Could BAT be our last chance? - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

21,051 members26,256 posts

Could BAT be our last chance?

Chris_Ali profile image
22 Replies

My husband (on Lupron, castration resistant and tried every treatment) checked into the hospital 10 days ago for intense bone pain that requires heavy morphine. He has weakened bone marrow with low platelets and low red blood cells. He's getting palliative radiation for pain in a few places. Can't walk due to pain. The hospital team says we can consider hospice next. But I'm considering starting BAT with him although his oncologist disapproves, and I would have to do it without their knowledge.

I feel like we have nothing lose except it may cause him more pain. But he's on so many painkillers now anyway. He's going to die within the next few months and BAT may have a slim chance of buying him more time. Plus making him feel better because of testosterone's positive side effects.

I'm afraid because I don't want to hurt him anymore. And I would have to figure out how to inject him with a lot of T. I've already discussed BAT with someone on this site who wasn't as far along as my hubby and got good results. He told me all about his experience and I'm about to read the BAT book on Amazon by Russ Hollyer.

I'm on my own because his pain meds make him loopy, although in the past he's said yes to supplementing his testosterone but not specifically BAT. Anyone have experience with BAT that could fortify us in our decision?

Written by
Chris_Ali profile image
Chris_Ali
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
22 Replies
Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen

That would certainly make his pain worse and his death sooner.

BAT has never been shown to buy men more time, and it has only ever been used in men who are asymptomatic.

In some men (about 30%) who are asymptomatic, it can possibly extend the time in which Xtandi delays progression. Here's a review of all the BAT trials to date:

prostatecancer.news/2016/09...

Do you really want to be responsible for creating more pain for him?

Chris_Ali profile image
Chris_Ali in reply to Tall_Allen

Well I understand BAR helps some people. We’ve tried everything else, especially androgen deprivation. And if I use a gel form of testosterone, then it doesn’t stay in his system so we could stop at any time. He’s already zonked out on pain medicine. Not sure he would feel much more pain than he already does.

I’d hate to have him feel more pain. But I’d also hate for him to die and for me to think I could have done something.

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply to Chris_Ali

"Well I understand BAT helps some people." No. There is absolutely no evidence that BAT "helps" men in your husband's situation. Testosterone has NEVER been given to men with painful metastases, because it would cause them to flare up and increase the pain. Yes, he could feel more pain than he already does. In fact, BAT has not been shown to increase survival in anyone, even asymptomatic men.

I understand your desperation, having been in your situation several times. But I'd hate to see you live with the guilt of increasing his misery during his last days.

KocoPr profile image
KocoPr

i am on BAT and I have to agree with TA. BAT isnt YOUR answer! I don’t know what is. I am so sorry for your situation. The doctors are giving him 2 months to live and have no more treatments. Clinical trials maybe but it sounds like he wouldn’t fit the criteria with only 2 months. I would not want more pain and meds to counter BAT bone pain flare up.

It’s the saddest thing to contemplate but it is unfortunately something most of us have gone through with loved ones. I am truy sorry you are going through this.

Take him home get hospice help, play his favorite music spend all your time with him and don’t forget to ask family and friends for help.

Chris_Ali profile image
Chris_Ali in reply to KocoPr

You said you’re on BAT. Do you regret it?

KocoPr profile image
KocoPr in reply to Chris_Ali

I made a long reply but i forgot to finish it.

I am absolutely loving BAT but be advised i use testosterone propianate and do my own injections. It is non standard of care and there is no proof as to how long i will stay hormone sensitive.

dhccpa profile image
dhccpa in reply to KocoPr

So at this moment you have not yet decided BAT is a positive, even for you?

KocoPr profile image
KocoPr in reply to dhccpa

Im not sure what you mean.

Let me say it is great for my well being. My cancer loves being fed androgens, and I love that it is controlled at this time.

It will be very hard to quantify my results since we don’t have enough data on HSPC patients on ADT, plus darolutamide. We also don’t have data and probably never will other than an n=1 (me), or n= 4 (a few others doing similar).

So if i had a choice which i do, i would still absolutely do pBAT again.

I am presently doing a month of high T, then a month on Orgo and Daro.

dhccpa profile image
dhccpa in reply to KocoPr

Thanks

KocoPr profile image
KocoPr in reply to dhccpa

No problem. The goal for us all is to delay resistance until a cure or much better treatments are found.

I am very optimistic with all the new things coming down the pipeline!

Also thanks to Max he is giving us the latest news.

dhccpa profile image
dhccpa in reply to KocoPr

Let's hope so. I'm a bit skeptical of true game changing treatment following failure of ADT, but hope I'm wrong!

Janhpr profile image
Janhpr

My thoughts are with you. BAT is not available in the UK on the NHS possibly for a good reason, this disease is cruel my husband has been fighting it for 15 years diagnosed in 2008, we are both 80 now and to a point he is still winning but treatment has taken its toll on his body ongoing Proctitis after radiotherapy, need to have some QOL, no good living if life is unbearable, my own personal thoughts. My husband had six treatments with good results of Lutetium but after 4 months PSA started to rise, not the miracle treatment we thought. He is now having R223 as no visceral mets, 4th treatment next week, just had CT on Saturday, he says he is feeling comparatively well, doing more normal things, up early, less fatigue so positive at the moment. The Hospice nurse did a home visit after a referral from the Oncology nurse and we have their number if we need help. Do get support from the Hospice who should help with pain management, thinking of you both Jan & Tony.

janebob99 profile image
janebob99

I'm sorry to hear about your husband's situation...

Here's a link to a .pdf called "A Patient's Guide to BAT" written by the inventor of the BAT protocol, Dr. Sam Denmeade at Johns Hopkins Univ.

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

Low levels of testosterone are well-known to be associated with higher levels of pain. I take high doses of morphine every day for chronic low back pain, and the pain clinic is always measuring my testosterone levels to make sure they are high enough.

The monthly shot of high dose testosterone used in the BAT protocol may help him to feel better in other ways. Less fatigue, better mood, more energy, etc.

The BAT therapy has been reported to increase pain levels in some men, however.

I would give it a try for one month, and see if it helps. Then, take it from there.

The monthly injection of high dose testosterone is hypothesized to "reset" the PCa cells to be sensitive again to ADT therapy. So, it's important that your husband remains on ADT during this therapy, Lupron or Orogovyz.

Good luck !

Bob

Chris_Ali profile image
Chris_Ali in reply to janebob99

How high do you keep your testosterone?

tarhoosier profile image
tarhoosier

ChrisAli: You CAN do something.

BAT is not that something.

You can make the best decisions for him. You can ease his path. You can comfort and love him as much as you can. You can give yourself permission to accept the future as it comes. You can care for yourself. All so valuable necessary.

Seasid profile image
Seasid

BAT is for asymptomatic men only.

janebob99 profile image
janebob99

My last T was 1026 ng/dl. But, I will be going on ADT in a few months, and it will drop to sub-castrate levels then

janebob99 profile image
janebob99

Hi, Chris.

I contacted Dr. Denmeade at Johns Hopkins, and received this response:

"We have seen therapeutic response and clinical benefit with BAT in asymptomatic patients. However, We do not give BAT to men with bone pain due to prostate cancer because BAT can make pain transiently worse.. BAT has never been evaluated for survival improvement in a formal trial. In the TRANSFORMER trial, survival for men who got BAT followed by Enzalutamide was 37.6 months vs 28 months for enzalutamide alone."

This is from the horse's mouth! Hope it is helpful.

Bob

OsloN profile image
OsloN in reply to janebob99

I am following the advice of Denmeade like in the STEP-UP trial, the sequential dynamic version. Two months of T Cypionat, then 1 month with complete AR blocking by Darolutamide. PSA rises in the first two months to 3, then drops by AR blocking to 0.2. The name of the game is AR manipulation. Have been doing this for a year, the values are the same.

When you study this mechanisms, you realize that BAT AND ARSi should be the treatment, not BAT alone.

I add the PARPi Olaparib in the BAT periods because of all the DSB having the BRCA2 mutation.

In 7F you sees what happens when SPA and Enza alternates, control the cancer.

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

Chris_Ali profile image
Chris_Ali

thank you Bob!

Azores1 profile image
Azores1

Why not ask dr Denmeade on phone consult or in person if possible? The folks here are typically no physicians.

OsloN profile image
OsloN in reply to Azores1

I have done that, Dr Denmeade has advised on the treatment, works very well.

You may also like...

Thought only this group would appreciate our last 60 hours

hard. My husband had his CT scan Tuesday and, as expected, it showed multiple bone metastases, but...

My first month of BAT therapy

first month on BAT therapy DAY 1 PSA 5 testosterone castrate level DAY 5 PSA 9.9 Testosterone...

What Are Reasons Not to Use Bipolar Androgen Therapy (BAT)?

Therapy (BAT) is the alternation of Androgen Deprivation Therapy with high doses of testosterone to...

Why does BAT work in so few?

Researchers at Johns Hopkins have now done extensive tissue analysis of men using BAT in the hopes...

Could I try BAT to restore sensitivity to previously used antiandrogen treatments.

switch to Enzalutamide. I was reading on the use of BAT to resensitize mCRPC. Would this be a...