what is the highest PSA that you are ... - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

22,285 members27,986 posts

what is the highest PSA that you are ware of where PC was still contained in the prostate?

billyboy3 profile image
16 Replies

I have a fellow who has a psa of 29, yet his doc is insistent that his cancer has not spread beyond his prostate. At our centre, we use the number of 5.5 as the highest level beyond which the cancer has likely spread beyond the prostate. Please send me your thoughts on what value is being used as of late. Thanks boys and stay well!

Written by
billyboy3 profile image
billyboy3
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
16 Replies
Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen

There is no such value. Some PC puts out more PSA, some less. A PSA of 29 is defined as "high risk," however.

billyboy3 profile image
billyboy3 in reply toTall_Allen

Thanks TA. I recognize the limitation of the current psa test modality, as did Dr. Murphy, co-discover of the psa test. That said, what I am attempting to do is to respond to a fellow's very high psa-29 from 20 a year ago. At our own prostate/men's centre, we use a figure of 5.5 as a high point in terms of possible cure through surgery, with of course other supporting indicators.

That said, it would be interested and very valuable to know at what point can we predict/use the current psa as a stronger or weaker indicator. The answer would of course be in the results from men who underwent treatment at various psa's score and chart the resultant outcomes.

We thus need to have all men who have been cured respond to this question. Unfortunately, our system does NOT keep track of these results and I would guess that we see very few men on this site who have in fact been cured, so results of any size will be hard to get.

Hope this clears what I am seeking on this issue. Thanks.

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply tobillyboy3

That 5.5 number has no basis in fact. I have been cured - my PSA was 7.3 when I was treated. The NCCN localized risk groups group PSA into 3 groups: 0-10 may be low risk (but may also be intermediate or high risk), 11-20 may be intermediate risk (but may also be high risk), 20+ is always high risk. You do not seem to want to understand that risk stratification is multidimensional.

noirhole profile image
noirhole

Mine was 8.4 and in Bones and lymph nodes. Never gone higher than 14 or lower than 2.5.

Zetabow profile image
Zetabow

Mine was 1386 on initial blood test, down to 21 now after 2 months of Hormone treatment.

CalBear74 profile image
CalBear74

Has the prostate been measured? PSA should roughly correlate with the volume of the prostate. BPH therefore becomes a significant factor; however, that measure of volume is never a guarantee that 100% of the cells composing the prostate at any time are cancer free. As the number rises so do the probabilities of some mutated cells being present. Of course, biopsies hope to extract some of these cells, but it may not always happen in the early stages.

I am not an MD; this reflect's my AZ urologist's patient ed efforts years ago.

Magnus1964 profile image
Magnus1964

29 is high but what you need to focus on is change and doubling time.

tarhoosier profile image
tarhoosier

I have a friend who had rising psa over a few years with several negative biopsies. When it reached 26 the urologist did a perineal biopsy, that is addressing the area between the scrotum and anus for biopsy access. Finally found the tumor. His surgery was successful and no return after 15 years. I cannot recall his gleason grade or score. Some of his psa may have been from prostatitis.

George71 profile image
George71

billyboy3,

Apparently if the PSA is under 20 at the time of diagnosis the chances of being metastatic is less than 8%.

all other groups are under 5%.

PSA levels at initial cancer diagnosis were divided into four groups: 0.2 to 3.9, 4.0 to 10.0, 10.1 to 20, and greater than 20 ng/mL. The ratio of metastatic prostate cancer compared with total prostate cancer diagnoses was compared for each year according to group.

"The proportion of metastatic prostate cancer present at initial diagnosis increased over the 10-year period for every PSA group, with the most significant proportional increase observed in patients with PSA levels greater than 20 ng/mL, from 8.5% (2004) to 22.9% (2014) (Figure)"

clinicaloncology.com/Prosta...

George71 profile image
George71

At the time of my biopsy my PSA was 10 -- my urologist said he had 2 patients with BPH -- and PSAs around 15 for 10 years and several biopsies were negative. He said he thought the chances of me even having cancer at all was 40% I had it -- 60% I did not.

CreativeOne profile image
CreativeOne

My PSA was 6.1 in 2001, slowly climbed to 38.7 in 2015. Needle biopsy August of 2015. 7 of 12 cores were 100% cancer and cancer was present in all other cores, to a lesser degree. Elected RRP surgery in 2015. pT3b M1 N0 Gleason 4+3=7 positive margins, and cancer present on bladder neck and urethra. PSA was never zero, and the doubling rate now is about 3.8 months, diagnosed as aggressive stage 4. Doctor recommended RT and ADT, but I chose to wait. After 4.5 years, I have only done diet changes and vitamin/mineral supplementations so far, but PSA was 8.23 in January of 2019. Started Banerji prostate cancer protocol of homeopathy January 23, 2019. PSA is due again in April (3 weeks from now) and we will see where my PSA is then, and I will decide what I want to do next.

Big_Mcc profile image
Big_Mcc in reply toCreativeOne

Please give an update on your new PSA level when you have the results. Good luck

CreativeOne profile image
CreativeOne in reply toBig_Mcc

As of 10/21/2021 My PSA is 7.53 and it is now 3 years since the post you read. I had a cystoscopy done 8/24/2021. Dr. found many small prostate cancer tumors at the neck of my bladder, narrowing and restricting flow, but not progressing much beyond my surgery in 2015. So far, no signs of any metastasis to bone or site other than my bladder. I haven't had any scans of any type done. I still have declined ADT, RT, Chemo, etc. I've gotten comfortable with my supra-pubic catheter setup and have a quality of life I like. I continue to use homeopathy and some hemp CBD products, but no other meds other than a low dose of metoprolol for atrial fibrillation.

Big_Mcc profile image
Big_Mcc

Hi. My PSA was 28.0 when diagnosed N0M0 yet it was already extracapsular and as such I was denied surgery and only offered EBRT June 2017 + ADT for 30 months. It was a take it or leave it choice and one Im still bitter about. I was defined as incurable on the basis of micromets. No idea how they knew micromets were present except possibly based on previous experience. PSA is now 4 and Im on the waiting list for next treatment. UK based. So yes, with a PSA of 29 his cancer may well be outside the prostate and apparently he may have micromets.

Boywonder56 profile image
Boywonder56

Psa 12 at dx stg1v with mets....psa had doubled in 1mo....im in mangus camp...

Mascouche profile image
Mascouche

Only a scan can determine if it is contained or spread out.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Proud and honored to announce that Cleodwoman is now moderator of the Prostate Cancer Caregivers group.

Proud and honored to announce that Cleodwoman is now moderator of the Prostate Cancer Caregivers...
Darryl profile image
Partner

Advanced (stage 4) group

I'm looking for a group that "deals' in stage, 3,4 prostate cancer, cancer that has spread beyond...

What happens in the very end stages of Metastasized Stage 4 prostate cancer?

What happens in the very end stages of Metastasized Stage 4 prostate cancer?...
cesanon profile image

What is the significance of high ALP in advanced prostrate cancer patients?

My father has been diagnosed with advanced metastatic prostate cancer. Gleason score-9 PSA-310...
Rahul_Patel profile image

Just checking in to make sure I don’t need to be doing anything else at this time?

Hi all, my father tested with 226PSA has received the results from his CT scan and Bone Scan....
FormulaRob profile image