Calcium and Magnesium Testing: I would like to to... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,717 members161,500 posts

Calcium and Magnesium Testing

Hannah13 profile image
4 Replies

I would like to to have my calcium and magnesium levels tested with Medichecks but I am unsure which calcium and magnesium test I would ask for? Which would be the most reliable one to go for? I would like a finger prick one if that is possible as don't have anywhere I could go to to get a vein one done.

Many thanks for any guidance

Written by
Hannah13 profile image
Hannah13
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
4 Replies
jimh111 profile image
jimh111

ionised calcium is a simple test your GP can do (if they are helpful). Magnesium blood tests are of little use they do not reflect intracellular levels. As regards magnesium the best test is to try supplementing and see how you go.

jimh111 profile image
jimh111

Like all these companies they are commercial. They do state 'Most of the magnesium in the body is found in the bones and inside the cells. Only a tiny amount of magnesium is normally present in the blood.' but fail to point out it is the intracellular levels that matter. They offer a 'red cell' (RBC) test which is a bit better but still only measures blood levels not intracellular. The gold standard is the 'magnesium loading test' where they give you magnesium and measure how much is absorbed. At home, just taking magnesium and seeing how you do is almost as good and much simpler.

Hannah13 profile image
Hannah13 in reply to jimh111

Thank you Jim - your info has been very helpful. I am now embarking on taking 300 mg of magnesium citrate per day to see how I go. How do you know if you have had too much?

jimh111 profile image
jimh111 in reply to Hannah13

That's handy because I've use magnesium citrate and so I'm familiar with it. I've taken up to 400 mg daily and it's OK. Take it in divided doses (twice daily?) and away from thyroid hormone, it can impair levothyroxine absorption.

The only time you should not take magnesium is if you have low blood pressure or impaired renal function (kidney disease). In these cases you should consult a doctor.

As your tissue levels of magnesium improve the body will reduce its absorption of magnesium from the gut. If you fail to absorb magnesium citrate it can act as a laxative. So, your toilet, clever little thing, will tell you if you are taking too much magnesium! Don't worry at the doses you are taking it would be a slow progression to softer stools, so you could back off early. It can take many months to restore magnesium levels so beware that a dose you can tolerate now may be a little too much in three months time.

The other issue about magnesium is that hypothyroidism causes lower intracellular magnesium levels, a 'shift from the intracellular to the extracellular space', so it's important to adequately treat hypothyroidism. On the other hand, hyperthyrodism or thyrotoxicosis leads to renal loss of magenesium. So, getting thyroid right is important.

(For those of you who are going to ask for the evidence: I've looked hard for relevant studies but can't find any good ones. I've taken the above information from Jean Durlach's out of print book 'Magnesium in Clincal Practice'. Prof Durlach is the leading expert on magnesium.)

You may also like...

Endo asking for calcium and magnesium blood tests

magnesium blood tests. I have read here that the magnesium test is not very accurate but leaving...

Optimum Calcium and Magnesium Supplements with Vitamin D

as hypothyroid) so need calcium but I understand calcium replacement can have adverse effects on...

Urine Calcium Test tips?

force testing of calcium properly. I can’t afford a £150 6 hour round trip London clinic test so...

Calcium and magnesium shouldn’t be taken at the same time as thyroid meds?

take calcium and magnesium at the same time as your thyroid meds and secondly calcium and magnesium...

What You Need to Know About Vitamin D3, K2, Calcium and Magnesium

co.uk/natural-remedies/vitamins/vitamin-d3-magnesium-calcium-vitamin-k2/ I didn't realise that K2...