Beware the easy way out!: I followed the... - Healthy Eating

Healthy Eating

62,252 members8,214 posts

Beware the easy way out!

Merry_Widow profile image
6 Replies

I followed the calorie-counted diet for four weeks, then I thought I'd have a "treat" and signed up for a food hamper from a diet firm. (Fortunately you don't have to sign up for anything, just order a week's meals.) The idea is you just eat what's in the box so you don't need to count calories or think about it at all. I wanted to train myself into a healthier eating pattern as well, with breakfast and lunch and so on.

Didn't work for me. I didn't actually eat anything more than what was in the box, but drink was my downfall :( I had carefully calculated the calories in a glass of wine, etc, so that altogether I would be having the NHS-recommended 1595 per day.

I felt fine and was exercising a bit more, but when I weighed in both my weight and waist size had increased to what they were two weeks ago! So upset and mad with myself. Now I'm trying to get back on track.

Written by
Merry_Widow profile image
Merry_Widow
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
6 Replies

Hi Merry_Widdow, so you bought a hamper of food and drank too much wine and now you're beating your self up, when in fact you've learnt that there's more to a balanced diet than a glass in each hand...sounds like a success to me 😊

Zest profile image
Zest

Hi Merry_Widow ,

Wishing you success with getting back on track again - it's a new week ahead, and like Hidden said, you've made a great start, and you can learn from any obstacle in your path, and negotiate your way around it, going forward.

Good luck! Maybe also join the NHS weight loss forum - also on Health unlocked, if you would like extra support with the weight loss side of things.

A link is here if you want to have a look:

healthunlocked.com/nhsweigh...

Zest :-)

TheAwfulToad profile image
TheAwfulToad

There's really no reason to be mad at yourself. You followed what it said on the tin and it didn't work (if I've read it right, you adjusted your calories-in and calories-out to account for the glass of wine). So how is it somehow YOUR fault? Logically, if you gained weight while still doing "all the right things", then there must be some problem with the diet itself, not you ... no?

The jury is still out on how badly alcohol messes up weight loss. Ethanol metabolism is surprisingly complex, so the ultimate fate of a glass of wine (or its knock-on effects) will depend on a whole bunch of other things going on in your diet - and also possibly on the phase of the moon, the colour of your curtains, or the air temperature in Hull.

General consensus is that alcohol is best avoided, although my personal experience is that I can drink 4-5 units a week without any effect on my weight. Still, that's just me, and maybe I'm just lucky. Even so, I suspect your weight gain had little or nothing to do with the wine, but was simply the usual mediocre result that (statistically speaking) a majority will experience with calorie-controlled diets.

Definitely a good plan to get into the habit of eating regular meals though. As someone else commented in another thread, it's a journey. It seems we have to go through these frustrations before finding out what works and what doesn't. I wish you a short and quick journey :)

Activity2004 profile image
Activity2004Administrator in reply toTheAwfulToad

Perfect advice, TheAwfulToad . Thank you for sharing this information.

Or you could just have a big laugh

about it all !

Imagine the ad campaign for that company. “Try us for a week, we guarantee you will gain weight!”

Hang in there, this week you will do awesome! Karen

elliebath profile image
elliebath

Put it down to experience. Out if interest when you simply calorie counted for 4 weeks did you include wine then as well? I managed to lose while still drinking (carefully) and have maintained the same way. But not everyone seems to.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

NHS the truth about carbs.

Hi everyone, Recently we've had members confused about what is the best diet for them with carbs...

Mark Hyman: The Problems with Nutrition Science

Edited to remove book plugs. The Problems with Nutrition Science I know you...
BadHare profile image

How much fat do we actually need?

There are some on this forum who think they need to eat a high-fat diet. There are others, like...
andyswarbs profile image

Any advise on my diet change? Salad everyday at dinner

Hi everyone, just joined. I started changing my diet lately. I'm trying to eat more nutrients that...
LuisRA profile image

Why do people fail on a vegan diet?

It is my opinion that a vegan diet is the most natural and beneficial diet for the human body. I...
andyswarbs profile image

Moderation team

See all
Activity2004 profile image
Activity2004Administrator
Kitten-whiskers profile image
Kitten-whiskersAdministrator
Cooper27 profile image
Cooper27Administrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.