Newsletter from Holland and Barrett - Pernicious Anaemi...

Pernicious Anaemia Society

31,968 members23,110 posts

Newsletter from Holland and Barrett

Little-My profile image
10 Replies

Today’s copy of the regular newsletter I receive by email from H&B is entitled De-mist-ifying the causes of brain fog and is all about B12.

Much of the info they include seems accurate to me, with one glaring omission. Not one single mention of PA. It is, apparently, the elderly, vegans and vegetarians who are at most risk of b12 deficiency. The answer, unsurprisingly, is to buy H&Bs products.

I know they exist to make money, but it strikes me as highly irresponsible not to make any reference to PA or to considering consulting a GP. Also foolish, as they could have promoted the oral sprays they sell.

I have written to them to complain and thought I’d share here in case of interest to other members.

The newsletter is also on their website:

hollandandbarrett.com/the-h...

Admin edits - please note that this is a prime example of how advertising hype works and some of the tactics that make it obvious that something is advertising hype - eg promoting own products as a solution to a problem

Written by
Little-My profile image
Little-My
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...

The ability to reply to this post has been turned off.

10 Replies
Pickle500 profile image
Pickle500

Thanks for sharing this.

They also incorrectly reference (in parentheses) that B12 is also known as cynocobalamin.

Are there H&B products that PA sufferers can use?

I suppose that they're not selling injections so maybe avoid talking about PA altogether.

All of this is such a minefield.

I also personally believe that Pernicious Anemia needs a rebrand. I think it needs to become known as autoimmune gastritis. Then we'd know that injections and Drs are required.

Pernicious anemia is really an outdated term that leads to even more mess and confusion. And for a disease that can lead to elevated levels of confusion, it's all a bit too much to swallow!

clivealive profile image
clivealiveForum Support in reply to Pickle500

Cyanocobamalin was the name of the original B12 injections and I have been having them since 1972 - now more than fifty years ago - in fact my next one is due on Monday :)

Pickle500 profile image
Pickle500 in reply to clivealive

Great stuff Clive.

We should get you to write up some (accurate) articles

😀

helvella profile image
helvella

In addition to what Pickle500 has identified:

1.5 micrograms could only ever be sufficient in someone who has a properly-functioning entero-hepatic recirculation of B12.

helping the body absorb folic acid

I usually take "absorb" to mean getting something from mouth, gut, skin, into out bloodstreams for onward distribution. (Well, roughly that.) Does anyone think gut absorption of folic acid is improved by B12?

Breast-feeding mothers may need an extra 0.5mcg a day, particularly if they’re also vegetarian or vegan.

Being vegetarian or vegan doesn't increase absolute requirement for B12. Breast-feeding mothers need more B12 (than similar/same people not breast-feeding) but hat need exists whether they get it from consuming vast quantities of meat or a tablet.

What happens if I consume too much vitamin B12?

There’s no set upper limit for vitamin B12, as there is very little evidence that too much is harmful. But the NHS advises having no more than 2mcg a day.

They quote this NHS site which actually says:

What does the Department of Health and Social Care advise?

You should be able to get all the vitamin B12 you need by eating a varied and balanced diet.

If you take vitamin B12 supplements, do not take too much as this could be harmful.

Taking 2mg or less a day of vitamin B12 in supplements is unlikely to cause any harm.

nhs.uk/conditions/vitamins-...

It is the greatest of my allegations that a company the size of H&B, with the numerous professionals they employ, their vast turnover, and their claims to provide meaningful advice on issues of health cannot tell the difference between a MILLIGRAM (mg) and a MICROGRAM (mcg).

deniseinmilden profile image
deniseinmilden in reply to helvella

I have found Twitter to be reasonably effective at getting companies to take action - if you post on their thread what you say is truly public.

clivealive profile image
clivealiveForum Support

I wonder if H&B think that P.A. sufferers would gain no benefit from B12 sprays/tablets hence their not including "us". - just a thought

deniseinmilden profile image
deniseinmilden in reply to clivealive

And a wise one at that!

Great to hear from you occasionally! So pleased you're still "Clive alive"!

Little-My profile image
Little-My

Thanks for all the replies and for highlighting the errors in their info that I didn’t know. Their inability to tell the difference between MG and MCG is indeed shocking.

It maybe that they are assuming that PA suffers can’t benefit from the oral sprays they sell, but that’s wrong of course and so, if it is their assumption, further highlights their lack of research.

Rebranding of PA is an interesting idea and could well help.

Hope everyone who is experiencing these extra high temps across the UK and elsewhere is staying cool!

deniseinmilden profile image
deniseinmilden

Thank you for this and thanks to those who have commented.

I can't help but feel there's a fresh young aspiring journalist newbie in the position of the writer for their newsletter who doesn't have a clue about what they are saying.

Unforgivable, nonetheless.

Gambit62 profile image
Gambit62Administrator

Thank you for this post - however, it does seem to have sparked some off topic discussion of dietary deficiency so I am closing to further responses.

The ability to reply to this post has been turned off.

You may also like...

Endoscopy results from 8/3/18

the endoscopy and says to watch b12 levels. So I wrote him an email and asked him to respectfully...

Re: high Folate levels & diminished returns from b12

than one type of b12 @ any one time can interfere with the absorption of active b12 through the...

Questions from a newcomer?

administering a 100 mcg doses of cyanocobalamin (b12 shot in Canada) for myself which i intended to...

List of all types of injectable vitamin B12 available from German online pharmacies

have compiled a list of all types of injectable vitamin B12 available in German online pharmacies...

B12 from the liver to the body?

i can only get B12 into my system via injections. Here is my question. Once the B12 injections...