Butter or I Can't Believe It's Not Butter? - Kidney Disease

Kidney Disease

12,349 members5,114 posts

Butter or I Can't Believe It's Not Butter?

Hugatree737 profile image
28 Replies

I get conflicting answers on this and I'm trying to slowly change my diet. I Can't Believe It's Not Butter is a vegetable oil spread. 1/2 the fat of butter and 0 cholesterol. I know the best answer is neither, but if I have choose, which is best for CKD? My gfr is 50. Thanks in advance for any help!

Written by
Hugatree737 profile image
Hugatree737
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
28 Replies

I asked my RD the same question and her advice was I Can't Believe..., but sparingly.

Hugatree737 profile image
Hugatree737 in reply to

Thank-you. I asked my nephrologist about a dietitian and he said not needed now, so I appreciate your help!

in reply toHugatree737

If possible you should tell your nephrologist that you WANT a referral. It's not up to them! It's your decision. They can help you develop a kidney-friendly meal plan that will help you slow the progression of CKD.

Hugatree737 profile image
Hugatree737 in reply to

I've asked twice and he says I don't need one, and I think it's because from what I read, insurance won't pay for it. I'm beginning to think I need to try a new nephrologist.

in reply toHugatree737

You can try a couple of other options before finding a better nephrologist. See if a dialysis center near you has an RD who will sit with you and get you started. You can also speak to the RD at your local hospital to help. You also can ask your PCP for the referral to see an RD. Hope this helps.

in reply to

In my area the dieticians at dialysis and hospitals will only talk with you if you’re a patient. But it’s worth looking out of town just to have the knowledge of what to eat and what not to. And it’s worth paying for yourself if your insurance doesn’t cover the consultation. It’s been very helpful to me and I’m stage 3

Cathyhains profile image
Cathyhains in reply toHugatree737

Hi! Insurance will definitely pay for a dietitian, most of the time. Just call your plan and ask! :) I'm a dietitian myself and insurance pays me all the time.

Bassetmommer profile image
BassetmommerNKF Ambassador

HI Hugatree,

The answer to this is not simple. Depends on what you are doing with it. Cooking and baking with ICBINB does not work the same way as butter. The water content is higher and the consistency is wrong. Can't make a roux (white sauce) with it and you can't bake with it either. But... I am not doing much of those things now anyways.

However, for eating, the caloric content in ICBINB is better than butter. I use Land O Lake lite butter (50 cals) for things like bread because I do not like the taste of any margarine on bread. But, I use ICBINB spray for my veggies and pasta all the time. Key thing is moderation.

pritikin.com/is-i-cant-beli...

Hugatree737 profile image
Hugatree737 in reply toBassetmommer

That sounds great. I'm going to try that. I don't like margarine either!

RhenDutchess123 profile image
RhenDutchess123

My Nephologist and PD Trainer told me always butter....but sparingly...he said margarine and oleo were harder for the kidneys to break down....

Hugatree737 profile image
Hugatree737 in reply toRhenDutchess123

Thank-you. That's what I hear too. I'm going to try light butter. I do need to lower my cholesterol.

RhenDutchess123 profile image
RhenDutchess123 in reply toHugatree737

And unsalted...

Zazzel profile image
Zazzel

My holistic kidney doctor said use butter only sparingly and then it should be grass fed which is higher than Omega 3. She said not to use any margerine or other processed type oils. Olive oil or macadamia oil are always better choices as they are higher in Omega 3. Organic palm oil can be used sparingly at higher temps.

As usual, it depends on who you talk to and there are varying opinions on what is the best choice. Wish it were easier to decide.

Hugatree737 profile image
Hugatree737 in reply toZazzel

Thank-you. I appreciate the oils information. I'm going to get some!

JimVanHorn profile image
JimVanHorn

I just don't use butter. For breakfast I use one ounce of cinnamon apple sauce on my toast.

Hugatree737 profile image
Hugatree737 in reply toJimVanHorn

That sounds good. Do you make it yourself or is it something already made?

JimVanHorn profile image
JimVanHorn in reply toHugatree737

If I but it it comes from an organic only store, and I add the cinnamon.

RonaldoResuelto profile image
RonaldoResuelto

If calories are a concern, lower calorie versions of both butter and ICBINB are available. The fat free version of ICBINB was discontinued. Some margarines and some butters add olive oil which is considered healthier. Check out Smart Balance. If you choose to use margarine, the softer versions and sprays are less hydrogenated and thus have less trans fats. Maintaining my weight is a problem for me since I went mostly vegan. So, in the interest of controlling my blood pressure, I use salt free regular butter. I haven't been able to find a salt free margarine. My GFR is 53.

RhenDutchess123 profile image
RhenDutchess123 in reply toRonaldoResuelto

I use Unsalted butter too....i always have...even before i knew i had CKD...i love to cook and bake...and most well written recepi will specify unsalted butter over regular butter...especially in gravys...that has probably blessed me with a very slow progression of CKD...I also rinse canned vegetables...it removes 40 % of sodium in them just with that simple act...and i never thought about it but i have never seen unsalted margarine either...lol

RonaldoResuelto profile image
RonaldoResuelto in reply toRhenDutchess123

I haven't tried washing canned vegetables. I buy the no salt or low salt variety when I can find it. I believe I wlil try the rinsing though. Via salt avoidance, the judicious use of potassium, and moderate exercise, I've managed to reduce my systolic blood pressure, and keep it down. The potassium option should be used with precaution for anyone with a tendency toward hyperkalemia. My potassium levels are staying within bounds. After a while, low salt tastes normal, and all those high sodium foods taste salty. They are. We have simply become accustomed to them. Our tastes adjust. Certain things, however, like popcorn, I still don't like unsalted. I avoid those things, use a salt substitute, or Mrs Dash. But remember, if you there is any possibility that you might be potassium sensitive, be careful. Look at the label of those substitutes. Of course, the rules change for those in more advanced stages of CKD.

Also, you can get too little sodium. It is an essential nutrient. I am a little concerned that I may go to far in limiting salt. It's easier to just avoid salt than actually keep track of my consumption.

Krazykatlady profile image
Krazykatlady in reply toRonaldoResuelto

I'm a big popcorn lover--a leftover from my childhood! It's true, without salt, it's just not the same. So I turn to the other two old childhood memories--a humongous seasoning/spice collection and the fun of playing with my food. What I tried with popcorn was, cinnamon, pumpkin pie spice, nutmeg, ginger, cloves, coconut shreds, oh yes, and the butter! That was my weirdest concoction so far. A girl's gotta do whatta girl's gotta do!

RonaldoResuelto profile image
RonaldoResuelto in reply toRhenDutchess123

Smart Balance has a low sodium margarine.

Hugatree737 profile image
Hugatree737 in reply toRonaldoResuelto

Thanks. I'm learning so much here!

RhenDutchess123 profile image
RhenDutchess123

For my Popcorn I sprinkle it with black pepper...did it by accident once and it tastes amazing...I dont worry about getting too low on sodium ...unless you are on diretic...but if I have to pick between the two, I would choose to be low side...The canned vegetables are the worst...they are not just sealed in salt...they are full of phosphorus as a preservative...and I lnow what you mean by stopping salt is no biggie...everything is too salty....

Krazykatlady profile image
Krazykatlady in reply toRhenDutchess123

I did that on purpose...with shredded Mexican cheese and this terrific salt-free seasoning from Puritans Pride. They have two I found, and one has orange in it! Both are delightful.

RonaldoResuelto profile image
RonaldoResuelto in reply toKrazykatlady

I'll check Puritans Pride out. Gotta have butter or butter flavored oil, or the seasonings won't stick. If the popcorn is already in oil, butter flavoring seasoning will work. The low-salt varieties of microwave popcorn still have considerable sodium. I used regular popcorn (no oil included), sprayed the inside of a paper bag with oil, introduced popcorn, placed the bag in the microwave, and let it pop until it slowed. My wife was afraid I was going to set the microwave on fire. It worked great. I did keep an eye on it while it was popping though.

Hugatree737 profile image
Hugatree737

Thank-you! That helps so much.

Krazykatlady profile image
Krazykatlady

I didn't know about the paper bag hack! That's cool! Cheaper than the silicone microwave popcorn dealiebobber I got at Amazon. You don't need oil if you don't want any. And it collapses.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Biopsy or not?

Hello everyone It has been a month since I learned about my CKD. I have stage 3b, my creatinine...
tas1kubra profile image

Whats your newest favorite food, and what, if anything did you have to give up?

In changing your diet to include kidney friendly foods, what new foods did you discover that you...
Bassetmommer profile image
NKF Ambassador

CKD 3 or not?

My EGFR last year was 57 and this year is 56. I asked my PCP for a referral to a nephrologist and...
Pappy58 profile image

CKD or not?

Hi all, in need of advice please. Went to my surgery for a blood test a few weeks back just a FBC,...
Calm2 profile image

Snack ideas?

Hello all! I'm trying to eat healthier with my snacking habits, but I'm getting tired of the usual...
Ladybug_05 profile image

Moderation team

See all
PattyM_NKF profile image
PattyM_NKFModerator
DorisL_NKF profile image
DorisL_NKFModerator

Top community tags

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.