Carb High-Fat...

Low-Carb High-Fat (LCHF)

2,816 members1,338 posts

"Water weight"

TheAwfulToad profile image
TheAwfulToadAmbassador
12 Replies

Hope you guys following Lytham's Challenge are all still full of beans (in moderation, of course :) ). I noticed that some of you who started early, and are now approaching week 3, are enthused by some quite impressive initial weight loss. While it's great to see that downwards movement on the scales, it's worth remembering that some of this (half a kilo, possibly more) is "water weight" - the loss of excess water held in various places. Most people lose more than is really good for them while one's body makes a rapid adjustment to the new diet.

Therefore, your weight loss will slow down somewhat, and may even stop, as you body re-establishes water homeostasis at the correct setpoint.

Not trying to rain on anybody's parade here. Just pointing out that it pays to be realistic and keep focused on the long view. Stick with it and the pounds will start to drop away.

Incidentally: if you've read some of the arguments on the internet suggesting that low-carb diets work by causing nothing more than water loss ... well, let me know if you see any wizened, prune-like LCHF adherents stumbling around :)

Anybody having sugar withdrawal symptoms?

Written by
TheAwfulToad profile image
TheAwfulToad
Ambassador
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
12 Replies
gonnadoitnow profile image
gonnadoitnow

Anybody having sugar withdrawal symptoms?

Well, chocolate is a big part of my life, so I'm feeling the loss. Also scared if I fall off this diet (it's Not a way of life... yet) I shall go back to eating more than is good for me. Other than the choc I eat pretty healthily.

TheAwfulToad profile image
TheAwfulToadAmbassador in reply to gonnadoitnow

Just make sure you eat until you're full and listen to your appetite re. fat, I think you'll be fine. If it helps, chocolate can come back into your diet when you feel that you don't need chocolate :)

gonnadoitnow profile image
gonnadoitnow in reply to TheAwfulToad

What planet are you on?? Who doesn't need chocolate?? :D :D

Side note: how do I do italics?

TheAwfulToad profile image
TheAwfulToadAmbassador in reply to gonnadoitnow

See here:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBCode

gonnadoitnow profile image
gonnadoitnow in reply to TheAwfulToad

Thanks!

Third time lucky!!

Subtle_badger profile image
Subtle_badger in reply to gonnadoitnow

If you are in the UK, get your hands on Montezuma's Absolute Black. 100% chocolate. You can safely eat it on low carb, because it's a beast, and a tiny piece is all you will want - and if somehow you could eat a whole 100g bar, it's still only 8g of carbs and practically no sugars. It's very different from even 90% chocolate. It will also tell you if you if it's chocolate you are addicted to, or the sugar within it.

One bar lasted me months. I would nibble a little of this bitter treat, and my body would pulse with a shock of joy. But a tiny piece is enough, the rest went back in the cupboard.

If you find it is not to your taste, you can use it as an ingredient.

gonnadoitnow profile image
gonnadoitnow in reply to Subtle_badger

Thanks, I'll look out for it, but I have a strong suspicion it's the sugar within... lol.

I have found that to stay hydrated I've had to massively up my salt intake. I never used much salt anyway so each morning I measure out a teaspoon of salt and add it to *everything*. I did start with two teaspoons but couldn't get down all of it.

Lytham profile image
Lytham

Don't all weight loss plans cause initial water loss? :-) x

TheAwfulToad profile image
TheAwfulToadAmbassador in reply to Lytham

I guess extreme caloric restriction will, because it'll force your body to burn through glycogen. The standard calorie-counted, low-fat, high-glycemic-load diet will not - you'll get a transient weight loss (some of which will be water) and then your glycogen stores will go right back up to their 100%-full state as your body recalibrates its power consumption to match the food that it's getting.

One of the reasons that carbs eventually trigger runaway weight gain is that your glycogen storage is essentially taken offline in this manner; if it's pinned at 100%, then by definition it can't absorb any more energy, so excess carbs have nowhere else to go except through the lipogenesis pathway.

Low-carb tends to cause additional water loss over and above that associated with a temporary glycogen rundown (it eventually stabilizes out at an optimal ~50%). That additional loss is driven by the shifting electrolyte balance. Most people who have been on high-carb diets for a very long period have elevated blood pressure, partly as a result of abnormally-high blood volume and abnormal sodium retention (that's why diuretics were, or used to be, the first-line treatment for high BP). As you switch to a healthy diet, this corrects itself, so people on blood pressure medication are usually advised to stop taking it when they drop the carbs.

Lytham profile image
Lytham in reply to TheAwfulToad

Interesting, thanks for the clarification :-) x

FairyTales profile image
FairyTales

I like your point of being realistic. Seems my water weight is totally gone that's why my weight is not moving much. I'm on Keto / LCHF for long. I cannot go zero carbs.

I have to have some comfort food which I restrict most of the days. Thankfully, I'm not addicted to sugar (cane sugar) or chocolates or any baked sweets. Only thing I miss is sandwiches.

You may also like...

Shocked at weight gain

scales, as I know you go by how loose your clothes are, rather than obsessing about weight. I was...

Weight loss

walnuts while watching tv as snacks and my fav pork scratchings (small pack).Plenty of water and my...

Weight gain

important, but I see the weight gain on my body. I haven’t felt the benefits any more either like...

Keto diet came 1st on save money, lose weight

save money lose weight on ITV tonight and 2019 winner on this programme is the keto diet. Winning...

Weight loss stories

eating and not a diet but would be interesting to have some responses about typical weight loss...