Has anyone here got their GP to give ... - Pernicious Anaemi...

Pernicious Anaemia Society

31,955 members23,096 posts

Has anyone here got their GP to give them a 'therapeutic trial' of B12 injections *WITHOUT* positive B12 deficiency blood test results?

Fleecie profile image
25 Replies

Hello all.

I'm currently suffering from a range of symptoms that overlap with B12 deficiency including some very strong numbness across my whole body but particularly feet and legs followed by arms.

I have read a lot of the literature around this and there are clear suggestions to proceed straight to a trial of B12 injections where a patient displays clear symptoms, especially neurological ones, despite 'normal' serum B12 results.

I don't know my whole testing history but I know I was last tested for B12 in 2019 with a normal result. I don't know if I've ever been tested for the other markers recommended to be tested to get a diagnosis i.e. MMA, homocysteine and active B12 (holoTC). But I don't think I have because those tests have never been mentioned and I know they aren't commonly done on the NHS.

Because I've done a lot of reading and research on this topic (including reading around here, thank you all) I am aware that I might encounter some resistance when I approach my GP to ask for additional testing and/or a therapeutic trial of B12 injections.

I was wondering if anyone here was able to get a doctor to put them on a trial of B12 injections, even in the face of blood test results that didn't clearly show B12 deficiency?

I am feeling absolutely desperate.

Written by
Fleecie profile image
Fleecie
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
25 Replies
wedgewood profile image
wedgewood

Firstly , do get a print-out of your last B12 test which was pronounced “Normal “ by your GP . You need to know that result .You are legally entitled to a copy . My b12 reading was pronounced “ normal “ and I was sent on my way . My result was actually low and I did have P.A . I had to go to a private doctor to be tested for P.A. and the IFAB test was positive ( intrinsic Factor Antibody test) Lucky because about 50% of P.A.Npatients rest negative . Yes , it’s not easy to get a diagnosis , but symptoms should be treated , no matter what the result is . So first get that. print-out . Important .

Fleecie profile image
Fleecie in reply to wedgewood

Hello Wedge. Thanks for the reply.

No, I haven't seen a print-out of it. I was told (just the other day) that it was 650 (high, right?) or something like that. I forget the unit.

wedgewood profile image
wedgewood in reply to Fleecie

yes that’s a decent level . But with your symptoms I think that it warrants another test . You last one was 2 years ago . It is possible to have b12 Deficiency/ Pernicious anaemia with a high B12 reading , but your GP may not know about this . It’s called “functional B12 deficiency “ .So look that up so that you are well informed .

Fleecie profile image
Fleecie in reply to wedgewood

Thanks for your reply. Yes I'm aware that the standard B12 test isn't fully accurate or reliable. I have done a lot of reading on the topic and this place was a useful source to point me towards that information.

At the time I was probably supplementing B12 so that may have given me a high result as well as the problem with the inaccuracy of the tests.

I am not saying for sure that I am B12 deficient though, obviously I can't say that with confidence. I have a lot of matching symptoms though and I've yet to get any other explanation or evidence-based diagnosis for all of them.

Bonjourtristesse profile image
Bonjourtristesse

No, I didn't have success. Despite 25 years of symptoms, borderline levels, getting private tests, private injections and reporting benefits back to GP.

I gave up. I paid for my own. I appreciate not everyone has this option.

I would point out that others have had success. I think you need to be very persistent, and very good at withstanding ridicule and standing your ground. Many of us are either too sick or not very good at challenging authority.

Nackapan profile image
Nackapan

Has your doctor tested you for other things? Referred you to a neurologist?

Alot of symptoms overlap with so many things

Get another full blood test

Ask for every test you can get to explain your symptoms.

As already suggested get your blood results for your own records

Without supplements another measure of b12 /folate useful before you try anything .

I hope you get some answers soon.

Then treatment.

I've heard of b12 injections bring trialled in some with chronic fatigue but from a specialist.

Bonjourtristesse profile image
Bonjourtristesse in reply to Nackapan

For some reason the nice guidelines state do not treat fatigue from MS with b12 injections. But I’ve no idea why.

I wouldn’t mind betting some people with ms are b12 deficient.

nice.org.uk/donotdo/do-not-...

And this says CFS shouldn’t even be tested for b12!!

nice.org.uk/donotdo/tests-f...

Nackapan profile image
Nackapan in reply to Bonjourtristesse

Oh I've just known people put on them with chronic fatigue.(old term ME) ..not MS (link you sent)

Must be certain specialists or perhaps the person asked??

Thanks for guidelines on this I hadn't read them.

CFS not tested for b12 seems odd.

As many with undiagnosed b12 deficiency get this label cfs and fibromyalgia describing the group of symptoms( one of my daughters being one of them) Just to show how 'the wrong label' can't halt vital tests causing then permanent disability.

Bonjourtristesse profile image
Bonjourtristesse in reply to Nackapan

Definitely. I was also told CFS or maybe fibromyalgia. I dread to think how many are suffering. I want to write to them all and ask them if they’ve tried b12 injections. Same with all the long covid people.

Fleecie profile image
Fleecie in reply to Nackapan

I've been under investigation for many symptoms for years. I've seen neurologists multiple times. However I'm not sure that I've been properly checked for the possibility of B12 deficiency. I may well have only ever had my total serum B12 checked and as you all know that isn't a reliable marker.

No doctor ever mentioned to me that they were checking the other B12 deficiency markers like 'active' B12 (holoTC), MMA, homocysteine and IF antibodies and I certainly never heard about such results. So I feel its likely I have never been properly tested, but I can't be sure.

I'm going to look into my previous tests a bit more. But given the NHS' rep around B12 deficiency I am expecting to find that I've only ever had my total B12 measured, which is unreliable.

Nackapan profile image
Nackapan in reply to Fleecie

Yes thars all ive had. No IFA test.

Other things on request lie ferritin snd vit D were.

Had to ask though.

My level was low so got loading doses eventually. But hadcto push hard fir a frequency of maintenence

My daughter had a brain scan before b12 tested at all!!!

Medics are not taught how devastating it csn be.

They search for other things meanwhile nof treated.

Fleecie profile image
Fleecie in reply to Nackapan

I remember reading a few of your posts around the forum here and you talking about your daughters situation. Another frustrating story. Is she getting proper treatment now?

Can I ask if she saw a neurologist? Presumably she did if she went for a brain scan. Did the neurologist do any of the B12 tests and was the possibility of B12 deficiency discussed?

I'm asking because I'm going to speak to my GP again soon and push for more B12 testing or a trial of B12 injections and i'm expecting him to raise the fact that i've seen a neurologist several times during the period where i've had these symptoms.

I think he might say ''well you saw a neurologist and they didn't find anything wrong with so I won't do anything further'' but the reality is that the neurologist didn't ever mention B12 deficiency or doing any testing for it so I just can't be sure that they (the neurologist) were thinking about that possibility at al.

So, yeah, did your daughter see a neurologist and did that neurologist either test for B12 markers and discuss the possibility of B12 deficiency? Would be really useful to know.

Thanks again.

Nackapan profile image
Nackapan in reply to Fleecie

No tbe neurologist dudnt test b12 They dudca dew Mri scans and ordered a lumber puncture.

Thru saw a bulge on hef spine but tgrn dudnissed it.

It was when she was admitted to hospital a few years later very low b12 was found low ferritin snd hostel and megoblastic anemia.

Sorry I missed your question and reply

The Gp fud apologise for missing it !!

Still didn't put slot of her symptoms down yo it.

Exasperating.

A fibromyalgia forum has revealed mist are low b12 !!

Chicken or egg. ??

J have my view

Horse12345 profile image
Horse12345

Hi Fleecie. I also have the same symptoms and a lot more, I have a low b12 it was 190 last test, but my g.p always say it's within guidelines!!! Believe me I have asked for help with no luck. I have even moved to a different. G.P .I have very low fertin 9 last test and I take pills everyday,and also a very bad stomach, all I get told over and over that's its all borderline. I have even had to stop work due to being so unwell. Still NO HELP. I have now been told by me G.P to go and see a neurologist. I am waiting to go see one Privately even private its a 14 week wait. I also feel like I am about to give up. I have tried my hardest to get the help I need for the past 2 yrs with this and I am still banging my head against a brick wall. Good luck .

Fleecie profile image
Fleecie in reply to Horse12345

Thanks for the reply. That's really sad to hear and tough to read Horse. I'm sorry you've been put through that. Stories like yours seem very common.

Sleepybunny profile image
Sleepybunny

Hi,

Apologies for the short reply Fleecie...I usually write very detailed ones but have run out of energy.

Link about "What to do next" if B12 deficiency suspected or newly diagnosed

b12deficiency.info/what-to-...

PAS (Pernicious Anaemia Society)

Based in Wales, UK.

pernicious-anaemia-society....

There is a helpline number that PAS members can ring.

Unhappy with Treatment (UK info)?

Letters to GPs about B12 deficiency

b12deficiency.info/b12-writ...

Letters avoid face to face confrontation with GP and allow patient time to express their concerns effectively.

Best to keep letters as brief, to the point and polite as possible. It's harder to ignore a letter in my opinion.

Keep copies of any letters sent or received.

UK B12 documents

BSH Cobalamin and Folate Guidelines

b-s-h.org.uk/guidelines/gui...

Summary of above document

pernicious-anaemia-society....

Above link includes statement "In presence of discordance between the test result and strong clinical features of deficiency, treatment should not be delayed to avoid neurological impairment"

I take this to mean ....if you have symptoms of B12 deficiency, you should be treated to prevent neuro damage.

Diagnostic flowchart from BSH Cobalamin and Folate Guidelines which mentions Antibody Negative PA.

stichtingb12tekort.nl/engli...

BMJ B12 article

bmj.com/content/349/bmj.g5226

Emphasises need to treat patients who are symptomatic even if their B12 level is within range.

BNF Hydroxycobalamin

bnf.nice.org.uk/drug/hydrox...

NICE CKS B12 deficiency and folate deficiency

cks.nice.org.uk/anaemia-b12...

cks.nice.org.uk/topics/anae...

Accessing Health Records (England)

nhs.uk/using-the-nhs/about-...

england.nhs.uk/contact-us/h...

patients-association.org.uk...

Have a look at my replies in the threads below which have lots of B12 info eg articles, books, websites, uk guidelines etc

healthunlocked.com/pasoc/po...

healthunlocked.com/pasoc/po...

healthunlocked.com/pasoc/po...

I am not medically trained.

Nackapan profile image
Nackapan in reply to Sleepybunny

I call that very detailed! 🙂

Fleecie profile image
Fleecie in reply to Sleepybunny

Thanks for your post. Fortunately i've done a lot of reading on here (and elsewhere) and i've come across your useful posts like this many times so I'm familiar with all these sources. Thanks again though.

MoKayD profile image
MoKayD

I'm from the US not Great Britain but I thought I'd share anyway. My friend asked her GP to test for B12 deficiency and her doctor agreed and then said "Why don't we just give you a shot of B12 and see how you feel?" What a great doctor. She felt less tired almost immediately. Her test came back low so she's now on monthly shots.

Fleecie profile image
Fleecie in reply to MoKayD

Thanks for the story. Sadly that outcome seems to be very rare.

MamaRun5 profile image
MamaRun5

Hi. I managed to get a private appointment to an endocrinologist. He suggested to the GP it was worthwhile considering a loading dose despite negative test for IF and "normal" b12 levels. It worked! Then I had to go back and he suggested the GP consider monthly injections and work from there. With the "back up" of the consultant the GP was more confident in prescribing. Unlike the gastro consultant who said "CFS , quit your job, running, life....."

Fleecie profile image
Fleecie in reply to MamaRun5

Hey, thanks for sharing your story. That's interesting and an apparently rare positive story.

Nackapan profile image
Nackapan in reply to Fleecie

I had yo get a neurologist to write to my Gp.Firstly ignored then my Gp against opposition from peers sanctioned sc and continue with 2 weekly prescription. Off licience

To still go for IM monthly thars now 6 weekly ad no nurses snd going by ladt one mat reduce further.

MamaRun5 profile image
MamaRun5 in reply to Fleecie

Refer to this....b-s-h.org.uk/guidelines/gui... it also helped

Fleecie profile image
Fleecie in reply to MamaRun5

Hey Mama, can I just a specific question? I've got a friend who is also suffering from B12 deficiency symptoms, hes going to just try a B12 injection immediately.

Did you start to feel better after your *first* shot? How long until you felt a change after that first shot? Is it common for people to feel a positive change after the first shot?

Sorry, I guess that's 3 questions! But I'm not very knowledgeable on this point. But I would like to be able to tell my friend if he could expect to possibly (if he is truly deficient) see some improvement soon after the first shot, or if he is likely to need multiple shots to feel any difference.

Thanks.

You may also like...

If I got an active b12 test done privately and it showed I was deficient, would my GP give me injections?

active b12 test done privately because I'm not getting anywhere with the NHS. I've now had 3 b12...

B12 deficiency, injections and blood test results

knowledge of B12 deficiency? I've been feeling rubbish with loads of strange symptoms for at least...

GP has finally agreed to giving me B12 injections but no loading doses ☹️

practice to have a B12 injection. However she said that as my blood test results showed me still...

GP will only agree to 3 monthly injections unless I have a blood test showing low b12 levels.

request for more frequent injections. ( I am aware you have been on the b12 injections for a long...

Can a very high B12 blood test result also mean you are deficient somehow?

contradictory I know. But my husband has so many symptoms that indicate he's B12 deficient -...