(Crazy) intermittent fasting of 16 hours ... - Healthy Evidence

Healthy Evidence

3,071 members452 posts

(Crazy) intermittent fasting of 16 hours everyday?

3 Replies

Hey, I have a friend that is starting this diet that tells him to do a long fasting of 16h. Basic biochemistry would tell me that most of the weight loss doing this will be due to glycogen and muscle mass loss, simply because gluconeogenesis would be happening quite A LOT if he does a 16h fasting everyday.

The guy that promotes that routine mentions some articles, but they all seem to be about intermittent diets where people eat 20% of their needs in one day (still able to keep blood glucose?) and eat normally on other days. Something like the 5:2 I suppose

Another point to consider would be that people doing (and promoting) that diet are actively training for muscle hypertrophy. Maybe they use other stuff like BCAAs formulas etc.

The only article I could find that would be close to that situation is about Ramadan fasting and performance of football players. Not surprisingly their performance was negatively affected by fasting: journals.tums.ac.ir/abs.asp...

Does something (crazy) like that even deserves a clinical trial?

Read more about...
3 Replies
JossS profile image
JossS

Here is a BBC article with a little info

bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-255...

in reply toJossS

Thanks for that! But the case I am describing they are advocating complete fasting, not just a drastic drop in calorie consumption. I think there is a major difference between eating little, but spread out during the day (not sure why that is considered fasting?), and not eating anything at all for 16h.

Hi Sipp. If people are going to do it in any numbers (as per Ramadan), I'd say it's probably worth at least observing the effects.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Are we looking at Obesity Science the wrong way?

As a heavily overweight person, I have an active interest in articles and opinions about obesity....
JossS profile image

VLCDs

The advice given about 800 calories a day diet is so out of date on the NHS website. I have been...
jrwm profile image

Dementia! Who really cares?

I was diagnosed with dementia in 2017. Now it has got to the stage invited by relatives for a...
Adlon57 profile image

Is there any evidence for the bullet-proof coffee craze?

It's made from filter coffee, two tablespoons of grass-fed butter and two tablespoons of...
Joel profile image

What evidence supports this proposal?

Much of today's news (other than something to do with Europe, Scotland, coal, ...) is filled with...
helvella profile image