Here's at least one piece of good news - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,824 members161,644 posts

Here's at least one piece of good news

vocalEK profile image
16 Replies

Being hypothyroid doesn't increase death (from all causes) if we get breast cancer. breast-cancer-research.biom...

Written by
vocalEK profile image
vocalEK
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
16 Replies
Caroline888 profile image
Caroline888

Thanks! Good news is always very welcome.

silverfox7 profile image
silverfox7

Would have liked to know whether they looked into iodine levels. After being diagnosed a few tearsago and already hypothyroid I came across lots of links re iodine. Many years after I was diagnosed with thyroid issues it had been suggested to me that mine could have been down to low iodine levels-I presented with a goitre and I don't have antibodies. Reading about breast cancer though and things connected I was reading that the breast is high in iodine and a suggestion that if low that could be an issue so have now upped my intake of foods that could help. Breast cancer is low apparently in Japan where I understand more iodine is in the diet.

Chippysue profile image
Chippysue in reply to silverfox7

Dr Edward Group talks about the link between iodine deficiency and breast cancer, and how iodine is needed in the body. Have a look on youtube. Of course many predict that most of us are deficient in iodine, selenium, magnesium. We only need to look at the increasing numbers of cancer, now 1 in 2.

silverfox7 profile image
silverfox7 in reply to Chippysue

Yes I've passed my finding back to the team that diagnosed me etc it's difficult one though as it's the scientists that do the research and they need funding but I feel we need to get the facts out there.

RockyPath profile image
RockyPath in reply to Chippysue

I had iodine, selenium, magnesium tested here in SE USA. My selenium was above range, I had plenty of iodine in my urine, and Mg was in the lower half of the range. Black beans and brown rice are great sources of selenium. Living on a pension, these are my staple foods. Black beans offer very complete nutrition.

Not presenting antibodies is inconclusive, as the standard tests catch about 90%, leaving a lot of us to slip past unnoticed. There are other antibodies produced but the testing isn't done often and probably costs lots more due to rarity.

in reply to RockyPath

You have to be careful with iodine though - too much can suppress thyroid levels! xxx

BirgitteG profile image
BirgitteG in reply to

How? Never heard about that! 8

in reply to BirgitteG

I didn't know either until reading it on here. Apparently iodine used to be used as a treatment for hyperthyroidism. I did a quick search and found this posted by helvella a couple of months ago:

healthunlocked.com/thyroidu...

BirgitteG profile image
BirgitteG in reply to

Thank you for the link.

It was your use of the word 'suppress' that confused me - I know about all the research showing the dangers of iodine. It's amazing that some researchers in that area apparently still haven't realized what a lot of other researchers have - that iodine is only dangerous to people that don't get enough selenium.

in reply to BirgitteG

I have no idea what the mechanism is that makes too much iodine have that effect, but used "Suppress" because couldn't think of another word to describe it.

Interesting the connection with selenium though. Do you have any more information about that, it sounds interesting?

BirgitteG profile image
BirgitteG in reply to

I'll come back to you 😊

BirgitteG profile image
BirgitteG in reply to

There's a fine explanation here:

livinglovecommunity.com/2017/06/20/iodine-selenium-and-hashimotos-a-balancing-act/

in reply to BirgitteG

Thanks x

vocalEK profile image
vocalEK in reply to RockyPath

When you mix black beans with salsa, you get a tasty dip. It's called Texas Caviar.

Well, we'd be less likely to get run over, fall down stairs or get struck by lightning if we are too exhausted to get out of bed. I'm always dubious about studies that cite an increase or reduction in all cause mortality

vocalEK profile image
vocalEK in reply to Angel_of_the_North

LOL. Good point!

You may also like...

Hey folks good news at last

My breast screening results have arrived at last. Wow ..at least I haven't got breast...

Can anyone recommend a good endo in Essex/London?

hypo. . I MUST sort this out soon, as the cancer in my breast, removed 5 weeks ago, has spread to...

Good news and \"Bad\" News

I sent the 2 Midgley papers and a presentation from a pro-t4/T3 Endo in the US , but anything...

Radiation for cancer other than thyroid.

Does radiation treatment for breast cancer affect thyroid medications? Does dose need to be...

Good news! Pathology results

grateful for what I have. Thank you so much for all your support and advice. Tamzin