1lbs off BMI??: I don't understand what... - Weight Loss Support

Weight Loss Support

114,976 members61,218 posts

1lbs off BMI??

Kerry82 profile image
10 Replies

I don't understand what BMI is?

two weeks ago my Bmi was 25.7 and now it's 25.3 according to the boots machine is this good?, it does say for my weight and height I should be between 18.5 and 25 so for me that's saying that I'm over weight.

Even if I don't understand it I'm loosing weight a way so I'm happy with that

Written by
Kerry82 profile image
Kerry82
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
10 Replies
HRHGaby profile image
HRHGaby

BMI is proportional to mass and inversely proportional to the square of the height. A BMI from 18.5 up to 25 may indicate optimal weight, a BMI lower than 18.5 suggests the person is underweight, a number from 25 up to 30 may indicate the person is overweight, and a number from 30 upwards suggests the person is obese. You can check your BMI here: bmicalculator.org/#tabs-2

Kerry82 profile image
Kerry82 in reply to HRHGaby

Thanks just check and it just clarified that I'm over weight, it was like a alarm saying "OVERWRIGHT OVERWEIGHT"

Thanks for that anyway I'll it internet to keep checking

Judywood profile image
Judywood

Yes you are correct - anything between 18.5 and 25 BMI is regarded as a healthy weight! 25.3 is brilliant and getting closer to 'healthy weight' - 25.3 is classed as overweight - but obviously not by much! Continue what you are doing and you'll be under 25 in no time! BMI doesn't cover all people - youngsters, athletes, rugby players, pregnant ladies, etc. But for many ordinary folks it gives a target of sorts. Don't go anywhere near BMI 18 - or I'll start worrying about you!

Judywood profile image
Judywood in reply to Judywood

Phew! Just read HRHGaby's reply - glad we agree!

OlsBean profile image
OlsBean

BMI should be used as a rough guide only, especially the closer you are to the "Normal Range" as it is uses what is considered by lots as an outdated formula (from Victorian times I think but don't quote me!) that does not take into account the fact that a taller persons will have proportionally larger arms, legs and torso in comparison to a shorter ones. There are online calculators that use an updated formula but once again you really should not be too concerned when you are close to the "Normal Range". BMI is great quick tool/calculation for Healthcare Professionals to quickly identify and classify patience that are very overweight/obese or underweight.

Jase44 profile image
Jase44

Kerry BMI is total rubbish I used to have a boss we called lofty (he was very short) who was 9 stone. He could reach level 16 on the shuttle run beep test yet his BMI said he was obese. We all laughed as he was the fittest bloke we new. If I was my ideal BMI I would be 12 stone. Can u imagine a 6'4" bloke at 12 stone is look like a rake. Lol. So don't worry to much unless your pushing 30 plus I my eyes regards J

Judywood profile image
Judywood in reply to Jase44

But that was because Lofty was "the fittest bloke you knew" !

Kerry82 profile image
Kerry82

Ha ha that made laugh jase44, I just didn't understand it as long as my weight drops that's all I'm concentrating on

Jase44 profile image
Jase44 in reply to Kerry82

Excellent Kerry that's all you have to worry about ;)

secondhandrose2 profile image
secondhandrose2

Yes, that's good, it's going down. It will go down gradually as you lose weight, because BMI is the ratio of fat to height (a rough estimate unless you have scales that measure it. There is an expected weight for your height and the ratio between them is said to determine (roughly) what your BMI is, it's a guide for medics to determine risk for ops, etc but a useful way of knowing roughly what you should ideally weigh.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

BMI

BMI seems to be the thing that everyone worries about. I have lost 7st over the last 13 months, I'm...

Body fat vs BMI

Hi all. Hope everyones weight loss is going well and keep up the good work. I was curious about...

BMI Calculators?

Does anyone know of a good BMI calculator? The one's I have tried say that my weight should be...

What's the "Healthy BMI" badge for?

I got this badge last week (happily gone now), and I just saw @[1274895] turning it down. I don't...

BMI 25 or BMI 22

Every time I go on the WiiFit it tells me that my ideal weight is around 10 stone 5 pounds (BMI...