Methylcobalamin or Hydroxo: Hi, I've... - Pernicious Anaemi...

Pernicious Anaemia Society

31,915 members23,044 posts

Methylcobalamin or Hydroxo

Heidiv profile image
2 Replies

Hi,

I've had weekly injections of Methylcobalamin for some months now with quite good results although neurological symptoms are still present. I'm planning to si twice a week to see of I make progress.

Right now I'm a bit confused. I think someone on this forum said it's better to use methyl if there is a suspicion of MTHFR. But someone else said it doesn't make a difference as everything will be converted anyway. As Methyl gives me the side effect of anxiety, I'm wondering if I should switch to Hydroxo...? If I have MTHFR, would Hydroxo help me as well as Methyl? Also, I am unable to take folic acid or methylfolate as my stomach's ruined and both make me very sick. I think someone said with the Methyl shots I could do without the folate..

Thanks as always!

Written by
Heidiv profile image
Heidiv
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
2 Replies
fbirder profile image
fbirder

Hydroxocobalamin should be just as good as, if not better than, methylcobalamin.

Everybody has MTHFR. It is an enzyme essential to life. Almost everybody has a mutation in the gene that makes that enzyme. Very rarely, one particular mutation, carried by around 10% of the population, may possibly cause a problem. For those people supplementing with methylfolate might possibly help. Taking methylcobalamin cannot possibly help.

No matter what type of B12 you take you still need folate. It is responsible for making some of the parts that make up DNA and also for one of the mechanisms that the body uses to switch various genes on and off.

b12science.com/B12Science/D...

Ryaan profile image
Ryaan

Hydroxocobalamin is good and is what’s licensed in UK for use by doctors.

Should be just as good.

You may also like...

changing hydroxo and methyl dosage.

I’ve been taking hydroxo 1500ug one injection a day for 2 years with folic acid and no improvement.

Methylcobalamin

with these though as they make me feel I'll. I will go back to my hydroxo until my next injection on

Methyl & hydroxo.

injecting methyl 3 times a day. I’m also injecting hydroxo. Should I be injecting hydroxo once...

Changing from methyl to hydroxo worries

Hi everyone. I'm about to switch from methyl b12 ampules to Dr myhill's hydroxo, and I'm worried...

Methylcobalamin

Barrett 1000 /ug Methylcobalamin which you dissolve in under your tongue. So do you think that it...