Mukherjee's "The Laws of Medicine" (2... - SHARE Metastatic ...

SHARE Metastatic Breast Cancer

6,809 members8,426 posts

Mukherjee's "The Laws of Medicine" (2015)

Hazelgreen profile image
7 Replies

Best521 strongly recommended Dr. Mukherjee's latest book, "The Song of the Cell". I looked up the reference, and ended up ordering all four of his books. I am currently reading his tiny, 70-page, "The Laws of Medicine", and thought some of you would be interested in his "three principles that govern modern medicine":

1. A strong intuition is much more powerful than a weak test.

2. "Normals" teach us rules; "outliers" teach us laws.

3. For every perfect medical experiment, there is a perfect human bias.

Dr. Mukherjee concludes, "...decision making in the face of uncertain, inaccurate, and imperfect information, remains absolutely vital to the life of medicine." I think what he may be saying is that patients are individuals about whom doctors know very little. Still, doctors must make decisions about each individual's care.

We patients may simply need to accept the limitations of this imperfect approach. Of course, we may choose to make any modifications we intuitively think will suit our individual uniqueness better, but that decision is ours alone.

Written by
Hazelgreen profile image
Hazelgreen
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
7 Replies
Bettybuckets profile image
Bettybuckets

hi Hazel- thanks for writing all the info. I loved his book and will look into the others.

queeneee profile image
queeneee

I have been getting 'better' decisions from my onc. since I asked him if he had read 'Winnie the Pooh'? He said he had. I replied - Do you know Eeyore? He is slow moving, depressed, stays in his hut and things don't change quickly with him? He nodded. I said - well I am a Tigger, I react quickly and am sensitive to medicines, I am good at the sprint, but find the marathon harder. I bounce back pretty quickly if not overwhelmed, and drugs move out of my system quickly because I am usually bouncing about... He often makes reference to my tiggerishness and I think he makes more suitable decisions for me, having that reference point.

Hazelgreen profile image
Hazelgreen in reply toqueeneee

I much enjoyed your self-depiction, Queenee! I think I might be more like Winnie when interacting with the medical community...a goofy, I'm okay smile. It's only when I'm home again that the scientist in me comes out.

Best521 profile image
Best521

Thanks Hazelgreen. I will have to buy the Laws of Medicine. Loved his comment “A strong intuition is much more powerful than a weak test”. How many times have we all experienced that to be true? Especially when it comes to MBC treatment.

Hazelgreen profile image
Hazelgreen in reply toBest521

He gives a case where it was more than an "intuition", but rather what he also refers to as "prior knowledge".

PJBinMI profile image
PJBinMI

I've read two of his books and loved them! He writes so beautifully and weaves "rules" with stories of patients. I'll be ordering his latest, too.

diamags profile image
diamags

I love him. I've read The Emporer of all Maladys and The Gene and will order the other two right now. He is both brilliant and insightful.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Not cancer related but I thought i’d Share my news!

After a couple of years of consideration we made the snap decision yesterday to welcome a new...
Julie2233 profile image

Cancer Without Chemotherapy: ‘A Totally Different World’ - The New York Times

Hi fellow MBC’ers: Very interesting & hopeful article!...

Laughter is the best medicine - let the fun Be-gin

Had the most amazing weekend with my best friends of over 40 years. Relaxing in the hot tub,...
Mindysooty profile image

Medical marijuana in Michigan

Though I've not had serious pain from mbc, I imagine it is just a matter of time. I've had bone...
PJBinMI profile image

Should i stay or should i go

I have been under a lot of stress at work lately . Our work load has doubled and my patients is...
Anitafazz profile image

Moderation team

See all
Jslanovich profile image
JslanovichAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.