Research in to the benefits of singing - Cure Parkinson's

Cure Parkinson's

26,583 members27,899 posts

Research in to the benefits of singing

3wishes profile image
12 Replies

fmhs.auckland.ac.nz/faculty...

Hi there. Recently there was an article online about Linda Ronstandt) stating that she as PD and this is the reason why she can no longer sing. I phoned my dad (who has PD) to ask if he can still sing and yes he can. Then I went to a presentation on brain research. See the article above about how singing can help people with PD.

Written by
3wishes profile image
3wishes
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
12 Replies
bigmama53 profile image
bigmama53

I have formed a singing group and have a speech therapist on board to help us improve our voices so that we can speak better and be understood and strengthen our voices to help us with the singing.

JohnPepper profile image
JohnPepper

Hi 3wishes. I have sung for many years, probably longer than Linda. I found that, at the time of being diagnosed my confidence to stand on stage had deserted me and my voice was very shaky. I stopped singing for many years. When I had recovered enough from many of my movement symptoms and had regained a lot of my self- confidence, I started to sing again to the old people, with whom I live. My voice is not as good as it was, but what do I expect at the age of 79. I do find that I get a lot of phlegm in my larynx, which does not help, but I can still sing.

Kind regards

John

bigmama53 profile image
bigmama53 in reply toJohnPepper

John, I found replacing cow's milk with goats milk solved the phlegm problem. I have to avoid anything which has cow's milk - a bit of a bore but made swallowing especially at night easier. If you do switch let mw know your experience.

JohnPepper profile image
JohnPepper in reply tobigmama53

Hi bigmmama. Thanks for this info. Are you able to get goat's yoghurt?

Kind regards

John

bigmama53 profile image
bigmama53 in reply toJohnPepper

Yes, very nice too!

Best

Val

JohnPepper profile image
JohnPepper in reply tobigmama53

Thanks Val

John

HealthSeeker7 profile image
HealthSeeker7 in reply toJohnPepper

Both dairy and wheat can cause phlegm. It's worth experimenting by cutting these out of your diet completely for a week to see if it makes a difference.

JohnPepper profile image
JohnPepper in reply toHealthSeeker7

Hi HealthSeeker7. Thanks for this info. I will stop eating yoghurt for a week and see what happens.

John

plainbob profile image
plainbob

About a year ago, on one of those excellent Radio 4 (UK) health programmes, there was a short piece to the effect that it is now thought that the voice may be one of the first faculties to be affected by PD, long before tremor, rigidity, hand-writing changes, dyskenesia, etc are first noticed. The latter are what send most of us to our GP for diagnosis, of course. Usually the changes to the voice are initially too small to be apparent to the person affected or an observer, but require analysis electronically.

I used to have a reasonable bass voice and enjoyed singing, harmonising, with a choir; it still is good at times but has gradually become unreliable in the sense of volume and timbre, although pitch remains good. Looking back, this may have started fifteen, even twenty years ago. I was first diagnosed about 7 years ago when tremor developed and one of the side effects was to make it difficult to hold a music score steady, made worse by the tension of the occasion. .

Singing is generally recognised as being good therapy anyway, whether or not a person has PD or any singing ability. So to .3wishes, JohnPepper, bigmama and the rest of the singers, all power to your elbows, enjoy and don't give up! God bless

3wishes profile image
3wishes

Thanks for your replies. I am most interested in the benefits of music and singing for lifting my dad's mood and his spirit. He mostly just sleeps and watches sport on t.v which drives my mother a bit crazy. He has bad depression and doesn't let her have friends over, so she goes out a lot. On a positive note, she takes him to the Parkinson's gym once a week and that seems to perk him up. The first sign of shaking was in his oesophagus. This makes swallowing food a bit hard. He also has a bit of dementia, but a better long term memory than my mum!

jillannf6 profile image
jillannf6

Hi I have PSP and sm still singing- it helps slow me down and is great for making music wuth others

lol,Jill

:-)

rory3028 profile image
rory3028

I have PD and was diagnosed in 1994 at age 54, but was told by more than one neurologist that my start date for PD was probably about 1988. I have many symptoms of PD but never developed the Parkinson's tremor. One of the things that bothers me the most, however, is the "freezing" in place of my feet, which often feel as if they weigh 200 pounds each and I can only take what I call "stutter steps." Strangely enough, one day as my daughter was helping me walk ad we were singing, we discovered that when we sing (and believe me it isn't pretty) I can actually walk in long steps and quite quickly and comfortably. We love to walk to the tune of "I could have danced all night" from the musical " The King and I", but it really doesn't matter what you sing (or hum), it really works for me. I know this isn't a big thing, certainly not a medical breakthrough, but it takes something that is really debilitating and makes it bearable. A number of months ago I saw a feature on network TV which said the same thing, and I am here to tell you that it surely helps

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Is there a link between attitudes to covid vaccination and the rejection of conventional medicine in the treatment of PD?

I was going to respond to one of Marc's posts about the lack of covid data in the USA with this...

Magnesium benefits in PD as Oral and Topical Application

Magnesium has many healthful benefits for PWPs and others with health issues. The right dose of the...

One foot in front of the other.

One of the tests my previous neurologist tried on me was to put one foot directly in front of the...

Going to the Hospital With Parkinson's DIsease

I want to share my story so that perhaps some of us can find a way to educate hospital staffs about...
Koko profile image

"Reflections of a Scientist with Parkinson's disease": An Invited Article in the Newsletter of the European Network on Nrf2

Prof. Antonio Cuadrado, a world leading neuroscientist from Madrid, is Chairman of the European...
wriga profile image

Moderation team

See all
CPT_Aleksandra profile image
CPT_AleksandraAdministrator
CPT_Anaya profile image
CPT_AnayaAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.