Can you take AA for too long? - Bone Health and O...

Bone Health and Osteoporosis UK

5,979 members2,641 posts

Can you take AA for too long?

WaryMary profile image
6 Replies

I will soon be 92 (DV) and have been taking Fossamax (monosdium alendronate trihydrate) since early 1990s. Is it bad to be on Alendronates too long? I ask this question now because yesterday BBC R4 Science Review programme was about new advanced scanning technology revealing micro-cracks and moleclar breakdown in bones of Alendronate users, which are not revealed in convention DEXA bone density scans. Their concern is about the structural strength and integrity of the old bone that accumulates in enhanced proportion due to the action of alendronate.

I believe the research is credible (team of12 researchers from 8 countries working together) and is ongoing. They are not prescribing any action at this stage other caution. Obviously this makes me all the more anxious to have my question answered about how long to take Alendronate.

Written by
WaryMary profile image
WaryMary
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...

The ability to reply to this post has been turned off.

6 Replies
Nadine99 profile image
Nadine99

My husband is now on a BioPhosphenate 'holiday'. He was told that he shouldn't take it for more than a 5 year period. How long he stays off them for is as yet unknown.

SarahMWolf profile image
SarahMWolf

Hello and thanks for your question. It might be worth giving our specialist nurse team a call (it's a free number 0808 800 0035) to talk about this.

Kaarina profile image
Kaarina

Hi WaryMary

I thought one should take a holiday from AA after 3 - 5 years. Unfortunately my mum was on AA for years and it was never suggested to her to do this. Our generation appear to be guinea pigs until more research is done regarding the medications we are prescribed.

I chose not to take AA.

As has been suggested call the helpline and speak with one of the nurses.

HeronNS profile image
HeronNS

Yes call the helpline. But it may help your decision whether or not to continue to know that apparently bisphosphonates are LESS effective in those over 80 than in younger patients. The effects of previous bisphosphonate medication remain indefinitely. At this point you may well do better by making sure your nutrition and supplements are top notch for bone building elements and vitamins, and you get what weightbearing exercise you can - even a little extra walking will help if this is possible.

in reply to HeronNS

I was told by my Rheumatologist that he thinks two years of Fosavance is quite enough and have a yogurt drink a day and walk.

Kaarina profile image
Kaarina in reply to

Hi Susuki,

Does your rheumatologist mean that after two years there is no need to ever have AA again? He makes OP sound so easy to turn around! ;)

Did he mention anything about getting Vit D levels tested and taking Vit D daily?

The ability to reply to this post has been turned off.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

question about prolia side effects

Hi! I am new here. Actually just found this site today. I am 78 years old and have been taking...

Just joined

In November 2016 after a Bone density scan I was diagnosed as Osteopenic. My doctor prescribed...

I asked ChatGPT about Fosamax. How does the medication Fosamax fake your DEXA score?

This was the reply. Fosamax (alendronate) is a bisphosphonate medication used to treat and...

Low intensity vibration devices.

Would like some input on these machines, which are about the size of bathroom scales and are used...

How long should I stay on AA

I have been taking Alendronic Acid with no problems at all for 2.5 years. How long should one...