WHAT THE DOCTOR SAID and METHYLCOBALA... - Pernicious Anaemi...

Pernicious Anaemia Society

31,973 members23,121 posts

WHAT THE DOCTOR SAID and METHYLCOBALAMIN

may61 profile image
3 Replies

Not a lot to be truthful.He said I was one of the healthiest people on his books.If only that were true.

Been having loads of problems over the past year,during and after lockdown.But over the past few weeks it’s been my legs .Getting worse daily and had another fall last Thursday .So told him I would see how I went on over the past two weeks would see how I went on and if no better would be back to him

Meanwhile been taking the sublinguals Had some folic acid this morning.and a hydroxy and a Methycobalamin a bit later

Been re reading Martin’s Hoopers book and came across a snippet about methylcobalamin being good for your legs so had another one and yes it is making a difference so gonna continue with them .

Let you know what the next installment is goin to be Think it needs to be second opinion

Written by
may61 profile image
may61
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
3 Replies
fbirder profile image
fbirder

Martyn's book was written before this paper - ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl... - which showed that all forms of B12 are converted to cob(II)alamin as soon as they enter the cell. From that point on they are all identical.

So there is no reason at all to believe that methylcobalamin is any better than other types of B12 for nerves, legs, etc.

Gambit62 profile image
Gambit62Administrator

may61, whilst there may not be an obvious explanation many of us do find that we respond differently to different forms of cobalamin. Some find methyl helps with some symptoms, some find that it gives them anxiety.Personally I also find methyl helps with some neurological symptoms but it doesn't do anything in relation to neuropsychiatric symptoms. I also find that adenosyl helps with urge incontinence. Just carry on if it is working for you.

If your falling down he can hardly say your the fittest patient he's seen. Unless his other patients are in a worse way than you and that would suggest he's not very good at his job. How can he ignore you the patient and only look at the piece of paper? That's not OK. Is there anyone else at the practice you can try? From doctor to doctor I have has wildly different diagnosis for the exact same symptoms.

You may also like...

Cyanocobalamin or methylcobalamin. what's the difference.

these? I have been taking methylcobalamin but I read on this site that a lot of people have been...

Doctors said I'm normal but I feel far from it!

45 (20-204) Vitamin d 38.5 (80-150) I have also had thyroid results showing Tsh 2.51 (0.27 - 4.2)...

Doctor said you can become allergic to b12. Oh please what next

Hello, My daughter is 23 and had low b12 for 5 years, drs, they did nothing. Anyhow I fought for her

Methylcobalamin and Headaches

I was wondering if anybody had any specific advice, information or reassurances regarding getting...

Methylcobalamin injections?

newbie and was reading that the methylcobalamin has some advantages over cyanocobalamin. Do you...