What are people's views on the Saatchi Bill? - Healthy Evidence

Healthy Evidence

3,068 members447 posts

What are people's views on the Saatchi Bill?

Gez_Blair profile image
5 Replies

which looks like its heading to the law books

telegraph.co.uk/health/saat...

Will it lead to life-saving innovative treatments for dying patient, or is it a license for quacks to dole out dangerous and untested drugs to vulnerable people? (Or a bit of both)

Written by
Gez_Blair profile image
Gez_Blair
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
5 Replies
Josephine_Jones profile image
Josephine_Jones

The coverage by the Telegraph in particular - Saatchi's "media partner" - has been misleading in the extreme. There is no requirement for this bill. It would not increase innovation, since current law already allows innovative treatments. It would, however, remove patient safeguards, allowing a doctor to go ahead with a treatment which no responsible body of medical opinion would allow. It would not be restricted to dying patients and could be used to justify wildly experimental treatment even where an effective treatment already exists. It could even hinder research, by deterring patients from taking part in clinical trials.

With amendment after amendment and with the confusing PR spin coming from the Saatchi team, it can be hard to keep track of it all but as far as I can tell, the same problems have remained from the beginning. I recommend stopthesaatchibill.co.uk/ for up to date news on this and for more detailed arguments by people who know their stuff.

in reply toJosephine_Jones

Just picking up this topic after 7 weeks with sporadic internet access! Did the govt ever publish the consultation responses?

Josephine_Jones profile image
Josephine_Jones in reply to

Here we are: gov.uk/government/consultat...

teessidesitp profile image
teessidesitp

This is a piece of ego legislation from an arch marketing entrepreneur that is trying to solve a problem about innovative treatment that doesn't exist except in his own imagination. It is a quacks charter the kind of which we thought was dispensed with 300 years ago when the enlightenment came along. If this gets through we are shamed as a modern country. Disgraceful.

Zeno profile image
Zeno

The committee stage in the House of Lords in on now. Watch here: parliamentlive.tv/Main/Play...

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Are we looking at Obesity Science the wrong way?

As a heavily overweight person, I have an active interest in articles and opinions about obesity....
JossS profile image

A Aman on tic tok says he's cured from schizophrenia wo meds. What are your views on this do u belive him is that even possible

So there is this guy on tic tok says he's cured from schizophrenia no meds he does like rekei and...
Atthepark profile image

Are dentists or opticians medical scans sent on to the patients GP?

If a dentist xrays a persons jaws, are the results automatically passed onto the GP's patients...
Adlon57 profile image

What can be done about reducing the public confusion created by conflicting health messages from the daily media vs. public health?

Public health messages: everything in moderation, make small long term lifestyle changes toward a...
robdavies profile image

On the slippery slope back into binge eating disorder

I was discharged from the eating disorder service in February and was doing really well (I even...
Ju1ie-Ann3 profile image

Moderation team

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.