Health Bloggers: Researchers have reviewed... - Healthy Eating

Healthy Eating

60,818 members8,167 posts

Health Bloggers

Cooper27 profile image
Cooper27Administrator
10 Replies

Researchers have reviewed the diets of the top 9 health bloggers in the UK, so determine whether their diets and advice are healthy. Only 1 met the criteria, which is interesting:

news.sky.com/story/dieters-...

I'll obviously qualify this, that we don't know whose sites were reviewed, and we also don't know what the criteria for rating the blogs. The only person to pass was a qualified nutritional therapist, so that helps narrow it down a little!

Written by
Cooper27 profile image
Cooper27
Administrator
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
10 Replies
benwl profile image
benwl

This is really interesting, and perhaps not surprising. A number of news organizations have reported this study, but I've not yet been able to find the original paper, probably because it's not yet been presented at a conference.

Personally it really annoys me when academics try to get exposure for themselves by sending out press releases like this without making the paper itself available.

This seems to be the press release.

eurekalert.org/pub_releases...

Cooper27 profile image
Cooper27Administrator in reply to benwl

Yes, it doesn't surprise me! I'm really quite curious to know whose advice is believed to be the most sound. But perhaps they're not publishing the paper yet, until they've sorted out the legalities? I imagine they'd have to name (and shame) the blogs, which might be risky ground.

S11m profile image
S11m in reply to benwl

"transparency, evidence-based references, trustworthiness and adherence to nutritional guidance, and bias"

If your doctor gives you advice - do you demand or expect a full bibliography for everything they tell you?

We expect bias from universities - where does their funding come from?

Does the nutritional guidance still advocate low-fat high carbohydrate?

I am glad to see that they used Public Health England's info.

benwl profile image
benwl in reply to S11m

I'm not demanding a full bibliography, just the paper being referred to.

It's only through reading it will we find out the specifics of the nutritional guidance they use.

As for bias, all research and all writing on health is potentially biased or subject to conflicts of interest. It's only through a critical reading of them can we find out how reliable their claims actually are.

This is interesting and I'm glad that the nutritional therapist was giving sound advice.

So thanks for sharing it as its food for thought thats for sure. 😊

Cooper27 profile image
Cooper27Administrator in reply to

What's worrying is that it seems one blog was run by a GP, and her blog apparently failed...

S11m profile image
S11m

This prompts a few thoughts:

Never believe anything you read in the news.

Perhaps it is the UK nutritional guidelines that are wrong.

Bear in mind that much of the WHO & NHS guidelines and standard advice are 50 to 100 years behind current research, which is on the internet for anyone to read.

What benefit are qualifications if what they teach is out of date or biased?

...but the NHS has benefited me - and I have benefited from hundreds of thousands of pounds worth of treatment.

Cooper27 profile image
Cooper27Administrator in reply to S11m

Yes, I know what you mean - I'd like to see their qualifying factors. But I suppose that even if we updated our definition of a healthy diet, 8 of the 9 bloggers would probably still be wrong! Our definition of "healthy diet" appears to be completely open to interpretation...

Best not to trust any of them...encourage people to come on to the healthy eating forum where you get good advice and no biased nonsense.

Zest profile image
Zest

Hi Cooper27

I'll try to keep my eyes open to find the study - it would be interesting to see the comparisons.

Zest :-)

You may also like...

Where are you on the Health Eating scale?

NHS Statistics on Obesity, Physical Activity and Diet in 2018. I like things like this as it's a...

Today is the start of Mental Health week for children,

and being a parent (and I was a single dad) so I know how we as parents worry about our children,...

Top Health food trends of 2020

wise: https://www.goodhousekeeping.com/health/diet-nutrition/g30520941/food-trends-2020/ I also...

Obesity is set to become a bigger threat to health than smoking...🍔🍟🌭

think that the real problem is too many people don't know or care or even think about what they are...

How can low carb be good for the planetary health?

anyone here justify eating a low carb meat based diet when seemingly by definition it is...