Ventolin inhaler -v- salbutamol gener... - Asthma Community ...

Asthma Community Forum

22,474 members24,860 posts

Ventolin inhaler -v- salbutamol generic inhaler

Eibhlinn profile image
15 Replies

I feel better with the genuine ventolin inhaler rather than the generic one. Does anyone else have any advice on this?

Written by
Eibhlinn profile image
Eibhlinn
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
15 Replies
EmmaF91 profile image
EmmaF91Community Ambassador

It happens. I’m the same. I can only use the branded CFC inhaler. Can’t do CFC free, can’t do generic. I just told my docs that I don’t get on with it (less effective, more side effects) so they order me branded. I also have the DPI version.

Hope this helps. At least you know it’s not just you (it’s actually relatively common... 😅)

Eibhlinn profile image
Eibhlinn in reply toEmmaF91

Thank you for your reply. I thought it was just me... but this generic one doesn’t seem to help my asthma and it tastes horrible and gives me a sore throat. Spoke to pharmacist and she “told” me that was the only one they ever gave out and it was ventolin by a different name. I knew the first one I had was the genuine ventolin one, but that had been from a different pharmacy. The generic one is much smaller....

I am going to speak to my doctor on Tuesday to see if she will just prescribe “ventolin only “

EmmaF91 profile image
EmmaF91Community Ambassador in reply toEibhlinn

Most pharmacies give out unbranded unless it’s otherwise stated because it’s cheaper. Speak to your GP, get it stated on your script and the pharmacy will get it for you. Good luck

Wintersbite profile image
Wintersbite in reply toEibhlinn

Hi yes thay can just prescribe ventolin or ventolin evohalours only as that is exactly what I am issued as I am allergic to the other blue one it actually causes me to have asthma attacks within minutes of taking it the ventolin is the only inhaler I take as I'm also allergic to the proventers same thing happens just tell your doctor there's something in it and you are reacting to it and could it be put on your notes that the only one you don't react to is ventolin ( evohalours) and yes you need that brand you can't explain it and yes you know it's the most costly one

SofaJockey profile image
SofaJockey

I find the pump in the Ventolin so much more effective than the generic. I get real Ventolins supplied to me because of that.

ReedB profile image
ReedB

I always found salbutamol was more effective for me, rather than ventolin, despite people telling me it was the same thing! Good to know it's not just me who has a preference 😊

Babbela profile image
Babbela

I'm the same only the the branded ventolin works better for me. I have tried genetic it hasn't the same effect, could be wrong I think its not strong enough for me .

westie22 profile image
westie22

Hi, I am the same. Several years ago I was changed to the generic brand and my asthma control dived. My practice asthma nurse specialist measured my peak flow, then gave me Ventolin proper, asked me to wait for 20 minutes, measured again and threw the generic inhaler into the bucket. Please, get in touch with your practice - doctor or asthma specialist and say what your finding. It isn't unusual. Good luck!

Bathtimebliss profile image
Bathtimebliss

I had the exact same problem. The generic one tasted of flowers which considering that's one of my allergies wasn't good lol and also gave me a sore throat! Ive also had other generic meds for my asthma which were ok it was just the ventolin. I have a very understanding gp practice and they changed it back to branded Ventolin which is on my prescription. Good luck x

Biggie_McDick profile image
Biggie_McDick

My mother had severe asthma which only responded to Ventolin. It took a couple of emergency visits for nebuliser treatment before her doctors eventually agreed and prescribed Ventolin. This was around 30 years or more ago, before it was realised that there was a difference.

My own asthma is mild but responds better to Ventolin than Salbutamol so I only get Ventolin nowadays.

Here’s a link to the Summary of Product Characteristics for both a generic inhaler and a Ventolin

medicines.org.uk/emc/produc...

medicines.org.uk/emc/produc...

If you scroll down to section 6 you’ll see the excipients are different. (Excipients are things added to a drug eg to keep it stable etc. For inhalers, it’s the propellant.) So, yes the drug is the same but the additive which activates it is different. I’m the same, if I have a generic inhaler I just end up using twice as much

R1100S1 profile image
R1100S1

No never noticed differences in effect!

Gilly100 profile image
Gilly100

Hi I found the generic ones useless. Doctor told me years ago that the particles in ventolin are much smaller and can get further into the lungs. Don't know whether that is still the case. I get mine from Boots as was told a long time ago that they have a relationship with the makers. Even though it says salbutamol on my prescription I always am given ventolin. Worth checking.

Elspe profile image
Elspe

Yes! I was told I had to ask my Dr to change the actual name on the prescription repeat forms to Ventolin, otherwise the pharmacy automatically substituted a "generic". The generic has a different propellant, AFAICS. It certainly doesn't suit me, I felt much better when ONLY using Ventolin.

Graham62a profile image
Graham62a

Hello

I totally agree with you, they try to save money, but the effect of the generic one (in my opinion) was 50% less effective, only used them for a day when I called directors and asked for ventolin only!

Always check my repeat prescription before ticking the box.

Regards

Graham

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

salbutamol vs ventolin

What do you think ? I have bean on ventolin for a long time did my repeat but had to see the gp...

Salbutamol/ventolin asthma

I think doses/puffs can be confusing as it depends on what strength we are discussing Ventolin...

Salbutamol Inhaler

Hi. Just looking for some advice regarding my daughter. She is 5 and using montelukast, flixotide...
Collyer16 profile image

Ventolin Inhaler

I notice a lot of talk re ventolin inhaler. I have had a very bad chest infection christmas/new...

Salbutamol/Ventolin use

Good morning all, I hope everyone is well. I recently replied to a post about this subject but...
ALUK_Nurses profile image
Partner

Moderation team

See all
Homely2 profile image
Homely2Administrator
Lysistrata profile image
LysistrataAdministrator
ALUK_Nurses profile image
ALUK_NursesAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.