Anesthetic eyedrops vs anesthetic injections - Macular Society

Macular Society

5,251 members2,600 posts

Anesthetic eyedrops vs anesthetic injections

Moptart profile image
17 Replies

I recently started monthly eyelea injections in June 2020 (3 so far). My doctor injects the anesthetic before eyelea. When I asked for anesthetic drops she said that due to the pandemic the practice is clearing and sanitizing rooms at a faster pace. Somehow this is not a good reason for me to endure 2 shots/eye!

She also mentioned the anesthetic shot provides better pain relief. I experience a lot of pain, I can’t imagine what it would be otherwise. I’m in the process of finding a second opinion from another ophthalmologist.

Anyone have a similar experience?

Written by
Moptart profile image
Moptart
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
17 Replies
Hrosie profile image
Hrosie

I attend an NHS eye clinic. I too have extra strong anaesthetic drops prior to my injection. Some people are more sensitive to pain than others. I have had 3 injections during the pandemic, since March, and am still treated with the drops.

Koalajane profile image
Koalajane

I have been receiving numbing drops before my Eylea injections throughout this pandemic.

kevinaki profile image
kevinaki

Why traumatize your eye with 2 injections ?

Find someone else....

Edman777 profile image
Edman777 in reply tokevinaki

The drops numb the surface of eye. The anesthetic injection only goes into the white of the eye and is required to numb the rest of the eyeball prior to the intravitreal injection. My doc uses both. The anesthetic injection is absolutely necessary to prevent pain during intravitreal injection. Are you sure that they are not also using anesthetic drops?

Moptart profile image
Moptart in reply toEdman777

The Numbing drops I receive are right before they measure eye pressure.

I Don’t know how long those last but usually the injections (anesthetic and eyelea) take place approximately 30 minutes later.

Do you think the initial numbing drop would last that long?

Edman777 profile image
Edman777 in reply toMoptart

Hi Moptart. The anesthetic drops last a while. Not sure exactly how long. The real test is if you can feel the anesthetic injection. I also receive the numbing drops for initial pressure tests. I then receive several drops of anesthetic prior to the procedure. They then wait several minutes before the anesthetic injection. On each occasion, I can feel a bit of a sting during the anesthetic injection. Nothing painful but a sting. The Avastin injection is painless.

springcross profile image
springcross

Hi Moptart. I am the same as the others on here and always have anaesthetic drops. Are you in the UK?

Moptart profile image
Moptart

Thank you to all who responded! I’m in San Francisco, Ca.

Since I’m new injections, I was curious to how much “worse” could discomfort be with drops vs shot.

I feel both shots and I have discomfort for a day following, with soreness where the anesthesia shot went in for up to a week. Plus, I experience subconjunctival hemorrhages lasting from a few days to 2 month!

The doctor never gave me the option to experience both.

ALMD profile image
ALMD in reply toMoptart

Please change your practitioner. With an experienced one there is no pain. The subconjunctival injection has always been pain free for me. I have had 34 eyelea injections with both methods. Re pain, I prefer the 2 painless injections.

ALMD profile image
ALMD

I live between England and Belgium. In Belgium I have two injections and both are totally pain free. In Oxford I have one with the anaesthetic drops and there is some pain on injection.

Another difference which affects me is that Betadine is used instead of the iodine, to which I am allergic, used in Oxford. Protocols vary between practitioners so please check other practices.

Retired130 profile image
Retired130

I'm in the USA. In PA. I spend 6 months in PA & 6 months in FL, so I have 2 Retina Specialists - one in each state. I get an Eylea shot in my right eye every 7 to 8 weeks.

The FL doctor only uses anesthetic drops. He puts the drops in, 5 minutes later he puts the drops in again, and then 5 to 8 minutes later he puts the drops in again & about 2 minutes later he administers the Betadine and then does the injection. This procedure has been very good for me with little to no pain when getting the shot & a quick recovery if there is the slight pain.

My PA Retina Specialist has used 3 anesthetic methods on me over the past 3 years. At first he was using the drops in 3 doses 5 minutes apart like the other doctor & things were great just like in FL. However, his supply of anesthetic drops ran out & he said there was a shortage of the drops so he could not get any delivered for a while. So he switch to an anesthetic gel. Though he applied 3 doses, the gel did not work as well as the drops & I felt pain and afterward had pain for most of the day. Next visit he still had not gotten a delivery of drops & I told him I did not like the gel, so he gave me the anesthetic shot before the Eylea shot. That was even worse than the gel as far as pain & discomfort after the two injections. Next visit he went back to the gel & I was not happy at all. Next visit after that he went back to the anesthetic shot and that again was worse than the gel. Finally he got in his shipment of anesthetic drops and, following his procedure of administering the drops 3 times at 5 minutes apart before giving me the Eylea shot, the Eylea injection was just about pain free with very little pain afterwards that totally went away after about 1 hour. So now I am happy again.

Summary - for me the anesthetic shot followed by the Eylea shot was horrible. 3 doses of the anesthetic gel followed by the Eylea shot was bad. The 3 doses of the anesthetic drops followed by the Eylea shot gave the best results & I continue to have the doctors in both locations use the drops.

Hope this helps.

JJnan profile image
JJnan

I've been having monthly inj throughout the pandemic, nothing had changed as far as injections go, they clean area with iodine , I have plenty of anaesthetic drops before and 1 drop of iodine ..no pain with inj x

Bluegreensea profile image
Bluegreensea

Hi Moptart

I too have anaesthetic drops before Eyelea injection. I'd have thought administering drops would be so much quicker, and as someone has already mentioned, limit the trauma and possible risks, to your eye.

When I have ozurdex implant I get anaesthetic drops then anaesthetic inj. Dont feel the anaesthetic injection. Then I get the implant, dont feel that either, maybe a dull push, at least not as painful as my years of antivegf inj were.

However, i believe the antivegf inj are usually given using a "guide" that's part of the injection instrument, the anaesthetic shot is freehand. That might dictate whether only doctors can give it.

StokeySue profile image
StokeySue in reply to

That makes sense to me - I’ve never encountered anaesthetic injections, surely the point of drops is that they go in before either needles or retractors? I’ve had 2 pandemic injections, both the usual anaesthetic drops

Shimano profile image
Shimano

An certainly relate to the severe pain but drops do nothing for me. Sounds like your doc is at least trying to find a solution. All the best. I know it’s hard.

thom3patty profile image
thom3patty

i receive extra numbing drops before an injection but still have a lot of pain after i called my dr before my last injection and asked for extra numbing AFTER my injection it helped like you wouldn't believe

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Eyelea injections

Yesterday I went to the eye clinic for an Eyelea injection. The anesthetic eye drops never work so...
RP1944 profile image

injections

Good afternoon, I have an update on my unfortunate experience last month with an Eyelea injection....
RP1944 profile image

Painful injections

I have been getting eye injections for several years and as I didn’t enjoy them they were not...
thom3patty profile image

Eyelea and Pain Killers

I don't take drugs, not even aspirin. However I have a choice between Eyelea and losing my eye....
Burnt profile image

Eyelea injections

I have been receiving eyelea injections since the end of December 2017 they have always been given...
thom3patty profile image

Moderation team

See all

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.