Vegan Advice.: Now, before I continue, once... - Diabetes India

Diabetes India

61,843 members12,096 posts

Vegan Advice.

MikePollard profile image
30 Replies

Now, before I continue, once again I will state that I have no objection whatsoever for folk espousing a vegan or vegetarian lifestyle for ethical reasons. However, it’s a stretch too far to suggest that it’s the optimal model of nutrition for human beings who are omnivores:

‘…an animal or person that eats a variety of food of both plant and animal origin’.

Why? You have a tough road to travel if you seek optimal nutrition. Don't take my word for it, here’s why:

vespapower.com/ofm/ofm-pyra...

Surely a site selling nutritional supplements and offering advice and warnings is a heads up, however I suspect prejudice and clinging to an ideal no matter what evidence is presented will make not a jot of difference.

Remember my take is to return to the diet of our ancestors who lived normal lifespans largely free of diabetes, Alzheimer's, cancer and heart disease. It’s a diet that the ANCESTORS of today's vegans thrived on and on whose shoulders they stand!

Written by
MikePollard profile image
MikePollard
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
30 Replies

even vegetarians were also diabetes free .Diet is not sole factor for getting diabetes.

Eating non veg in the most peaceful way ?

Vegetarian food is also nutritious and so many vegetarians live long and healthy. However, with heavy usage of chemicals, nutritious vegetarian diet may be difficult or a bit expensive. For lower income people doing physical work meat and fish help. Those who are vegans need not be argued with, but need not be obeyed blindly. Eggs and milk from ethically reared chicken and cattle are necessary for the economy and nutrition.

MikePollard profile image
MikePollard in reply to

B12

I think that we are all off tangent

The link shows the nutritional deficiencies we may face being a vegetarian or a vegan

It's not an issue if anything causing diabetes

Mike has posted this link with the intention that the deficiencies are understood and taken care

Maybe also indicating that we were omnivores

My belief is that we have opted for being a vegetarian by our ancestors. This is in some case and not in all cases.

Hence to take care of the deficiency foods like milk, ghee, butter, paneer etc are recommended for intake of B12 which other wise will be difficult

Now taking B12 thru an artificial means like tabs, capsules, sublingual or injection is not really designed for in the ancient times.

Vegan is a relatively newer concept which may face these deficiencies

I am a vegetarian and I now started taking eggs as well as fish oil caps to cover the deficiencies.

I would like to make it clear that my statement is not intended to show how diabetes is controlled or not controlled. Making it clear before someone starts shouting on these concepts controlling diabetes.

I AM NOT MAKING ANY COMMENT ON DIABETES CONTROL BUT ONLY ON THE DEFICIENCIES!

As usual my post is not being read properly

I mentioned that vegans have to take supplements

Not challenged the diet

It appears we need more fats for understanding

Vegetarian diet is a deficient diet

Infact many drs rx B12 to all diabetics who are vegetarian

For vegan It's even more critical

Anup

Please explain to someone here that we are vegetarian who take milk and hence less deficient in B12 compared to vegans who are totally deficient

I have many times pointed out that our ancestors were smart and advised us to take milk, ghee, butter, paneer to overcome B12 and omega3 deficiency

Vegan is a newer western concept which puts the people under total B12 and omega3 deficiency

I have been pointing out this for a long time

But some are unwilling to understand and keep putting counter arguments

Not the same is theory of jainsim is being put forward to me which I have many times pointed out in many threads

Life is a paradox

@ anup

cure profile image
cureAdministrator

Hey Hidden what is true/optimum level of B12??? Who fixed it??? what was the basis for the same????

As there is lot of ambiguity in Vit D level....

cure profile image
cureAdministrator

You know what?? Hidden we in India have natural sunlight thru out year...for body to make sufficient quantity of Vit d just 15/20 mts of skin exposure to sun is required....

And still.....all over India there is vit D deficiency....

Almost all Indian have Vit level below 40....

The present level is fixed as per study made on white Caucasian population.

naturally we may have some different level....No one knows what is optimum level for Indians....

Same thing may be applicable to B 12????

cure profile image
cureAdministrator

hmmm just do some google search on optimum vit d level....

U will get info.....

cure profile image
cureAdministrator in reply to cure

Hidden this is applicable in many fields.... what we read and follow is applicable and based on studies done on western population...

Even as per studies done...Indian population shows more plasma concentration of statin at very low dose.

The gist of the above link:

Omnivores does not need supplements

Vegetarians may need supplements

Vegans has to have supplements

MikePollard profile image
MikePollard in reply to

Absolutely on the money - well observed Shashikantiyengar. Your intelligent concise summary does you credit!

MikePollard profile image
MikePollard

Rats!

MikePollard profile image
MikePollard

Say what?

MikePollard profile image
MikePollard

They supplement!

MikePollard profile image
MikePollard

They don't need to -they are omnivores!

MikePollard profile image
MikePollard

B12?

MikePollard profile image
MikePollard

Again, if you take ANY animal product, you are unlikely to be deficient in B12

MikePollard profile image
MikePollard

Stand in the sun for 20 minutes - all the vit D you need. Not out in the sun - eat fish!

ShooterGeorge profile image
ShooterGeorge

In my humble opinion nobody can be vegetarian and be alive, then where is the case of being a vegan & be alive?

Do the vegetarians clean the vegetables and leaves externally and internally to the extent of ensuring that there are no micro or mini creatures/organisms are remaining there?

Do the vegetarians filter the water they drink or use for coffee/tea/cooking to ensure that it is free of any mini/micro organisms that come under animal (nonplant) class?

Do the vegetarians filter the air they inhale to ensure that it is free of any mini/mocro ... ...

If the answer to any of these three questions is in the negative, they are not vegetarians, leave alone being a vegan!!! Their intake contains living or dead stuff of nonplant class or category.

MikePollard profile image
MikePollard in reply to ShooterGeorge

A little confused George, nevertheless cogent!

We are all trying to defend our stand

But cannot deny that our ancestors were omnivorous

We keep fighting between ourselves on the issue of diet

Just as others keep fighting on religion

We just have to go back to our roots and think

There is no need to change your diet but only to bring about a realisation -What we were then and What we are now...

cure profile image
cureAdministrator

recently been to Matheran....a nice place near Mumbai....In jungles of Matheran we find two type of monkeys...Red faced and black faced....

It was interesting fact told by native that Black faced monkeys are vegetarian...and red face monkeys eat anything....

So just googled.....here is some info.....

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gray_...

Gray langur means black faced...

The link says....

Gray langurs are primarily herbivores. However, unlike some other colobines they do not depend on leaves and leaf buds of herbs, but will also eat coniferous needles and cones, fruits and fruit buds, evergreen petioles, shoots and roots, seeds, grass, bamboo, fern rhizomes, mosses, and lichens. Leaves of trees and shrubs rank at the top of preferred food, followed by herbs and grasses. Non-plant material consumed include spider webs, termite mounds and insect larvae.[22] They forage on agricultural crops and other human foods, and even accept handouts.[23] Although they occasionally drink, langurs get most of their water from the moisture in their food.[24]

in reply to cure

These so called herbivores actually produce SCFA in their system

These non digestible carbs for us are actually broken down by bacteria to SCFA in their GI system or colon for these herbivores

So the living organisms just cannot live without fats..

We have to take endogenously or produce in endogenously

We see these effects when we take Resistance starch..

cure profile image
cureAdministrator in reply to

Yes natural instinct of grey langoors forced them to consume insect larvae for additional supplement to vegetarian diet.

in reply to cure

For B12?

cure profile image
cureAdministrator in reply to

Guess yes....and many other nutrients....we really don't know what other nutrients they are deficient of .....

But seems this is natural instinct....

Do u know about yartsa gunbu....???Ophiocordyceps sinensis?? it is sort of Himalyan worm....in Chinese medicine it is considered as wonder drug.....

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ophio...

they say it is very nutritious......

It is nothing but some sort of larvae ...

MikePollard profile image
MikePollard

youtube.com/watch?v=RQq93Q2...

You may also like...

Strict Vegan diet followers - what is your experience in reversing type 2 diabetes.

seek if anybody has personal experience from vegan diet in reversing type 2. I have been following...

Vegetable/meat based Diet?

with being vegetarian or vegan for ethical reasons, but it is not an argument for optimal health:...

Pls advice on Diabetes meds.

poor quality of advice

Advice needed for diabetes