Milk thistle : Hi has anyone had good... - British Liver Trust

British Liver Trust

38,082 members18,674 posts

Milk thistle

Amberc14 profile image
11 Replies

Hi has anyone had good reviews with milk thistle have Ast gone down with anyone

Written by
Amberc14 profile image
Amberc14
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
11 Replies
Ph1ldad profile image
Ph1ldad

I used this for twelve months after being diagnosed with hep C and cirrhosis. It had no effect on either the condition of the liver, the blood results or symptoms. I decided that this was another "magic" cure put out by the herbal groups who believe in witchcraft or making money at the expense of us worried, gullible ill folk who would grasp any atraw to help lengthen their lives.

janey_babs profile image
janey_babs

My specialist told me there was no scientific evidence to say it improves anything. Ask your specialist if it will do any harm.....if not then it's your choice if you want to give it a bash. I'm a firm believer that sometimes these things help even if it just settles your mind.

Amberc14 profile image
Amberc14

I've been drinking it and my Ast has come down slowly I'm hoping it come down more just wondering if anyone has good things to say about it

briccolone profile image
briccolone

as others say there's no scientific evidence it helps but I can tell you that in Italy milk thistle is heavily prescribed by the medical community not just quack groups for liver related conditions as is a a diet rich in artichokes. I've used it a lot myself-difficult to say if there's been any improvement?

Amberc14 profile image
Amberc14

I'm hoping when I have more bloods my Ast goes down again it was a doctor in Canada that told he gives it to his patients with liver problems

Amberc14 profile image
Amberc14

You've just been tested for hepatitis to rule it out. My doctor said it's very unlikely I have it as only my Ast is raised has been for a while but hasn't raised above 40 and now it's 38 so I think milk thistle is helping...... Anyone with hepatitis does only Ast raise or would others be raised

LyndaLynda profile image
LyndaLynda

The Milk Thistle question is frequently raised. The opinion of hepatoligists in the UK seems to be - it won't do you any good but it won't do you any harm, you can take it if you want. So personally I believe that if the doctors have nothing to do for your liver disease that can help you you might just as well try it. Buy it from a reliable source. It is widely used in some European countries. Hepatologist in the UK don't like 'alternative therapies', because the content of the pills is not regulated in the same way as prescription drugs, so there may be substances in them that can harm the liver. They would never agree with you taking Chinese Medicine.

Amberc14 profile image
Amberc14

I'm drinking the milk thistle detox tea. By doctor s...... My Ast wasn't going down before but I've been drinking it and within a couple week went from 39 to 38 so will see what's happend next week

Caramberman profile image
Caramberman

Milk Thistle is reportedly used for detoxification of the liver, so it aids the natural "cleansing" process which is always fighting against bad diets, over-eating, over drinking and lack of exercise and that is assuming we have no other illness. AST is a liver enzyme and as liver cells naturally die they go in the blood stream and break up AST is released. If you have high AST then it is likely your liver cells are dieing at a faster rate. Basically, you should check with your doctor, but I would say Milk Thistle is only one thing that can help but it cannot be effective on its own. You cannot drink alcohol and at the end of the day take Milk Thistle and say "OK I am good" Take Milk Thistle but also work on diet, level of alcohol and definitely do exercise. Again I am assuming you do not have hepititus or another illness.

in reply toCaramberman

Agreed, lifestyle change with support with milk thistle is effective

Amberc14 profile image
Amberc14

I'm not sure sure what's caused it or why it's going going down slowly I I do eat lots of takeaways sweets and chocolate... I've stopped drinking wasn't wasn't drinking much before I don't don't no much much about Ast but my liver Ast is suppose suppose be 30..... It's 40.. 39....38 so so slowly going down my other liver tests are fine.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Milk thistle

Anyone else taking milk thistle? I have taken it daily since being diagnosed with cirrhosis 3yrs...
C1JAM profile image

Milk thistle

Does anyone have experience with Milk Thistle suppliment? Did it work for your liver? Can it harm...

Milk thistle

Good morning, I was just wondering if anyone has tried milk thistle to try and improve cirrhosis of...

Milk Thistle

Is this supplement worth a try? I’ve got a fatty liver and fibrosis - does it help prevent further...

Does Milk thistle help?

I've never taken any herbal remedies.. Just wondering if anyone on here does? Does it help?
Estiebargle profile image

Moderation team

See all

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.