Alpha Lipoid Acid & Acetyl L Carnitine - Help! - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,878 members161,692 posts

Alpha Lipoid Acid & Acetyl L Carnitine - Help!

mids_thyman profile image
25 Replies

Hi everyone,

I have a dilemma - can you help me?

I have hypo-thyroidism which is treated with lexothyroxine.

I'm also a type-1 diabetic and just been diagnosed with peripheral neuropathy (although still being investigated), I've been put on duloxetine for pain, but am experiencing some not-very-pleasant side-effects and want to doctor to take me off them.

So am also looking at taking supplements that people have said that they've got great results with for neuropathy. The problem is some of these look like they might not good for hypothyroidism. Online, there is conflicting advice everywhere!

The two supplements that seem controversial are:

R-Alpha Lipoic Acid.

Acetyl L Carnitine

My questions are, do these 2 interact with hypothyroidism/levothyroxine? And if so is there a way around it or a way to take them alongside levothyroxine? Could timing make it work?

Thanks in advance,

JP619.

Written by
mids_thyman profile image
mids_thyman
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
25 Replies
Regenallotment profile image
Regenallotment

how is your B12 Ferritin and Folate? If these are low for me I get numbness and tingling. I’ve had all the electric shock tests on my arms and they are 100% certain not nerves. Just a thought. I changed from Thorne Basic B to Igennus a few months ago it came back, it used to come back the week of stopping B Complex for blood tests, SD advised separate B12 and folate those days, that has helped. It’s definitely the Thorne Basic B that helps me. But it takes a few weeks to sort it.

I tried L Carnitine but didn’t notice any difference when I stopped.

I don’t know the other one, I also don’t have experience of type 1 diabetes. That sounds like an added challenge and the little I do know means neuropathy in extremities is a worry.

So just a thought maybe you have been super excellent and mainting your sugars and are low on the Bs?

Hope you find your answers easily 🌱🦋🌱

humanbean profile image
humanbean

Low OR high levels of vitamin B6 can cause neuropathy :

Deficiency : en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitam...

Toxicity : en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Megav...

Years ago, long before I started researching, testing and treating thyroid hormones and related vitamins, I had a lot of symptoms of having low levels of B vitamins. I took a daily dose of a poor quality B Complex which had very high levels of every B vitamin in it. The supplement helped and my peripheral neuropathy went away. I continued taking it, then after a few months my neuropathy started to come back again. I researched and found out that vitamin B6 was the only ingredient in the B Complex I was taking that had any common toxicity symptoms. I stopped the B Complex and the neuropathy went away. I have never taken a B Complex with high B6 ever since, and so far my neuropathy hasn't come back.

mids_thyman profile image
mids_thyman in reply to humanbean

Thanks guys,

I've had various blood tests and everything has come back OK. It's confused me as my diabetic control has always been really good so not sure what's happening. My doctors are taking a "You are diabetic... so it's related to diabetes" approach (frustrating). I'm being sent for a nerve conductivity test, but not sure when it will happen yet.

In the meantime I'm looking at a range of supplements that I've found online to take as a combination, hence my original question about interactions with underachieve thyroid/levothyroxine:

R-alpha lipoic acid

Benfotiamine (Thiamine/Vit B1)

Pyridoxal-5-Phosphate (Vit B6)

Methylcobalomin (Vit B12)

Folate (Vit B9)

L-Citrulline

Acetyl-L-Carnitine

Jaydee1507 profile image
Jaydee1507Administrator in reply to mids_thyman

Have you had these levels tested? If so what were the results?

We need OPTIMAL levels of key vitamins for our thyroid hormone to work well.

humanbean profile image
humanbean

There is an interactions checker on this link :

drugs.com/drug_interactions...

Add one drug e.g. Levothyroxine, then add a second drug then click on "check interactions".

Or you can see a list of all the drugs that interact in some way with Levo :

drugs.com/drug-interactions...

Neither of the things you mentioned in your original post are mentioned in the list, but drugs.com is good for prescribed drugs, not so good on supplements.

.

A couple of good links on the two substances you mentioned :

selfhacked.com/blog/lipoic-...

selfhacked.com/blog/acetyl-...

The alpha lipoic acid link doesn't mention thyroid at all but does have a lot to say about blood sugar. Whether it would affect you is something you would have to check.

The acetyl l carnitine link suggests it could suppress thyroid hormones and that it might be helpful with hyperthyroidism. Anyone with hypothyroidism should give it a wide berth just for that.

.

Thiamine in several forms is considered a helpful supplement by a few sites.

Izabella Wentz mentions it - do a search on her website :

thyroidpharmacist.com/?s=th...

This is the best site I know of on the subject of thiamine - it has nearly 200 articles that mention it. You can poke around and see if any of them mention diabetes in the same articles.

hormonesmatter.com/

hormonesmatter.com/?s=thiamine

humanbean profile image
humanbean

If you decide to start taking B vitamins of any kind be aware that some forms of B vitamin are "inactive" i.e. the body has to convert it into another form to make use of it. It is always best to avoid those because people with thyroid disease are often not great at doing these conversions. It's much better to supplement the "active" versions which don't require conversion to be useful to the body.

jigsawhealth.com/blogs/news...

SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator

please add actual results and ranges for

TSH

Ft4

FT3

Vitamin D

Folate

B12

Ferritin

Both Thyroid antibodies

TPO

TG

How much Levothyroxine are you currently taking

What vitamin supplements are you currently taking

As type one diabetic this is autoimmune so it’s highly likely your hypothyroidism is autoimmune too

Have you had coeliac blood test

Or are you already on strictly gluten free diet

radd profile image
radd

mids_thyman,

I've had both and they were fine. I was high dose of ALA for months during chelation (amongst numerous other sups) after having amalgam removed.

I use combos now and these are regulars, albeit it in much smaller doses. Obviously take well away from thyroid meds.

Charlie-Farley profile image
Charlie-Farley

Hi Mids,

Are you sure your hypothyroidism is being optimally treated? Looking at the post 15 days ago you are only on 50ug of levo?

The reason I ask is so many GP's treat the lab work rather than the patient and think if they drop kick you in the range job done 😱. Please read my bio - I wrote it as a case study and explain many of the misconceptions Drs have about how to read blood tests etc. Profile and bio behind my face icon.

Have you had Hashimoto's confirmed?

Vitamin D doesn't have range but still looks low - always add ranges or the '< ' where applicable you get the '<' with antibodies tests for instance.

I would agree with Regenallotment because I had nerve conduction tests in arms (before diagnosis) and they could find nothing - symptoms went away when vitamins and levo were optimal for me for my body (not just drop-kicked into the range).

mids_thyman profile image
mids_thyman in reply to Charlie-Farley

Thanks Charlie-Farley & SlowDragon,

No, my hypothyroidism isn't treated optimally as far as I can work out. I'm pretty new to taking an interest in this. I haven't had the chance to see anyone since my last post, but from there the gist was that my although my levels were all in-range, FT3 and FT4 levels are fine, but my TSH is too high at 2.39. I have a phone appointment with my doctor tomorrow, and I'm going to try and convince him to up my Levo.

My thyroid levels were:

TSH level: Your result is 2.39 mu/L (normal range 0.27 - 4.2 mU/L)

FT3 level: Your result is 4.8 pmol/L (normal range 3.1 - 6.8 pmol/L)

FT4 level: Your result is 19.4 pmol/L (normal range 12 - 22 pmol/L)

Other results:

Haemoglobin: Your result is 144 g/L

Ferritin: Your result is 135 ug/L

TSAT: Your result is 44 %

Active B12: Your result is >300 pmol/L (Serum B12 was 476 pool/L when tested by the doctor, normal range 133-675)

Folate: Your result is 12.3 ug/L (Folate was 9 ug/L when tested by the doctor, RANGE 3.10-19.90)

Vitamin D: Your result is 51 nmol/L

I understand the B12 result is academic as I was supplementing, and it doesn't necessarily mean that my body is processing it in the gut. So I've switched to a sublingual spray a few days ago, just in case.

Charlie-Farley profile image
Charlie-Farley in reply to mids_thyman

I think it is imperitive to discuss symptoms in relation to tests - because if you don't they certainly won't. I think most Drs presume a blood test is there to save them from having to think about symptoms WRONG! When I was going through dose increases, I noted the alleviation of symptoms as dose increase kicked in and the symptoms returning as the dose increase benefits wore off and I needed the dose upping. I am pretty sure I discuss this in my bio (if not there should be a post). 😉👍

Maggie0652 profile image
Maggie0652

Duloxetine is a nightmare medication. It blocks both thyroid function and uptake of thyroid meds. I was on it for several months for neuropathic pain and it made me extremely ill.

I take low dose Naltexone (LDN) now for my pain and that’s working really well for me.

mids_thyman profile image
mids_thyman in reply to Maggie0652

Thanks Maggie. That's really interesting. I had no idea about an interaction with thyroid medication. Is that well recognised, or something you personally found (or both)?

Batty1 profile image
Batty1 in reply to mids_thyman

Duloxetine or Cymbalta is absolutely disaster with thyroid medications as mentioned above.

mids_thyman profile image
mids_thyman in reply to Batty1

Thanks Batty. I believe you all. I'm also a bit annoyed that doctors have put me on it as well. Are your comments based on personal experience, or is it generally accepted?

I checked on various drug interaction websites and found nothing. But I'm finding it increasingly complex working out which websites you can believe! The users on here seem much more knowledgable than elsewhere.

Batty1 profile image
Batty1 in reply to mids_thyman

Personal experience I took it a couple of years ago for my psoriatic arthritis and it messed up my thyroid levels even though I took it hours from my meds.

Maggie0652 profile image
Maggie0652 in reply to mids_thyman

It was both.

When I was taking it I found I was sleeping neatly all the time, just couldn’t keep my eyes open. Put loads of weight on. I felt like I was dragging myself through treacle when I was trying to walk. I had a thyroid test after 2 months and my TSH had shot up, t4 was rock bottom.

At the time (2012), the online PIL acknowledged that duloxetine affected thyroid function and medication uptake. I’ve been searching for it but can’t find it now. I did download it.

When I came off it, I had the most horrendous withdrawal symptoms that went on for over a year even though I only took the duloxetine for 3 months.

My thyroid med absorption recovered after a few months.

I’ll keep looking for the info and add the links if I can find them.

mids_thyman profile image
mids_thyman in reply to Maggie0652

Hi Maggie, Thanks, that's really interesting. My doctor has agreed to me stopping duloxetine, so that's what I'll be doing. Can I ask, what dose were you on before you stopped, and did you taper, and for how long? I'm trying very hard to avoid withdrawal symptoms.

HappyHealthyGirl profile image
HappyHealthyGirl in reply to mids_thyman

Hi mids_thyman ,

Just a quick note for if you decide to try LDN - it doesn't suit everyone - I felt seriously suicidal taking it, even a tiny dose, so I had to stop. Also, a friend independently felt the same way.

Obviously, it does work for some people, like Maggie0652 , so we all have to try things for ourselves. It sounds like you're pretty good at monitoring & taking things slowly, so just wanted to mention to look carefully at your mood if you do try it.

Hope everything's progressing well.....

😀

wellness1 profile image
wellness1 in reply to Maggie0652

Glad you found something that helps with pain. How long did it take for you to notice an improvement? (if you don't mind my asking :))

Maggie0652 profile image
Maggie0652 in reply to wellness1

probably about 6 months. I was already having 3-monthly capsaicin patch treatment which had maybe given me a 40-50% improvement in pain levels. Taking the LDN made a massive difference though it was gradual so it’s difficult really to pinpoint when it became obvious

Miffie profile image
Miffie

I am currently finding Imipramine working well for neuropathy which diagnosed some years back. I am also prescribed co codamol to boost if it’s really grim. I find this better than Pregabalin which I was on previously. Hope you get an accurate diagnosis and some relief soon.

ICE187 profile image
ICE187

I take ALA as well, but not within a couple of hours from my Levothyroxine. No issues when spacing it out for me.

Thyb profile image
Thyb

I thithink Alpha lipoic acid and taurine are great. Just take ALA a couple of hours away from levothyroxine 😊 I wish you well

You may also like...

Anyone tried acetyl-L-carnitine

concern that acetyl-L-carnitine might interfere with thyroid hormone. Don’t use acetyl-L-carnitine...

Acetyl L Carnitine and CDP Choline - Do they effect Thyroid?

I am 64 started taking Acetyl L Carnitine 250 mg x2 twice a day and CDP Choline 250 mg 2x a day....

L-Carnitine Supplementation may help with mental fatigue in Hypothyroid patients 

function or interactions to Levo. Today I found out that it seems that supplementing with...

L-carnitine

levothyroxine for Hypothyroidism and didn’t know if L-carnitine will interact with the levothyroxine

Alpha Lipoic Acid supplement

excited reading about this supplement as I suffer from peripheral neuropathy and it is getting...