Concerns that testing in UK is getting worse - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,936 members161,765 posts

Concerns that testing in UK is getting worse

Algic profile image
23 Replies

I'm hearing that there are moved circulated to move to just Tsh testing only . This will be completely useless. Private testing is not the answer for all as most people can't afford basics at the moment. So many are struggling. Without being political the NHS has been mismanaged and starved of recognition.

Currently NICE are backing only Tsh and T4 testing. T3 was requested by Gp with clinical reasoning. It wasn't done.

ITT are focusing on the T3 campaign. We need proper testing for Gps to manage our condition .

I'm thinking of starting a petition to get this debated in parliament , that the current test fails.

Written by
Algic profile image
Algic
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
23 Replies
RedApple profile image
RedAppleAdministrator

Algic, TSH only testing has been the norm in the UK for many, many years. FT4 only being tested if TSH is below range. FT3 is very rarely tested, regardless of reason for request by GP/Endo, as not deemed necessary or useful.

Rather than starting your own petition, it would be far better to get as many people as you can to sign the current Govt Petition by Dr Peter Taylor for funding to enable research into the need for T3, which would include FT3 testing.

Give more funding for thyroid research and patients after price hike petition.parliament.uk/peti...

Algic profile image
Algic in reply to RedApple

Actually in our area we have T4 testing but for how long. How can we argue the need if no thyroid hormone is being measured and only pituitary hormone is measured. We should be billing our ogs for our thyroid tests . They are failing us. Nobody is getting the same level of care we got 20 yrs ago and that was poor. Nobody is fighting for the basic care we have lost. I saw an endo that didn't even know where the thyroid was and thought a ct was the same as a MR. And nothing changes in 2 years. (she was later examined under clinical governance and is no longer employed) it's not just T3 but actual proper care we need.

Bean101 profile image
Bean101

My Dr requested Aldosterone and renin blood tests due to symptoms and very high renin in the past.. the lab refused to do it

HealthStarDust profile image
HealthStarDust in reply to Bean101

Have you actually spoken to the lab about this? I get the sense a lot of times a GP says this, but in fact the GP has ordered the test incorrectly for the lab to process. This happened to me and another GP ordered the test the correct way. Suffice to say, I didn’t go back to the GP who downer even know how to order tests!

Algic profile image
Algic in reply to HealthStarDust

Gp wrote on the form full reason why

HealthStarDust profile image
HealthStarDust in reply to Algic

Ah! Oh. All my forms have reason for testing, they have to but as I found out, that doesn’t mean the correct test was ordered on the system in the particular way that the lab requires. Hence, speaking to the lab is helpful to know why they refused.

It’s suspect a lot of the times when tests are refused it is because the GP selected the wrong test.

FancyPants54 profile image
FancyPants54

I must be lucky then. My GP request form, completed by the nurse for my private endo visits always test FT3 for me. I've never had a refusal. So it's probably a postcode lottery like so much else in the NHS these days.

HealthStarDust profile image
HealthStarDust in reply to FancyPants54

I think it’s a both postcode and GP lottery. Some are too inept at ordering the right tests in the particular way the lab requires. Or, just tell us lies as they don’t like an informed patient. Or, just would prefer not to protect their own egos as they have no clue how to interpret them.

I haven’t had FT3 done yet, but I have had FT4 several times and T3 done via GP. I haven’t had any lab refusals yet thank god 🤞🏽

Algic profile image
Algic in reply to FancyPants54

That's the thing it's private not nhs

FancyPants54 profile image
FancyPants54 in reply to Algic

No, only the endo is private. All the tests are at my GP surgery. On the NHS.

greygoose profile image
greygoose

I don't think testing FT3 would improve treatment because the majority of GPs don't even know what T3 is. And can't even interpret a TSH test correctly. Education of GPs needs improving before anything else can be done.

HealthStarDust profile image
HealthStarDust in reply to greygoose

Since no one is willing to educate them, sadly it falls on us to work collaboratively with them as far as possible. And, even more so for many who have to rely on the NHS.

Not an easy world we navigate.

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply to HealthStarDust

Not easy at all. But doctors, for the most part, are resistant to learning from patients. They think we're all idiots!

HealthStarDust profile image
HealthStarDust in reply to greygoose

While, few, many can be reasoned with… eventually. It’s hit and miss.

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply to HealthStarDust

Oh it certainly is! I had one doctor refuse me T3 because he didn't know what it was. And another that prescribed T3 because he didn't know what it was. Depends so much on the individual character of the doctor, as well as his level if thyroid knowledge.

HealthStarDust profile image
HealthStarDust in reply to greygoose

They need rehabilitating GG! We need some kind of clinic to literally rehabilitate these professionals to have some clinical curiosity, positive risk taking, and just care to learn how to treat hypothyroidism.

We can throw in some education on bedside manner as an add on.

The whole thing is a global disgrace, and, I’m having to remind myself that there are some good ones out there who at least seem willing to learn alongside you.

The other day a GP enquired why my dose was increased when TSH in range, to which I replied we simply don’t know where in that range my wellbeing is, hence it’s a range! This opened up a conversation and agreement on the limitations of TSH. It’s not like they don’t know. It just seems they need reminding!

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply to HealthStarDust

They need rehabilitating GG!

Well, that's what I said in the first place!🤣🤣🤣

HealthStarDust profile image
HealthStarDust in reply to greygoose

Sneaky 😌 And, until that happens, we need to be both patients and educators/rehabilitators and help them understand tests.

😇

Algic profile image
Algic in reply to greygoose

You would be surprised prior to covid gps were being trained on how to manage and read results mine were

Fruitandnutcase profile image
Fruitandnutcase

I had Graves’ disease back in 2012 and never ever had my T3 checked - even when the consultant put it on the list to be done. Anytime my thyroid has been tested recently it has only been TSH. So I do my own home fingerpick test with Medichecks and have everything recommended by TUK done annually.

Have signed Dr Taylor’s petition.

HealthStarDust profile image
HealthStarDust

That’s a good system. I can see blood results but not which tests have been ordered. Unless you mean consultation notes which are not indicative of anything. Is it on a certain app or can you just see it on NHS app?

DippyDame profile image
DippyDame

It's going to take a Damascene conversion!!

Have you read this?

thyroiduk.org/about-thyroid...

Algic profile image
Algic

Actually it costs one pound yes a pound for the nhs to do a TSH t3 and T4 I did some research on this. So those who pay for private testing ask for a breakdown.

You may also like...

Normal blood tests again but still feeling awful and getting worse.

Following my blood test on 21/6/2019 to see if I am Hypothyroid the results have come back normal...

Depression getting worse

150 but I worry that as I'm small and 9st it will harm my heart as my TSH is already low. Thanks...

Hair Loss getting worse

with hypo thyrodism tsh was 5.1. I was put on levothyroxine 50mcg then tests showed tsh down to 1.4...

Concerned after blood test

Annual thyroid blood tests done last week Results sound concerning as tsh 0.08, T4 20.3. Both...

Concern about Blue Horizon test for thyroid 3

blood test 4th April with Blue Horizon used a new lab The range posted to me with result we TSH...