[i][b]'Brain fog' sufferers to be tested for la... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

141,244 members166,489 posts

[i][b]'Brain fog' sufferers to be tested for lack of B12 [/b][/i]

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministrator
19 Replies

'Brain fog' sufferers to be tested for lack of B12

By Henry Bodkin

OLDER people experiencing "brain fog" should be tested for vitamin B12 doctors with the aim of improving the ing B12 as we age. deficiency, the health watchdog has rate of diagnosis. said.

Experts say as many as one in 20 people over 60 and one in 10 over 75 could be suffering from the deficiency, with dietary changes, the organisation said. overall numbers increasing because of the rise in veganism. The vitamin is found in meat, fish, eggs and dairy, but very little is contained in plants.

Common symptoms include fatigue, confusion, blurry vision and mental health problems such as anxiety and depression, which can make the deficiency hard to diagnose.

The Daily Telegraph - Front page - Wednesday 12th July 2023

Written by
helvella profile image
helvella
Administrator
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
19 Replies
TiggerMe profile image
TiggerMeAmbassador

No mention of upping the low end range then?

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministrator in reply toTiggerMe

I only posted the first column (approx.) - and without access cannot see what else there is when it continues on Page 2!

TiggerMe profile image
TiggerMeAmbassador in reply tohelvella

Oh, the suspense! We'll have to wait and see 🙃

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministrator in reply toTiggerMe

A real page turner... :-)

Suggest you look at the draft of the new B12 guidelines - I posted a link earlier.

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator

As I also have 'pernicious anaemia' my GP told me I can have as many B12 injections I rhink I may need, and I now have a monthlly jab instead of quarterly.

My mother also had P.A. but unfortunately her GP told her she needed no more B12 injections as her blood test was now fine.

The result of her GPs decision enabled my mother to develop stomach cancer which was the result of (I believe) stopping her B12 injections that enabled cancer to develop.

gabkad profile image
gabkad in reply toshaws

That's like filling the tank with petrol and assuming it never needs filling again.

I just shake my head with these idiot GPs.

I thought stomach cancer was from Helicobacter pylori infection. Maybe reduced ability to absorb B12 from food might be also from the damage done to the stomach lining by this bacterium. Of course antibody testing helps to determine if it is PA or something else. And endoscopy.

jade_s profile image
jade_s in reply togabkad

Gabkad, Autoimmune metaplastic atrophic gastritis (AMAG) is the cause of stomach cancer in PA. Seen on endoscopy. Damage to mostly corpus & something else i've forgotten, usually without antrum involvement. B12 injections are the treatment.

I've often wondered if supplementing acid (ACV, lime juice, betaine) would also help forestall it. The cancer develops as a side effect of low stomach causing changes to the gastric parietal cells (which secrete the acid) and/or the antibody attack on them (GPC ABs).

H pylori can also cause atrophic gastritic but then it's not thought to be immune related. Some suggest it is but i'm not completely convinced.

gabkad profile image
gabkad in reply tojade_s

But if parietal cells are damaged and the lining of the stomach is no longer normal cells, then the digestion can't be good. Proteins wouldn't be broken down to amino acids and iron wouldn't be well absorbed either. Plus other stuff as well. Sounds terrible.

My paternal grandmother died from stomach cancer.

jade_s profile image
jade_s in reply togabkad

Indeed :( That's why regular endoscopic screening & nutrient testing is advised.

What blows my mind is that extra acid supplementation is not advised. Seems totally illogical.

I'm very sorry to hear about your grandmother. And shaw's mother but i've said it before. x

My father died from esophageal cancer but my gastro now thinks it may have actually been stomach cancer that spread to the esophagus. He only had the 1 endoscopy after decades on PPIs. We knew nothing about b12 or any of this back then.

I get endoscopies & recently colonoscopies every ~3 years because of this history. My personal (nonmedical) opinion is that anyone with PA/B12D should also regularly get at least an endoscopy.

gabkad profile image
gabkad in reply tojade_s

My grandmother died in 1972 aged 76. She had a very hard life. My father had H. pylori so I always figured my grandmother probably had it too.

I've had antibody testing for H. pylori and it came back negative.

Definitely though hypothyroidism results in acid reflux and probably can also cause esophageal cancer from chronic burning.

ColderThanIce2 profile image
ColderThanIce2

Here is the other half, hope it's okay to post it here :)

"Vegans told to be aware of what they eat as experts criticise poor nutritional education"
Fruitandnutcase profile image
Fruitandnutcase in reply toColderThanIce2

Thanks for that - newspapers with paywalls are so annoying.

PRJ20 profile image
PRJ20 in reply toFruitandnutcase

and  helvella - thanks from me, too, helvella, and  ColderThanIce2

Re the getting behind annoying paywalls: try prepending the site with 12ft.io/ - it works with most but, not all paywalls.

Here's an example with an article I found in Pulse last month, though I'm not sure I've chosen the best article/that it makes much difference...

pulsetoday.co.uk/views/edit... 👈Without prepending

12ft.io/proxy?&q=https%3A%2... 👈With hopping over the 10ft wall.

12ft.io/proxy?ref=&q=https:... 👈A similar article on the B12 issue in Pulse. 😊 🪜

PRJ20 profile image
PRJ20 in reply toFruitandnutcase

helvella /ColderThanIce2 complete with the picture I accidentally removed due to IT problems! 🙄

Happy 12ft wall hopping folks!
gabkad profile image
gabkad

If someone is near the bottom of range (which varies quite wildly between labs and countries) then they would be considered fine and dandy? What are the targets? The article is quite useless in this regard. But at least it repeats the mantra that vegans have to supplement vitamin B12. (at the minimum)

And the other thing is elderly people tend to not consume a lot of leafy greens or fresh vegetables that contain folate. So you've got that as well to consider which is seemingly not considered.

Really, it gets complicated. They should just take a B complex capsule. But they won't unless the NHS pays for it. I think this government healthcare from birth to the grave has created a society that suffers from learned helplessness. There is an assumption that 'we paid into it' so it should provide everything but it just doesn't.

Over here a lot of seniors absolutely will not get any prescription filled that is not part of the drug benefit program much to their demise. I was at the pharmacy the other day picking up my prescriptions when the pharmacist says 'your medication is never covered by drug benefit'. My reply was 'I care about my health. I don't rely on the government.'

It's so bizarre. I'd rather pay for progesterone than have a hysterectomy. It's that simple. It costs me $55 per month to avoid the need for surgery. That's the way I look at it.

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministrator in reply togabkad

I think that 'won't pay' is only a part of the problem.

The supplement industry is full of snake oil - as well as decent things. And many simply don't have whatever it takes to investigate what is needed and follow it through. Many think they can get everything from a decent diet. (And some probably can!)

There could be room for a non-prescription prescription. A piece of paper (or an email or text message or whatever) which a doctor can use to say what the patient should be taking. For example, a dose of B12 and folate. The patient then presents that in a pharmacy or other supplement seller, or online, and they can see which products meet their needs. But the patient pays. This is simply a way to avoid mistakes, misunderstandings, inappropriate products.

One way this helps is it opens up the opportunity for patients to choose other attributes - lactose-free, capsule or tablet, etc.

1tuppence profile image
1tuppence in reply tohelvella

Your thoughts are good, as always Helvella..... yet when we take account of the lack of medical education re nutrition, we face another problem that will affect what a medic thinks, never mind knows, the patient needs.

PRJ20 profile image
PRJ20

Article in full ☺️

12ft.io/proxy?&q=https%3A%2...

Regenallotment profile image
RegenallotmentAmbassador

we watched a documentary recently that said we could get our B12 from veg if it wasn’t so clean, apparently it’s in the soil. So getting it from animals is third party, they pick it up from the soil then digest it then we eat them. Might have been Countryfile 🤷🏽‍♀️ can’t remember. Need to buy/harvest muddy veg 🌱

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Brain fog, other symptoms, dosage, B12 deficiency and testing?

I don't post very often as having had the radioiodine treatment for hyperthyroidism, I thought that...
CyclingDog profile image

Vegans 'need to be aware of B12 deficiency risk'

Just been told of an item on BBC news. Many thyroid sufferers also have B12 deficiency, (often...
Polaris profile image

Potential New Treatment for “Brain Fog” in Long COVID Patients

Although brain fog in thyroid patients has often been dismissed by medics (whether not understood,...
helvella profile image
Administrator

This might be of interest for anyone who struggles to raise their iron levels or is frequently anaemic or nearly anaemic

I should point out that this paper is old. It was first published in 2000. The second thing I...
humanbean profile image

Another reference to the importance of adequate B12 levels in over 60's in particular.

A couple of excerpts:- 1. In the elderly, it can cause dementia, says David Smith, Professor...
shaws profile image
Administrator