Results of TSH & FT4 taken same day at 2 differ... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,617 members161,376 posts

Results of TSH & FT4 taken same day at 2 different hospitals:

Clutter profile image
30 Replies

Following some discussion about timing of TFTs I'm posting results taken at 2 different hospitals and 2.5 hours apart last week. Both tests were fasting because of cholesterol morning draw:

11.00 TSH 0.17 (0.35-5.5) FT4 17.2 (10.0-22.7)

13.30 TSH 0.13 (unknown) FT4 18.3 (9.0-19.0)

I intended my 2nd test to be drawn at 13.00 when TSH is lowest as GP had agreed to reduce my T4 without endo's consent and I didn't want him to get a row.

Original threads healthunlocked.com/thyroidu...

Written by
Clutter profile image
Clutter
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
30 Replies
jimh111 profile image
jimh111

These are normal variations. TSH is 'pulsatile' which means it's release isn't contant, it fluctuates a bit. I recently read a paper (lost it for now) which stated something like you need to take about 15 blood tests to arrive at an average result that is accurate to five percent. Small differences (< 10%) in thyroid blood test results are not meaningful.

Jim.

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to jimh111

Yes, I realise they're normal fluctuations and accord with the circadian rhythms which fluctuate a lot over 24 hours (as shown in the graphs in the links).

Jackie profile image
Jackie

Hi It is due to the assay , also time of day. Normally T4 should be top third of the range, wherever done. Also you do not mention FT3 ( free T3) vital for the correct treatment.

best wishes,

Jackie

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to Jackie

Didn't mention FT3 'cos labs didn't test, Jackie :( I agree with you that there isn't a full picture without it.

Jackie profile image
Jackie in reply to Clutter

It is annoying. Some hospitals do it. My cardiac do without my permission, usually when I have just taken it, makes it double! Just as infuriating.

Jackie

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to Jackie

That's just a waste of resources but could be dangerous if they attempted to treat or alter meds on that result.

Jackie profile image
Jackie in reply to Clutter

yes, I am petrified of that. having a big row with Cardio at the moment, they want to disconnect my ICD, certain death, etc etc , meeting tomorrow to try and combat their lies, not much hope of that!

Jackie

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to Jackie

I had to look it up Jackie. Why on earth would they disconnect it? Surely it would kill you?

Jackie profile image
Jackie in reply to Clutter

Hi That is their idea as I am dying any way. However, I cannot live for an hour without it and I am not going to commit suicide. However, they are over ruling me!Especially as often in a coma and then i am powerless.They have been to the ethics committee, evidently my wishes do not count! although I have the support of all my many consultants and brilliant private Cardio, still powerless.I am extremely complicated and they do not understand my 12 co morbidities etc. So, they are going for the easy option. !I will see how the meeting , today goes, but I dread to think. I may just leave, not easy in a wheel chair!

I knew you would need to look it up, but so complicated to explain!I have to for many docs and of course, nurses.

Best wishes,

Jackie

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to Jackie

Jackie, I'm very shocked. I imagined ethics committee's ruled to determine when patients lacked mental capacity. Have you contacted your MP? If you requested removal I could understand their dilemma, but to do it this way? Do they think removal will benefit you in some way? How can they remove it without your consent?

Jackie x

howlyn profile image
howlyn in reply to Clutter

Shocking

Jackie profile image
Jackie in reply to Clutter

Hi They can, and it is not unusual.My own good docs agree with me, but cannot interfere!!!!He told them all lies and also the clinical director, I know this for a fact.

I also had the sham meeting today. When I proved everything he had aid to be untrue, but useless.My good consultants want me to take it much further but exhausted.All the wrong treatment has not been documented, obvious nothing I have sent or given. has been read. I know some things that have happened are illegal but if they do not document it all, as they do not, nothing I can do..

I am actually too ill for these battles but it is my life. I do exactly what my decent consultants tell me to and they also say I have to keep myself alive and not trust ( their) hospital!

I cannot go elsewhere as the "best" for all my co-morbidities!You can imagine what some of the others are like. It is partly as I am extremely complicated.

Imagine what it is like for people without a good brain or mentally kill!

Thanks any way.

Not beaten yet , but struggling!

Jackie

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to Jackie

I'm still struggling to understand how removal could possibly benefit you. Pacemakers are never removed and this is a form of it.

Sorry you're having this battle when the important one is to manage your health.

Very best wishes,

Jackie x

Jackie profile image
Jackie in reply to Clutter

Hi, It is because of the defibrillator, they say it is uncomfortable for the nurses to see it reviving an almost dead patient! Must not have that, at any cost!

Thanks,

Jackie

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to Jackie

Incredible! Why have defibrillators at all if they're disturbing to nursing staff? Oh yes, they stop patients from dying of heart failure. Nurses need to get over themselves or get a different job not kill you off because you offend their sensibilities.

Jackie profile image
Jackie in reply to Clutter

My ICD by defibrillating has saved me with my last 2 arrests, I had 2 before that and very lucky. Actually a good Cardio. Only one in about 20 !! Cardiac in hospital is such a nightmare. Unfortunately I have a lot of emergencies and have no choice.When dying in there, they just pull the curtains and ,leave me on my own.

This is one of the best hospitals in Europe!!!

Jackie

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to Jackie

Doesn't sound like it to me. It's not even back door euthanasia when withdrawal will kill you. It's not right.

Jackie profile image
Jackie in reply to Clutter

Hi Probably a mistaken but just e mailed them and asked for details of the meeting , after advice, to include all the false accusations.!!

Jackie

Parksie7 profile image
Parksie7

Hi

I think that you feel that your TSH should be lower in the second test. However, your own circadian rhythm for TSH may not have very high peaks and troughs. In some some individuals the pulsatile nature of TSH is not very apparent. If you look at the graph in the link below for subject 34 you will see that there is only very modest changes in the amplitude of the peaks and troughs.

press.endocrine.org/doi/ful...

I also suspect that if a patient takes replacement meds in the long term that the pulsatile secretion pattern may become skewed dependent on timing of replacement meds - I have no evidence for this, but it makes a lot of sense that the secretion patterns for TSH could be altered as a response to replacement thyroid hormone timing.

Lx

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to Parksie7

I wonder whether lack of thyroid makes much difference too.

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK

Afraid that without knowing the reference range, the very modest numerical difference between 0.17 and 0.13 could be reduced or expanded by the second TSH range starting lower or higher! If you see what I mean.

If the second TSH test had a range 0.25 to 4.5, then you are looking at where 0.13 falls in the "below range" 0.00 to 0.25. That is, almost exactly halfway between zero and bottom of range. If the second test had a range 0.45 to 5.6, then it is where 0.13 falls between 0.00 and 0.45. Which is not even one third of the way between zero and 0.45.

I appreciate that this is a very mechanistic approach but is meant to show how difficult it is to interpret the results.

Other than this, the "normal variations" arguments do seem quite strong. A shame your first test had not been at 08:00 (or earlier!) - that might have made the second test look very different instead of only marginally so.

By the way, I have recently had a short period when I felt very slightly over-dosed on levothyroxine. I absolutely hated the feeling. If I had to choose between feeling like that for years and feeling much better than that, I am fairly sure I know which way I would go.

Rod

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to helvella

I've never known the TSH range as it's always been under <0.1.

The timing exercise worked out the way I wanted and I would certainly advise anyone borderline or requiring an increasing to test at sparrow's fart.

I don't think I'm overly sensitive to meds but 18 months of over medication had a very unpleasant cumulative effect and made me very ill indeed. I've certainly improved my health and well being since my 'detox' and hope that I'm on the road to recovery now.

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to Clutter

Yep - understand that - if it is at limit of detection, the range obviously doesn't matter!

Lilian15 profile image
Lilian15

I had to have a blood test done for endo and for GP so decided to have them done on the same day (save me having to go through it twice). It was the same blood, taken at the same time, at the same hospital. The GP got his results which showed I was overmedicated. The Endo got his results which showed I was undermedicated. So one of the testing equipments was faulty. How long it had been faulty nobody knows nor how long they will still be using the faulty one because nobody cared when I pointed this out. The endo said I should have more thyroxine and my GP refused to prescribe it because his test results showed over medication. Even when I told him about the different results he took no notice. I guess he either didn't understand or was not listening to me or just didn't care. He was sticking by the results he had in front of him whether they were faulty or not.

I phoned the lab about three weeks later pointing out the discrepancies. The chief of the lab did not understand what I was saying. She said it is possible to get two different results from two different machines. I tried to point out to her that although the numbers might be different it could not possibly be from the same blood that one could show hyper and the other hypo. Eventually she said she understood, but that could be just to get rid of me. She did offer to do another test for me. Unless they recalibrated the faulty machine it would be useless as I would not know whether that result would be right or wrong.

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to Lilian15

That is scary!

chihiro profile image
chihiro

Hey Clutter

That's interesting.those 2 tsh results are really close despite 2 and half hours between them!

Now if you could kindly build a time machine,go back in time and redo them without fasting I would really appreciate that :D

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to chihiro

If I could do that, I'd go back far enough to uninvent the "exquisitely sensitive" TSH test :-D

Muffy profile image
Muffy

8 - 8-30 am is best as TSH would be higher in the range and FT4 lower.

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply to Muffy

It is if your borderline hypo, Muffy, or want your meds increased.

I wanted to avoid a meds increase and looked to test when my TSH would likely be lowest.

Muffy profile image
Muffy

Sorry Clutter, got the wrong end of the stick.

You may also like...

Medichecks result different from Bupa? Taken at same time!

different: Medichecks: TSH 0.226 FT3 4.14 FT4 17.2 Bupa: TSH 0.22 FT3 3.3 FT4 15.9 Now I’m...

TSH, FT3 & FT4 results

London October 2017: TSH 1.310 mIU/L (0.270-4.2) FT3 3.86 pmol/L (3.74-6.11) FT4 14.9 pmol/L...

Differing TSH results

would also check FT4 and 3 levels. I did the Monitor My Health test at 8am, fasting, stopped B...

Same Dose- different results

results. My TSH seems to have come down quite a bit but my FT4 has also dropped quite a bit TSH...

TSH/FT3/FT4 Test Results

just had these results back: TSH 0.05 (0.2 to 4.2) FT3 4.17 (3.1 to 6.8) FT4 13.6 (11 to 22) I've...