Erfa reformulation???: Has Erfa really been... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

141,242 members166,488 posts

Erfa reformulation???

11 Replies

Has Erfa really been reformulated as well? I remember reading about a possible reformation on STTM a while ago, and then nothing...those of you on Erfa, have you noticed any difference as far as efficacy is concerned? Erfa Canada has denied any reformulation, as far as I know, but many users seem to think the pills just don't work the same anymore...any thoughts?!

Read more about...
11 Replies
shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator

This is from STTM:

UPDATE as of May 2014: Erfa was reformulated somehow, even though they deny it, causing symptoms to return for patients. See this: stopthethyroidmadness.com/2...

Hypopotamus profile image
Hypopotamus

It stopped working for me. Although my blood test results remained the same, I didn't feel well on it. It makes me feel like I've been given a heavy sedative.

Unfortunately for me, because his other patients on ERFA are apparently doing OK, my Endo won't switch me to anything else (after a year of begging).

in reply toHypopotamus

Can I ask what you asked to be switched to, please? I am doing fine on Erfa so far, but if the day comes when I don't, it's good to know there are alternatives...

Hypopotamus profile image
Hypopotamus in reply to

I asked for Westhroid or Nature Throid.

mrmoo profile image
mrmoo in reply to

Hi anna69 - Are you still doing fine on ERFA?

in reply tomrmoo

I have not taken Erfa for the past year, but am now on Thyroid-S (from Thailand). It works well. I was disappointed with Erfa and found it to be inconsistent; it was like each batch worked differently strength-wise...I have no idea if it has changed since and is now working better; hopefully, others will chime in...?

mrmoo profile image
mrmoo in reply toHypopotamus

Hi hypomotamus - How are you doing now? Your post is a year old and I'm wondering f you started to do better with a new ERFA script or if you finaly switched to somethine else that works?

Hypopotamus profile image
Hypopotamus in reply tomrmoo

I switched to Thiroid, and have felt a lot better for it.

deceived profile image
deceived in reply toHypopotamus

Do you mean Thiroyd? How long have you been on it? Any problems with it? Where did you get it?

Reply

deceived profile image
deceived in reply tomrmoo

Do you mean Thiroyd? How long have you been on it? Any problems with it? Where did you get it?

Ok, so this is going to be a controversial question...

At Thierry Hertoghe's practice, in Brussels, they now prescribe Erfa, as that is considered superior to Armour...and several pharmacies in Brussels that used to carry Armour no longer do, they just carry Erfa. One pharmacy even told me Armour is no longer being manufactured, which (I found out later) is simply not true.

However, this is what I have been wondering: I have read over and over again that you need to swallow NDT in order to make it work optimally, not chew it up or take it sublingually...is it at all possible that, if you swallow Armour, it will work better (possibly with cellulase supplements to break down the excess cellulose)? Or are NDT drugs without cellulose always better...?

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

ERFA

Hello everyone, I started a trial of ERFA, a couple of weeks ago after, at last, seeing an...
aliwt profile image

ERFA vs Thyroid S

Hi Folks.Would people say that ERFA has higher percentages of T4 and T3 than in Thyroid S...

Erfa allergy?

Today, I took Benadryl before Erfa for the first time. I have had no itching at all today. Since...

Problems with Erfa

OK, so now I've been on Erfa since December 2013, and I have not been able to make it work. I read...

ERFA changed manufacturer.

Just saw this on STTM: ARE YOU ON ERFA AND HAVE NOTICED YOUR HYPO SYMPTOMS RETURNING (and you...
jennybean profile image

Moderation team

See all
SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator
Jaydee1507 profile image
Jaydee1507Administrator
RedApple profile image
RedAppleAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.