Iodine and sea salt: I see a Dr. David... - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

22,371 members28,137 posts

Iodine and sea salt

lewicki profile image
23 Replies

I see a Dr. David Brownstein an alternative doctor in Michigan. He has written eight books two of them are about Iodine and sea salt.

He says Iodine and salt are very low in our diets.

He recommends Lugol's Iodine (a prescription ) and a Celtic Sea Salt from a mine in

Brittany France.

The salt does not have any Iodine.

Something I do daily.

Dosages are half teaspoon of the salt and 20 drops of the Iodine daily.

Just part of my routine.

Written by
lewicki profile image
lewicki
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
23 Replies

I would agree with you on the iodine....I add Morton's salt with iodine to some of my meals...but I also use the Himalayan pink salt as well...what's the deal with the Celtic sea salt...does it have a mineral the other salts do not?

lewicki profile image
lewicki in reply to

It has the 82 trace elements and Dr. Brownstein thinks it is best. Also, the amount of Iodine in table salt is very little and the salt is bleached and does not contain all of the trace elements.

in reply tolewicki

Yeah...I've read about the trace elements...but the key word is trace and the result is that there is very little trace of these elements to have any benefit..if a benefit exists at all.

lewicki profile image
lewicki in reply to

I think the thought is our blood is close to sea water and we are just making sure we get these trace elements I guess.

pjoshea13 profile image
pjoshea13

See these (very) old posts:

healthunlocked.com/advanced...

healthunlocked.com/advanced...

-Patrick

GeorgeGlass profile image
GeorgeGlass in reply topjoshea13

How did the iodine supplementation make you feel after taking them a few weeks? Any different? How about thyroid test results?

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen

What are you taking it for? Thyroid problems? Some people are allergic, and if your kidneys are malfunctioning, this is something to avoid (they require tests for creatinine clearance before the iodine contrast is given for a CT scan.)

lewicki profile image
lewicki in reply toTall_Allen

Good question. It is recommended by the doctor since we are low in Iodine. I do not add salt or cook with it or add to foods. I am going to stop it till after my PSMA scan I am doing may 14. thanks for the response.

lewicki profile image
lewicki in reply toTall_Allen

We all look for the magic bullet. Of the 20 or so men that I have known 70 or so years. Half have prostate cancer. Some have died of it and many died of other things. In the 50's and 60's we were testing the bomb. Remember when you could not eat the cranberries since a bomb cloud rained on the cranberry bogs in Minnesota? I and my friends all lived in Detroit and so what is the common denominator of this decease. Just thinking that Iodine may protect us. They say the ratio is one in five will get this. For my experience it is one in two at best. Just thoughts.

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply tolewicki

I think your horse has left the barn.

lewicki profile image
lewicki in reply toTall_Allen

Had to cut grass around the barn. Glad to be back.

TFBUNDY profile image
TFBUNDY

20 DROPS!!! What strength is the Lugol's? I thought I was pushing it at 4 drops of 7.5%. How many mg of iodine are you shooting for?

lewicki profile image
lewicki in reply toTFBUNDY

5% Concentration. I just follow Dr. David Brownstein's recommendation. He wrote a book Salt why we need it and cannot live without it. The label on the bag of salt says Celtic sea salt light grey Celtic. Available on Amazon.

GeorgesCalvez profile image
GeorgesCalvez

I live in Brittany with a Bretonne wife and chatte, that is a female cat in French by the way, it is also something else feminine, so not a word to bandy around unless your meaning is clear!

You do not get sea salt from a mine, you get rock salt from a mine, sea salt by definition has to come from the sea.

The flavour of sea salt is dependent on the grade; fleur de sel is white, very pure sodium chloride and tastes like salt, sel gris is grey and contains significant trace elements, it has a saltier, slightly bitter flavour.

I would be a bit careful with salt, particularly if you are on ADT, as it can cause enhanced blood pressure and that is not good. Bretons and Bretonnes are notorious for overdoing salt and they do have slightly enhanced blood pressure on average.

We have this lovely salted butter that has little crystals in it, great on hot toast, you get the melted butter and the little crystals as well, but it is best advised to take it in moderation.

Putting a pile of salt on your plate to dip your radishes or green onions in before eating is also a regional habit.

I would say that you are going a bit overboard with the iodine, if you have good kidney function, etc then it may not do you any harm, it will just pass out in your urine.

We eat quite a lot of fish including mussels and oysters so I suspect that the average Breton's iodine intake is far more than is required for normal thyroid function.

pjoshea13 profile image
pjoshea13 in reply toGeorgesCalvez

Hi Georges,

I grew up in Plymouth, England - a mere 159 miles north of the Brittany coast (159,000 miles since Brexit) & so grew up on the same seafood, to some extent. But here in the mountains of North Carolina, U.S., we are 1,250 miles from the best shellfish caught in northern waters. I haven't seen a live lobster since we moved here and I hate to think how long it took for the oysters to arrive.

Seafood doesn't figure much in the traditional local diet. Luckily for the old families, iodine was added to salt about a hundred years ago. These days, the health-conscious avoid salt and iodine insufficiency is probably common again.

I envy you your access to good seafood - if not your climate. The product Iodoral is considered to be a safe alternative to a dozen Belon, Rivière d'Etel, Croisic, Quiberon, Pernef, or Golfe du Morbihan twice a week.

Best, -Patrick

lewicki profile image
lewicki in reply toGeorgesCalvez

You are correct. This brand of salt is mined by hand. The brand is Celtic Sea Salt. See celticseasalt.com It is a light grey Celtic. Words off the package. Our cat is named Posy. Means a small bouquet of flowers.I like the word bandy. Thanks for the warning for blood pressure. In Michigan where I live there was a goiter problem 100 years ago since the soil is void of Iodine. This is about when they started to iodize the table salt. i think you would use a salt free butter. Think I will try this. Appears to be a great addition to our diets for getting the nutrients of the salt.

j-o-h-n profile image
j-o-h-n in reply toGeorgesCalvez

Greeting Georges, I want to thank you for giving me a new french word (CHATTE) that I can call my ex-wife...

Merci beaucoup.

Good Luck,Good Health and Good Humor.

j-o-h-n Wednesday 05/05/2021 8:06 PM DST - Cinco de Mayo

MateoBeach profile image
MateoBeach

Seaweeds are another option. Capsules of powdered kelp has all of the trace elements too. Much more tasty is fresh or pickled seaweed salad. Kanpai

GeorgeGlass profile image
GeorgeGlass

How did the iodine supplementation make you feel after taking them a few weeks? Any different? How about thyroid test results?

lewicki profile image
lewicki in reply toGeorgeGlass

I cannot say since I have been taking it for years. It may be a small part of why I am still here.

lewicki profile image
lewicki in reply toGeorgeGlass

I cannot tell since I have been taking it now for many years. I have recently increased the dosage to 30 drops.

GeorgeGlass profile image
GeorgeGlass in reply tolewicki

what does 30 drops equate to in milligrams? I have a sea iodine tablet from life extension that is a 1mg dose = 667% of RDA for iodine.

lewicki profile image
lewicki in reply toGeorgeGlass

The solution is a 5%. Called Lugols iodine. I am not sure how to covert to RDA. I will look into the answer.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Foods/Supplements-Vitamins: Iodine

If you search PubMed for <prostate iodine> you will get over 1,500 hits. Unfortunately, most are...
pjoshea13 profile image

How a high-salt intake inhibits tumors

They found that excessive salt inhibited the function of a type of immune cell scientists call...
George71 profile image

Iodine as a Prostate Cancer Preventative

I've been on a soapbox lately espousing the benefit of iodine supplementation. Here is an article...

Sea Cucumbers and their cytotoxic effect on PCa.

I saw something earlier on Sea Cucumbers from Sammamish. This is a follow up....
Spyder54 profile image

Iodine-125 Seeds & Cremation

A new paper, below, prompted this cheerful little post. Concerns an autopsy in Japan where: "We...
pjoshea13 profile image

Moderation team

Bethishere profile image
BethishereAdministrator
Number6 profile image
Number6Administrator
Darryl profile image
DarrylPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.