Which B12: When I had my 23andme test last year... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

140,948 members166,084 posts

Which B12

Jefner profile image
7 Replies

When I had my 23andme test last year it came back that I was MTHFR etc., and my then FD said I needed to take Hydroxycobalmin, not the methyl that I was taking. My levels on my last blood test (in profile) arn't too bad so I cut down on taking every day.

When I had my OATS test done recently it says I have a high methylmalonic acid marker which is seen in poss vit B12 deficiency or defective absorption.

My now nutritionist says I need methyl and not hydroxy.

Confused.com - I have no idea what to take

Written by
Jefner profile image
Jefner
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
7 Replies
startagaingirl profile image
startagaingirl

Hi - you need methyl and not hydroxy because you can't convert hydroxy well.

Clutter profile image
Clutter

Jefner,

Apparently most people do have MTHFR mutations. healthunlocked.com/pasoc/po....

Pop over to PASoc for advice about high MMA and B12 deficiency. Hydroxycobalamin is only available in injections I think.

Jefner profile image
Jefner in reply toClutter

Clutter

Thanks hon, I have a bottle of hydroxy Swansons tabs that I had been taking for a whilst until she moved me onto these metabolics.com/b-complex-po.... She wants me on two a day now but little does she know I was only having half a capsule each day because I am sure something in them is a little too strong for me

radd profile image
radd

Jefner,

Many on this forum advocate 1000 pg/ml & supplement in tablets, sublingual (under the tongue) or liquid as Methylocobalamin.

Most MTHFR issues means you struggle to convert cyanocobalamin to hydroxocobalamin and then to adenosylcobalamin and methylcobalamin. …. BUT it depends on what other genetic mutations you have that influence these conversions and the effect it has on absorption and use of.

If you have had other genetic testing and trust your practitioner to interpret your results correctly, it may be that you need hydroxcobalamin in preference to methylcobalamin.

Be aware you will also need to take a B complex in addition to the B12 to keep a balance in the Vit B group..

Jefner profile image
Jefner in reply toradd

Thank you i already take a full complex with b12

Gambit62 profile image
Gambit62

Clutter , Jefner you can get hydroxo sublinguals and also nasal sprays.

some people with MTHFR variants don't respond well to methyl B12 and there are other genetic variants that may not respond well to methyl.

Jefner suggest that you take a look at and post on the PAS forum - link provided by Clutter above. If you have details of the last test you mention would be useful to provide those - particularly if you also have B12 levels.

Jefner profile image
Jefner in reply toGambit62

Gambit62

All my results on are on my profile hon. My B12 levels are up and down like a yoyo

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

I'm slightly concerned about high levels of B12.

In my latest blood test my B12 was 900pg/mL (191.0 - 663.0) I have read that it can be ok to have...
AnneEvo profile image

Which supplements?

Can you pls advise me on the best supplements to take for good overall support for autoimmune...
MissFG profile image

B complexes and b12 breaking me out?

I have been getting spots on my face, neck and shoulders for a few months now. I'm gluten free, I...
Smotv80 profile image

Monthly B12 injections

I have monthly B12 injections for the past 5 years, presuming it is to do with the fact that I have...
Margo profile image

B12 advice needed

Hi everyone. I posted a while back and you were all so helpful. I've taken a lot of advice from...
crabapple1 profile image

Moderation team

See all
PurpleNails profile image
PurpleNailsAdministrator
helvella profile image
helvellaAdministrator
SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.