Do we even need statins?: We know that... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

141,243 members166,489 posts

Do we even need statins?

Guineapiggy profile image
13 Replies

We know that uncontrolled hypothyroidism increases cholesterol so this needs to be attended to before starting any cholesterol-lowering medication suggested by the doctor. What is not suggested is that we don't need to lower it anyway. Cholesterol is needed by the body for a lot of processes and there is plenty of info available that lowering it is not beneficial. It is known that results of trials can be manipulated to show a desired outcome. There are many reports of statins causing negative health effects with no benefits.

Personally, I believe that they are a moneymaking con promoted by drug companies and I wouldn't consider taking them. Unfortunately, the medical profession seem to have been blinded by the "evidence".

These two videos are well worth watching so you can make up your own minds, especially if you are under pressure from a doctor to take them (hopefully the links work).

youtu.be/Iom8WRaejMc

youtu.be/T3ldcRYadR4

For the full Aseem Malhotra video see

youtu.be/CV-Qbbl_e6o

[ Link edited by admin to one that can work on this forum. ]

Written by
Guineapiggy profile image
Guineapiggy
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
13 Replies
Alanna012 profile image
Alanna012

Thanks for this!

My 67 year old mother has become unhealthily obsessed with her 'high' cholesterol. For many years her cholesterol levels were declared good, but it is now that she has severe osteoporosis (and a few decades past menopause) that it has become raised. Which I think makes sense, as she probably has more inflammation and you make your steroid hormones from your cholesterol. So I can't see the sense in telling her to reduce it.

But since she's been told that it's something to worry about, she has become obsessive about her diet and she has now cut out red meat, cut out dairy (she isn't using an alternative, just cutting it out) switched from butter to vegan spread, stopped drinking tea, given up all her favourite beverages, cut down on her portion sizes, stopped cooking with salt.

Now she is complaining that she feels tired. I don't think she is getting enough vitamins now, and ironically her blood pressure is now high. But she's old school in trusting positions of authority completely, so as far as she's concerned, the cholesterol needs to keep being lowered. If she is offered statins she would take them no questions asked. I just hope that's not what she's offered at her next hospital visit.

Guineapiggy profile image
Guineapiggy in reply toAlanna012

This is why the info we are fed is so dangerous. Looks like your mum has swapped everything good for something bad. Can you show her the Jimmy Dore video if the 3 hour one is too long?

Alanna012 profile image
Alanna012 in reply toGuineapiggy

Good suggestion I will try with the video. But I have tried speaking to her before, but she doesn't trust me over her GP/consultant. In her mind they of course know best on this issue.

The thing is I'm sure the doctor initially told her to cut down on all these foods, not eliminate them, but she's so anxious now she's just cut them all out completely; she got upset when I offered her a fried egg as I was making breakfast and when I offered to boil her one instead, she said they are really high in cholesterol so she literally refused to eat anything except the toast. I don't think that's healthy, so I thought I'd go along with her and told her to mention all these changes she was making the next time she went to the GP and ask about the eggs, thinking the GP will say, you really don't need to go this far. But when she came back she said the GP was pleased and commended her on the changes she's made!🤦🏾‍♀️

Guineapiggy profile image
Guineapiggy in reply toAlanna012

It's not easy. My husband is the same and thinks a GP knows everything. As we know, that certainly doesn't apply to us folks with an underactive thyroid and they only prescribe levo, only want to measure TSH and ignore free T3 levels!!

arTistapple profile image
arTistapple in reply toAlanna012

I have found it’s a waste of time talking otherwise to persons with this outlook. After you have supplied the sources of info and a brief explanation, they should be treated like adults and left to make up their own minds - especially if you know they are the type to follow GP advice without question.

That sounds very uppity I realise but it’s like many issues in life. Plus it’s not our responsibility. We hate it when doctors appear to be ‘wrong’. It’s really a similar process just the other way around.

Guineapiggy profile image
Guineapiggy

Another good one

youtu.be/2NelIuNXuY4?si=52v...

elaar profile image
elaar

" What is not suggested is that we don't need to lower it anyway. Cholesterol is needed by the body for a lot of processes and there is plenty of info available that lowering it is not beneficial."

I would disagree with this, it obviously depends how high it has reached though. Hypercholesterolemia is not a good thing to have. It has a cause, and that cause specifically needs to be identified and treated rather than doctors continuing their obsession with statins.

I think the confusion with cholesterol is that people are often told that cholesterol (LDL) has to be low as it's the "bad" one, when that's not the case. It certainly has to be kept from going very high though (untreated thyroid issues, diabetes, obesity etc..). But what exactly is too high is another question.

There's plenty of large unbiased scientific studies published online that show that high levels of LDL increase all-cause mortality, BUT the same seems to be true of low levels of LDL also.

I have a rule, no youtube videos/vloggers/bloggers/podcasts when researching this type of thing.

Guineapiggy profile image
Guineapiggy in reply toelaar

This wasn't aimed at people with hypercholesterolemia, but for the general population who are needlessly being prescribed them. Just as you said, high and low levels of LDL seem to be correlated with mortality therefore it is logical to assume that LDL is not the bad guy anyway. It is the manipulation of the data that uses relative risk versus absolute risk to demonstrate the effectiveness of statins and so persuade doctors to prescribe them. If the absolute risk is negligible then this is just a moneymaking machine for pharmaceutical companies.

Guineapiggy profile image
Guineapiggy

Here's another good one:diabetes.co.uk/news/2016/ju....

There is evidence that statins increase diabetes risk so doctor's are now being paid to prescribe them to type 1 diabetics!! There is a good bit at the bottom of the article saying that low cholesterol increases mortality in the elderly.

Sparklingsunshine profile image
Sparklingsunshine in reply toGuineapiggy

Its a bit like weight, we know being overweight or obese increases a myriad of diseases, heart disease, strokes, diabetes, even some cancers. And yet being underweight when you are elderly is associated with a higher mortality risk. It seems its better to carry a bit of excess weight the older you are. As ever these things are not black or white.

RedApple profile image
RedAppleAdministrator

Guineapiggy, you seem to be researching this quite a lot. Have you come across anything that acknowledges and/or discusses genetic variations that can cause some people to have naturally low or naturally high levels?

Guineapiggy profile image
Guineapiggy in reply toRedApple

I haven't looked that far into it. I guess there will be genetic variations as there are with everything but I haven't seen it mentioned in the the stuff I have read.

serenfach profile image
serenfach

The brain contains approximately 20–25% of the body's cholesterol. Growing evidence suggests that different statins are able to lower brain cholesterol synthesis, slowing the transmission of nerve impulses. At my age, I worry about going dolally on a regular basis, let alone allowing an outside chemical help the process! Now anyone see where I put my glasses?

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Taking statins does not commonly cause muscle pain, researchers say

The issue of statins causing muscle pain and /or damage has come to the fore - again. The...
helvella profile image
Administrator

Cholesterol, Hypothyroidism, Statins

The issue of elevated cholesterol in those with undiagnosed/under medicated hypothyroidism used to...

Hypothyroidism and Statins

I already know it’s not a good idea if you have hypothyroidism to go on cholesterol lowering...
Batty1 profile image

NHS to trial twice-yearly injection alternative to statins

Will be interesting to know if there has been, or will be, any mention of thyroid in relation to...
helvella profile image
Administrator

Cholesterol (just asking again. ..)

We are told how cholesterol is bad and it will kill us. We are told to go on a diet and avoid...
Justiina profile image

Moderation team

See all
SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator
Jaydee1507 profile image
Jaydee1507Administrator
RedApple profile image
RedAppleAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.