Vitamin b12 queries!!!: Any updated... - Pernicious Anaemi...

Pernicious Anaemia Society

31,973 members23,121 posts

Vitamin b12 queries!!!

Riyad55 profile image
2 Replies

Any updated information regarding b12 treatment? Which one is best-- methylcobalamin/hydroxocobalamin/cyanocobalamin??

Written by
Riyad55 profile image
Riyad55
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
2 Replies
Gambit62 profile image
Gambit62Administrator

there is no easy answer to your question - people respond differently to different types of B12 - and in fact there is a fourth adenosyl that you haven't mentioned.

Some of this difference in response is probably genetic in origin and even then it is going to be difficult to interpret if you have a full genome because of interactions between different genetic combinations and the fact that the full processes for activating certain genetic variants is a long way from being understood.

Some people find methyl good - others find it does nothing for them and others find it actually makes things worse

cyano should not be used if you have lebers - a rare genetic condition - mainly affecting males - which makes you particularly sensitive to the cyano element. It can cause damage to the optic nerve in people with lebers

hydrox works well for lots of people but some people find it doesn't do enough and some people don't get on with it - finding cyano suits them better.

adenosyl is the least stable type - not sure if it is available as injections - but is available as tablets/sublingual tablets.

there is a rare genetic variant that makes people unable to process methyl fully so it is available to be combined to form adenosyl at the cell level.

the only way to really know which suits you best is to try and see.

Personally I use a mix of all 4 - cyano and hydroxo as injections, hydroxo and methyl as nasal sprays and adenosyl as sublinguals. methyl doesn't help me at all with neuropsychiatric symptoms but is quite good for some other neurological problems. adenosyl seems to be the best in terms of controlling incontinence.

Riyad55 profile image
Riyad55 in reply to Gambit62

thank you soo much. informative and elaborate answer. Greatful to you.

You may also like...

Query b12 amount & frequency

symptoms and exhaustion to be prolonged, if you take b12 daily instead of alternate days... Or...

B12 loading doses query

nurse who does b12 is only in Tuesday and Wednesdays, is that ok to have the b12 injections one day...

Functional B12 diagnosis query

specialist is needed in the UK to diagnose Functional B12 deficiency? My GP practice doesn’t seem...

Vitamin b12 vitamin b9 anaemia

your injections? Of course our B12 is always going to be high. My latest B12 result came back as...

B12...and supporting vitamins/minerals

willing to share the treatment plan, or any advice/experiences, which gave them best results-just...