Is it ok to have soya based protein s... - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

22,372 members28,136 posts

Is it ok to have soya based protein shakes daily ?

Tinkudi profile image
17 Replies

I have been giving dad whey protein shake but I want to add the amount of protein so was thinking of adding a non dairy source such as soya protein or pea protein.

Is it alright to take a soya based protein shake or other soya and tofu products on a regular basis ?

Written by
Tinkudi profile image
Tinkudi
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
17 Replies
Hobierat profile image
Hobierat

I think your dad is around my age and i have been doing protein (amino acid) supplements for at least five years. When I stopped eating meat I felt I needed to add more protein especially on days I workout at the gym or trail. each serving consists of Whey protein isolate25g is my main protein, my plant based protein powder Orgain brand ingredients are made up of pea protein, acacia, brown rice, mung bean and chia seeds 21g I also do PB (peanut butter) consists of peanut flour, and coconut palm. 8g. I frequently add the PB to my whole grain cereal and cultured lowfat milk breakfast meal.

Do you add additional protein to your own diet? If you don't mind me asking are you the son or daughter?

I had my muscle estimate calculated at my gym recently and the trainer said I was approximately 34%, I think he said that was above average for an old man so I'm guessing it works. I also added creatine because it was said us older folks lack these three amino acids found in your muscles. I just last month started taking another amino acid HMB which is supposed to prevent muscle breakdown while supporting recovery.

I think you understand that question you just asked about protein is going to get 50-100 opinions, and that's all they are opinions. I suggest you start slow and see what works .

Tinkudi profile image
Tinkudi in reply toHobierat

hello 😊

Yes dad is 83 so around your age.

I have been giving him whey protein but thought of giving some more in the form of plant protein rather than adding more dairy protein. I want to try and avoid his LDL cholesterol from going up as as per Dr Myers , that can be used to make dht testosterone when ADT depletes the T. As of now he gets around 40’gm protein a day. His weight is around 75 kilos.

I am the son.

Why do you add peanut butter ?

My best wishes for you 😊

Hobierat profile image
Hobierat in reply toTinkudi

Peanuts are legumes, rich in protein. The butter might be just a Reference to consistency for spreading. We buy roasted peanuts a grind them at the store, turns them into “peanut butter”. Check it out nutritional snack food also. It’s 6am here and I’m on my way to the gym , join me!

Tinkudi profile image
Tinkudi in reply toHobierat

You are an inspiration gymming at this age 😊

I am a little lazy to do that at 6 am 😄

mrscruffy profile image
mrscruffy

I add dried peanut butter, BCCA's (enzymes) dried bone broth, collagen and Creatine amongst other things

Anthonyve profile image
Anthonyve

Soy milk and tofu are excellent sources of protein and actually help with. Prostate cancer.

Here is a look at a study , that you might find helpful.

I’ll mention that Dr Greger has an odd way of communicating, but his scientific credentials are impeccable.

All the best.

Cheers, Anthony

nutritionfacts.org/video/th...

Tinkudi profile image
Tinkudi in reply toAnthonyve

Thanks 😊

Sagewiz profile image
Sagewiz

My look into Soy showed a double-edged sword. It seems at earlier stages it can be beneficial and later it can become harmful. I would access some studies before implementing too much on a regular basis. I eat edamame when I can, but do not make it a huge part of my diet.

Tinkudi profile image
Tinkudi in reply toSagewiz

Yes. It’s confusing with metastatic disease.

NewPotatoCaboose profile image
NewPotatoCaboose

I prefer hemp protein powder

podsart profile image
podsart

there is a question whether soy can raise your estrogen level beyond a desirable level for Pca

Sagewiz profile image
Sagewiz in reply topodsart

correct. Studies have shown both ways, but the conservative consensus is it is beneficial at the beginning stages and becomes more detrimental as it advances. I wouldn't go crazy with consumption levels, but small amounts from fod sources only in early stages is worth a try. themossreport.com

podsart profile image
podsart in reply toSagewiz

Good luck

carguy profile image
carguy

Hello,

After 6 years of ADT treatment and eating mostly a plant-based diet, my muscle mass decreased considerably and I started to pull muscles easily. I started to drink whey protein drinks (puori protein powder) and a scoop of collagen peptides every day. I was always afraid that the whey protein may increase my PSA, but it hasn’t. Plant-based protein powders are good but many contain heavy metals and pesticides. For that reason, I went with the whey protein. Puori is part of the clean label project, and tests each batch for contaminants. Along with weight-bearing exercise, my muscle mass has improved and I injure myself less frequently. Good luck to you.

Tinkudi profile image
Tinkudi in reply tocarguy

thanks. What do collagen peptides help in ?

carguy profile image
carguy in reply toTinkudi

It helps strengthen joints, ligaments etc. It is a protein containing amino acids.

swwags profile image
swwags

I use pea protien. Her's an article fro TA on protein:

prostatecancer.news/2024/05...

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Trace protein in urine ? Could it be due to adding metformin or Xtandi or protein shake ?

Dad’s routine urine report showed “ trace protein “. He has never had this show up earlier ?...
Tinkudi profile image

Better to take whey protein or plant protein ?

Deciding to add a protein shake to my diet since I am on orgovyx. Some posts mention plant based...
Simpson80 profile image

ADT and daily carb intake for weight training

Because of ADT I have been on a strict diet. I do not consume any flour, or sugar. Of course, I...

Coq10/Ubiquinol- is it ok or not ok to take ?

Dad takes coq10 as he also takes low dose statin since many years. I read someone on this Board...
Tinkudi profile image

Is soya milk advisable for APC,?

TA posted last week that 'cow juice' is safe to drink, so allow it in Tea, coffee. I switched my...
16starsky profile image

Moderation team

Bethishere profile image
BethishereAdministrator
Number6 profile image
Number6Administrator
Darryl profile image
DarrylPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.