BBC programme on circumcision - Men's Health Foru...

Men's Health Forum (Penis Health)

36,378 members9,070 posts

BBC programme on circumcision

foreskinsaver profile image
10 Replies

We have been advised that the film entitled A Cut Too Far? Male Circumcision, will be broadcast on BBC1, Thursday, July 18, at 22:35

bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0006wj8

Every year in the UK thousands of baby boys are circumcised for religious or cultural reasons. The practice, which involves removing a small part of their penis, is one of the most common surgical procedures in the world. But several European countries are considering a ban on circumcision, unless there are medical reasons for the operation to be carried out. Is it something we should consider banning here?

Written by
foreskinsaver profile image
foreskinsaver
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
10 Replies

Just had a circumcision so definitely gonna watch this program not sure if this program will be available outside the Uk as when was in Australia sometime visiting family and friends i couldn't get access to British on live media players because of copy right rules but definitely think this could be interesting to see was also wondering why in America 90 per cent of new born baby boys have this done its very interesting to see which countries do this while others won't unless you pay for it.

in reply to

It’s done routinely in the USA so the doctors can make a bit more money for a few minutes work.

foreskinsaver profile image
foreskinsaver in reply to

Not sure if it will be available outside the UK. I helped the programmes Associate Producer Ali May with his research for the film. Ali has written an inspiring article in the Huff Post entitled Child Protection Laws Are Clear – Except When It Comes To Male Circumcision. Here is the link: huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/... You ask why newborn babies have this done in the USA. The simple reason is that doctors are making money out of it. The circumcision rate has fallen in the USA, In some states it is now down to 50%

richlandfarmboy profile image
richlandfarmboy in reply toforeskinsaver

Please figure out how to broadcast this in the US, We have over 300,000,000 ignorant people in this county that need educated. Especially Doctors.

foreskinsaver profile image
foreskinsaver in reply torichlandfarmboy

I hope we will be able to get this in a version that can be seen outside the UK.

I just watched it. I’m left a bit confused. All the way through he seemed to be saying that it was an unnecessary procedure that neither Muslims nor Jews demanded, and met men who regretted having it done to them as infants... BUT in the end said that if it’s properly regulated then it should continue as if it was banned those people would continue to have it done in any case with less qualified people. Very dodgy logic I think. By the same token maybe the law should say there’s no point in trying to stop speeding motorists as they will continue to do it anyway? From my perspective his journalistic stance fell to bits in the last 2 minutes inexplicably and he reverted to the cultural norms without any real justification. All in all a confusing and confused piece I found.

foreskinsaver profile image
foreskinsaver in reply to

I totally agree. I appeared briefly in the programme but did not speak. I was at the meeting in stone where men were talking about the damage . There were some powerful stories that they did not use and Adnan was visibly shaken by them . I was disappointed in it.

in reply toforeskinsaver

Thanks for your response. Let’s see what the consensus feedback is.

foreskinsaver profile image
foreskinsaver in reply to

I have received some responses and they are not complimentary. I expect more tomorrow. I work for the charity 15 Square.

enricom23 profile image
enricom23

it should be outlawed worldwide. this isn't the bronze age.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Circumcision report on BBC TV

There is a lot of interest in circumcision on this forum. This 10 minute BBC report from East...
jimpollard profile image
Partner

Circumcision Questions

Hello, I have been seriously considering getting my penis circumcised for quite a while and have...

Unhappy With Circumcision.

Just wondering is anyone unhappy with the out come of there circumcision (NHS - Medical Reasons)...
madant09 profile image

Circumcision

Evenin fellas...I’m kinda Undecided as to you whether or not I want a circumcision...I’d like one...

High cut Circumcision

I had a high cut v shape circumcision. Done for religious reasons. Most foreskin on the under part...
As1014 profile image

Moderation team

Norwich1 profile image
Norwich1Moderator
jimpollard profile image
jimpollardPartner
mpntod profile image
mpntodPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.