Knee replacement : I have had one knee... - Arthritis Action

Arthritis Action

7,536 members2,115 posts

Knee replacement

Nanlov profile image
16 Replies

I have had one knee replaced a few years ago and now have extreme pain, bone on bone, in the other knee.

I asked my GP for a referral and he said to try injections as there’s a long waiting list!

(I’ve tried these before and they only offered temporary and not much relief!)

Can I insist on a referral??

Written by
Nanlov profile image
Nanlov
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
16 Replies
1vern0n profile image
1vern0n

I think it varies from one area to another. My GP referred me to MSK where I was given injections for just over a year and when they stopped working it was then I was referred to the orthopaedic department for extra x rays and a knee replacement. This system can be known as "gate keeping". I had expected some sort of flush out first or a partial knee replacement but like you I had bone on bone and the consultant said that I needed a TKR.

Nanlov profile image
Nanlov in reply to 1vern0n

Seems to be a money saving exercise 🤦‍♀️

I’m going to see an Orthopaedic Consultant privately and see if he can recommend a FKR.

Happyrosie profile image
Happyrosie

in our area we start with MSK (the physios) and don’t see GP at all - the physios refer you.

Nanlov profile image
Nanlov in reply to Happyrosie

Could I ask what area please?

Happyrosie profile image
Happyrosie in reply to Nanlov

I’m in Sussex

Nanlov profile image
Nanlov in reply to Happyrosie

Thank you. I might ask for a physio referral and see where that leads too…

Nat107 profile image
Nat107 in reply to Happyrosie

Same with mine, I’m being referred to consultant after 1 year wait after being referred to physio as consultant won’t touch you until see. Physio

next step knee replacement she said do referral but just wondering if any alternative to have first before this. Iv had injections and don’t last long

piglette profile image
piglette

For my NHS hip I had to get funding and then agreement from the orthopaedic surgeon to put me on the waiting list. I believe the surgeon often does this. In my case it was my rheumatologist.

Nanlov profile image
Nanlov in reply to piglette

Thank you . Seems I’ll have to go privately for an Orthopaedic consultation and take it from there

piglette profile image
piglette in reply to Nanlov

I did that for my first hip. The orthopaedic surgeon said I would be in a wheelchair in six months, which may have helped. I paid for him and an x-ray. You will then have a letter to your GP.

katieoxo60 profile image
katieoxo60

Hi Nanlov you usually have to have tried all before Knee referral unless you have an accident and injure the leg. The Gp is correct its a long waiting list but it would be of benefit to be seeing a specialist or the orthopaedic department. Best Wishes

Nanlov profile image
Nanlov in reply to katieoxo60

Thank you.

Runrig01 profile image
Runrig01

Unfortunately you can’t insist on referral, as GPs have strict guidelines to follow re referral for joint surgery. Most guidelines insist on initially seeing a MSK team, with the aim of managing this in primary care, unless you have a red flag, which warrants surgeon to assess. That’s tends to be things like fever, weight loss,

Here’s an article which explains the process quite well.

rcseng.ac.uk/-/media/files/...

Hectorsmum2 profile image
Hectorsmum2

It my area you have to try all the other options first, pain killers, injections, exercise and braces. I think if none of these work you get you referral. A matter of ticking boxes.

Kneesandtoes profile image
Kneesandtoes

Have a look at Alyssa Kuhn’s Arthritis Adventure channel on YouTube. She has advice on bone on bone arthritis and how to lower inflammation.

Nanlov profile image
Nanlov in reply to Kneesandtoes

Thank you 😊

You may also like...

knee - replacement advice

terrible left knee problems for six years and last year was diagnosed with OA in the left knee...

TOTAL KNEE REPLACEMENT

and nerve pain. Since the op my back and feet have been twice as bad and I have a spasmodic pain...

Aids after knee replacement

total knee replacement next month.Advice, please, on aids to source beforehand. I already have an...

Partial knee replacement

Hi, after waiting just over two years I’m scheduled to have a partial knee replacement in March....

Knee replacement

years old and have just joined here. I have arthritis in both knees and have been told you have the...