Chemo vs Immunotherapy: Howdy all. In... - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

22,286 members27,986 posts

Chemo vs Immunotherapy

ChickenWrangler profile image
16 Replies

Howdy all. In the last three weeks or so I have been diagnosed with very aggressive stage 4 prostate cancer. It is has spread to my lymph nodes, innumerable lesions on bones from neck to knees with most centered around ribs. I am currently on Nubeqa and Lupron with docetaxel starting next week. I was diagnosed in Germany and the doctor there wanted me to take the Nubeqa and Lupron but use an experimental immunotherapy drug and stay away from chemo for the first few months. Has anyone else been in this sort of situation? I am a performer and have many big gigs coming up in the next 4-6 months. Has chemo affected anyone’s voice on this forum? How tired were you after stopping chemo? How long to recover strength? I am torn between this “miraculous” immunotherapy drug and starting chemo. I realize that there are individual reactions to chemo, but I’d like to get a generalized idea before starting and/or choosing which path to take. Thanks in advance!

Written by
ChickenWrangler profile image
ChickenWrangler
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
16 Replies
Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen

Chemo will be ineffective if you put it off. It has to be started around the same time as Nubeqa. There are no immunotherapies approved for your situation unless you are msi-hi/dMMR.

DannyMan profile image
DannyMan in reply toTall_Allen

Saw several of your knowledgeable comments on here - any thoughts for a novice to all this with my situation?

RyderLake2 profile image
RyderLake2

Hello,

You might also want to consider a radiopharmaceutical like Lutetium-177 as an alternative to chemotherapy. Germany has been a pioneer in this form of treatment

OzzieJ profile image
OzzieJ

Chemo is generally 6 blocks of 3 weeks. So in total 18 weeks. As I remember it I was very tired for 2 weeks but in the 3rd week I had recovered before the next cycle. Although it is cumulative so once you get to cycle 5 and 6 you will be more tired. During chemo I was still able to go skiing and worked through most of it. I had no voice impacts but taste was impacted during treatment. By about 4 weeks after chemo I had recovered although I caught pneumonia and ended up back in hospital. So you do have to be aware that your immune system can be compromised by the chemo treatment. Best of luck with your treatment.

TomsD1 profile image
TomsD1

In Australia I think they are starting with lutetium in chemo-naive cancer.

Cape1 profile image
Cape1

I’m at a very similar place and will get Stand alone Immunotherapy tomorrow morning. I was diagnosed 18 months ago, with metastatic PCa, and went on Relogolix and Darolutemide and quickly went down to .02. Stayed on for 10 months, and granted. Holiday when PSMA PET scan showed nothing in prostate and just one bone met, whereas there had been three. ( was told they NEVER see that)

During the holiday, my testosterone bounced back in 3-4 weeks to 500 and PSA rose to 18, over 4.5 months, at which time I went back on Relogolix and Darolutemide, and again PSA dropped rapidly. I, was at .125 last week. All scans and panels appeared normal as recently as May.

I thought I was in a good place, but 2-3 weeks ago had pain under right rib and scans and biopsy showed small cell spread to liver, even though panel remained good. Brain scan showed clear.

My MO at famous Boston hospital at first poo pooed it, as highly unlikely to go so fast in a bad direction, but then he seemed almost panicked, called me last Sunday morning, almost demanding I go on platinum based Chemo.

I declined the chemo, over his repeated objections, but said I’d consider stand alone Immunotherapy, at which point he agreed to “add that in”.

I said Stand alone, or nothing, which he reluctantly agreed to , although saying he NEVER does stand lone nd doesn’t expect it to work.

surely, all cancers are different, as are all patients, so it’s like Forrest Gump and Life as the box of chocolates ( you never know what you’ll get), but I turned up two points of light.

One being Dr Li, who has books and many YouTube video. He cured his own 80-year old mother with stand alone for eight years, and a family friend who is an RN infusion nurse at another famous Boston hospital specializing in melanoma, and yes I know that isn’t small cell, as I have.

However, she said they NEVER do Chemo, only Stand Alone, and are getting MANY total cures after 2-3 infusions.

This is Chess in 1000 dimensions, and this is my current direction, and time will tell. 🙏

dhccpa profile image
dhccpa in reply toCape1

What type of immunotherapy is this?

Cape1 profile image
Cape1 in reply todhccpa

Wrong thread? I’m not doing chemo. Only Immunotherapy called Atezolizumab

dhccpa profile image
dhccpa in reply toCape1

No, human error. I meant to ask the type of immunotherapy, which you answered. Sorry for the confusion.

dhccpa profile image
dhccpa

I could do chemo, but I chose immunotherapy (Provenge) first. The Prostate Cancer Foundation says in their guide that Provenge seems to work best if done before chemo, which influenced my thinking at least partially.

MarylandGuy profile image
MarylandGuy in reply todhccpa

how well did provenge work?

dhccpa profile image
dhccpa in reply toMarylandGuy

It's too early to tell yet. I just finished up Monday. Based upon what I've read, since it is not supposed to reduce PSA or stop existing metastases to disappear, it may be difficult to determine exactly what it did anytime soon. But I'm glad I did it at my current status rather than later.

MarylandGuy profile image
MarylandGuy in reply todhccpa

Ok. I am in a similar boat. I have had treatment one of three a few days ago. I did have an adverse reaction of chills and shaking. They paused, gave me meds and were able to finish.

dhccpa profile image
dhccpa in reply toMarylandGuy

I ha 2.5 hours of strong chills after I got home from the second dose, and low energy the next day. I had no reaction after 3rd dose, though arguable my energy levels are still not quite up to par. But I'm exercising regularly.

MarylandGuy profile image
MarylandGuy in reply todhccpa

I did not face much after the first dose at home except maybe muscle aches. Next week starts cycle two.

dhccpa profile image
dhccpa in reply toMarylandGuy

Good luck

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Abiraterone vs Nubeqa

I've been on Lupron only for 5 years, metastatic to bones. Generic AA would be the next cheapest...
dhccpa profile image

Should I undergo Triplet therapy?

Was diagnosed with stage-4 prostrate cancer with metastasis to lymph nodes and bones in April...
Samrecan profile image

CDK 12 mutation and Immunotherapy

Hi All, My PSA as is starting to rise on Arbi/Dexa. I have the CDK12 mutation which is apparently...
MikeMartin profile image

Cancer immunotherapy

My husband almost done with his chemo treatment (two more rounds) his oncologist both local and at...

Chemo with docetaxel?

I recently posted about my experience with Zytiga, and the proposed switch to Erleada, which I...
Arcticfox44 profile image

Moderation team

Bethishere profile image
BethishereAdministrator
Number6 profile image
Number6Administrator
Darryl profile image
DarrylPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.