Nubeqa vs Abiraterone for post Doceta... - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

22,367 members28,133 posts

Nubeqa vs Abiraterone for post Docetaxel maintenance?

TMcgee profile image
22 Replies

Thanks to the many on this board that offered suggestions I will soon complete a slightly modified triple therapy of ADT+ABI+Docetaxel. My challenges with side effects included eliminating Tylenol and reducing ABI for one cycle; and then, switching from 1000mg ABI on empty stomach to 250mg ABI+ 10mg Prednisone with low fat breakfast. The end result was PSA dropped to .55 and liver enzymes returned to normal range. The only snafu is a CT scan for breathing issues showed more bone Lesions (2 lesions found during bone scan). Thus, there is a possibility that my diagnosis changed fro low to high volume during the period between initial scan and treatment.

Now, my questions: First, I have read extensively about Nubeqa and it seems to be the better alternative for maintenance after Docetaxel. Outside of the cost issue, is there any reason not to switch from ABI to Nubeqa?

Second, what should be my next steps after triple therapy? Outside of the liver enzymes issue and a breathing issue that went undiagnosed, I was able to continue daily workouts, lost 12 pounds, and seem to tolerate the treatment well. Suggestions?

BTW - thanks to everyone with their help and suggestions to date. Everyone here is awesome!

Written by
TMcgee profile image
TMcgee
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
22 Replies
Scout4answers profile image
Scout4answers

Can't really help with your specific problem but just wanted to say that Travis Mcgee was one of my favorite characters in all fiction of which I have read a lot (Current fav is Joe Pike by Caris) I have followed McDonald's advice and enjoyed an early retirement.

I am living the life of a seventeen year old as well. went to a Sam Cooke/ Ray Charles concert last night and danced in the aisle next to our seats. Not giving up sex that easily, although it is much different than when I was 17. ;-)

I did get high enzymes from Abi and reduced dose, now back at full strength and liver is normal. So maybe you can still get some mileage out of Abi.

TMcgee profile image
TMcgee in reply toScout4answers

Sorry, but Joe is nothing without Elvis. 🙃

Scout4answers profile image
Scout4answers in reply toTMcgee

Sounds like we have followed the same literary path, another favorite is Michael Connelly.

What are you reading currently?

TMcgee profile image
TMcgee in reply toScout4answers

Yes, we seem to have very similar literary interests. Recently, I have become a big fan of CJ Box’s Joe Pickett and Johnson’s Longmire. Both have a Joe Pike character. Candy for the mind during those days when life isn’t normal.

Scout4answers profile image
Scout4answers in reply toTMcgee

thanks I will check them out… literally as I get the books on cd at my library. I listen to them at bedtime and they put me to sleep by the 2nd or third chapter..

No greater luxury than somebody reading a story to you.

TMcgee profile image
TMcgee in reply toScout4answers

I am very lucky, my local library offers online audio and Kindle editions for 21 days at a time. It’s a life saver. BTW. In reading your profile, you are (or were) taking 250mg ABI with yogurt. Any issues?

treedown profile image
treedown

I am on Xtandi right now which is Nubeqa's older brother. I was on Abi my first go round. I prefer it because I don't want added steroids and it is easier to take since you don't have to worry about time of day or with food or splitting up the 2 drugs. I would have preferred Nubeqa as I understand it doesn't cross the brain blood barrier and that seems relevant to me whether any has been proven yet or not.

So far side effects have been about the same on both. I am also on Lupron 3 month shots.

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen

You reduced your dose of abi and got less side effects and less effectiveness- no surprise there.

There is no evidence that Nubeqa is better or worse than Zytiga.

This isn't triplet therapy, it's sequential, which is not as effective.

TMcgee profile image
TMcgee in reply toTall_Allen

TA. What is the difference between taking Lupron+ABI+ Docetaxel concurrently and triple therapy.? Also, why is 250mg of ABI with food less effective than 1000mg on an empty stomach? Isn’t the absorption 5x?

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply toTMcgee

"What is the difference between taking Lupron+ABI+ Docetaxel concurrently and triple therapy.?" I may have misunderstood. Triplet therapy is concurrent. I thought you were saying that you wanted to start Nubeqa for maintenance after docetaxel, which sounds like you are using it sequentially. But it is better to take an adequate dose of Nubeqa than the inadequate dose of abiraterone that you have been taking. If both doses are adequate, there is no known reason to prefer one to the other.

"Also, why is 250mg of ABI with food less effective than 1000mg on an empty stomach? Isn’t the absorption 5x?" The average absorption is 5X, but results vary widely among individuals. That's why, now that cost is no longer an issue, it is better to be certain of the biologically available dose you are getting. In your case, you obviously were not absorbing enough. Your first clue should have been the reduced side effects - side effects would not be reduced if you were absorbing the same amount of the drug.

TMcgee profile image
TMcgee in reply toTall_Allen

Thank you for the clarification.

TMcgee profile image
TMcgee in reply toTall_Allen

“In your case, you obviously were not absorbing enough. Your first clue should have been the reduced side effects - side effects would not be reduced if you were absorbing the same amount of the drug.”

I spoke at length with my MO about your statement. In a prior post, I alluded to overdosing on Tylenol daily and it being the cause of my elevated liver enzyme issue. Originally, MO dismissed my theory, but after tracing my enzyme numbers versus my changes in therapy, he agrees that Tylenol was the contributing factor.

Now, I have the issue of trying to figure out how much Abi is necessary. My MO wants me to stay on Abi and I want to take the drug in the morning with food for QOL reasons. According to the FDA label, I can add fat to my Yogurt to increase absorbency. So, how much absorbency is too much?

Currently, my PSA has dropped from .57, .55, .44 which is the only indicator that I have. I end my Docetaxel in 2 weeks; and then, I plan to decide if I should return to 4x250mg or stay with 250mg and add fat to improve absorption. How far over 1000mg is safe? I couldn’t find any trials where higher dosages were evaluated.

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply toTMcgee

"for QOL reasons" - What QOL reasons? If equal amounts are bioavailable, there are equal side effects. Only the dose that is actually absorbed contributes to side effects or efficacy.

Higher doses of 2000 mg were tried in the Phase 1 trials - it had no greater efficacy but more side effects.

TMcgee profile image
TMcgee in reply toTall_Allen

thank you!

Cooolone profile image
Cooolone

Well, we really never get to KNOW the bioavailability of any drug we are taking because they never test for that! Even when there is metabolic issues, absorbtion issues, etc., with oral medication. So we can regurgitate what studies have shown, but we will never truly know how much drug our body is getting. I've traveled this path with my MO at one of the leading PCa Cancer Hospitals in the country.

Very deep rabbit hole to venture down, the Maximum Tolerable Dosage as established by study, yes, by the drug companies that will sell you the drug vs the possible Minimum Effective Dosage that would achieve the same results... Biochemically as in regard to the individual!

And the Darolutamide is a 2nd generation inhibitor for a reason. If you can get your insurance to approve it, I believe it is worth it. Here's an indirect look between them:

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/338...

Showing the Daro to have less side effects...

Everyone is an individual for sure, so you never know. But if something is "better" and you're not burning a line of therapy, why not use it?

Just thoughts...

Good Luck and Best Regards

TMcgee profile image
TMcgee in reply toCooolone

fantastic info! Thank you

j-o-h-n profile image
j-o-h-n

After 15 years of Lupron and casodex my M.O. took me off casodex and replaced it with nubeq/a (/=no u). Been on it for a month and so far no side effects except I'm losing my sense of humor.

j-o-h-n <===<<< Senior management is about to spike my spikes....

Good Luck, Good Health and Good Humor.

j-o-h-n Saturday 04/22/2023 5:34 PM DST

TMcgee profile image
TMcgee in reply toj-o-h-n

Losing your humor would be a huge loss for this board.

Pops78 profile image
Pops78 in reply toj-o-h-n

Interested to know the results of Nubeqa vs the Casodex, after a few months?

j-o-h-n profile image
j-o-h-n in reply toPops78

To Pops78,

Began Nubeq/a (/ = no u) on 03/09/2023. Results so far:

P.S.A. 2.14% as of 02/20/2023

P.S.A. 1.24% as of 04/03/2023

Remember to ask me in a few months.....

Good Luck, Good Health and Good Humor.

j-o-h-n Friday 04/28/2023 10:59 AM DST

Pops78 profile image
Pops78 in reply toj-o-h-n

Impressive, thanks. Good luck!!! Will continue to follow if that's ok.

j-o-h-n profile image
j-o-h-n

Thanks Much C G

j-o-h-n <===<<< Senior management is about to spike my spikes....

Good Luck, Good Health and Good Humor.

j-o-h-n Saturday 04/22/2023 6:20 PM DST

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Abiraterone vs Docetaxel

In the CHAARTED trial, metastatic burden was divided into low burden (4 lesions). CHAARTED’s...
TMcgee profile image

Zytiga vs Nubeqa for Triple Therapy

Hi, I've recently received a diagnosis of Stage 4 prostate cancer, which is high volume and...
littleCar profile image

Abiraterone after Docetaxel for mCSPC?

It's been a while since I posted. I am 68 years old, otherwise healthy and now 14 months...
john205 profile image

Xtandi vs. Abiraterone vs. Nubeqa

So… my recurrence treatment plan consists of RT and ADT & Xtandi for 2 years. I’m still working...
shueswim profile image

Abiraterone / Docetaxel

New video from: "Christopher Sweeney, MBBS, physician, Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, compares...
pjoshea13 profile image

Moderation team

Bethishere profile image
BethishereAdministrator
Number6 profile image
Number6Administrator
Darryl profile image
DarrylPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.