Vitamin D: This morning I bought a pack of... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

141,242 members166,488 posts

Vitamin D

Pollypet profile image
31 Replies

This morning I bought a pack of mushrooms, and as it was a sunny day, I put them outside to sunbathe. No - I’m not going crazy! Did anyone else listen to Tim Spector’s recent radio interview ( part of the Zoe Health Study) about research which shows mushrooms are like humans and can generate their own Vitamin D from the sun? I found it fascinating and certainly one way of introducing natural Vit D into my diet. So, sunbathing mushrooms it is then!

Written by
Pollypet profile image
Pollypet
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
31 Replies
Alanna012 profile image
Alanna012

Well I never! And I love mushrooms, I shall place them right near the kitchen window in future!

Pollypet profile image
Pollypet in reply toAlanna012

It may be that direct sunlight light is needed from being outside - just like we can’t get a suntan through glass windows. 😍

Alanna012 profile image
Alanna012 in reply toPollypet

Oh I see. Not sure I can trust the nosey squirrels in my garden not to throw them everywhere but no harm in taking mushrooms out for some air while I'm also outside🙂

Stourie profile image
Stourie in reply toPollypet

yes you can get a tan through glass but it takes an awful long time. Jo xx

Poppy_Ann profile image
Poppy_Ann

I would never expect mushrooms to increase vitamin d with sunlight as they prefer dark damp places to grow did they measure the vit d in a set weight ie measure 50 grams of mushrooms before being in the sun or 50 grams of mushrooms after being in the sun if they if they weighed them after being in the sun then I would expect them to gain more of what they measured due to the Loss of water from being in the sun but if they measured the mushrooms before being in the sun then split every mushroom in half then put one half in the sun and kept the other half in the dark then measured the amount of vitamin D, if they compared both against each other, unless the total vit d from the ones from in the sun was higher even though there would be less weight they should contain more vitamin D, it is easy to get the numbers that you want when testing one against another but you should make sure you are making the tests fair.

radd profile image
radd in reply toPoppy_Ann

Mushroom & Vit D interesting reading. ...... fungi.com/blogs/articles/pl...

A Review of Mushrooms as a Potential Source of Dietary Vitamin D .. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

Pollypet profile image
Pollypet in reply toradd

Thanks - interesting reading.

Hashiboy profile image
Hashiboy in reply toradd

Thanks radd the second article is brilliant.

radd profile image
radd

Pollypet,

Yes, I did and it was an incredible discovery.

I too have started leaving my mushrooms in the sun 😀. I love all Zoe research and listening to their guests.

Hedgeree profile image
Hedgeree

Hi Pollypet,

I didn't hear that but very interesting though.

But I've noticed that some prepackaged supermarket mushrooms do have enhanced vitamin D marked on their wrapping (can't remember the wording they used or which supermarket?) Not sure if they're more expensive than 'regular' mushrooms?

I'm guessing the growers possibly grow them under a UVB lamp similar to what people use when they keep reptiles? (so they get their vitamin D3 essential for their animals' health)

But I've not explored how they actually do it.

TiggerMe profile image
TiggerMeAmbassador in reply toHedgeree

I remember seeing this, can't be doing with shrooms myself but it showed them just very quickly zapping them under a UV light

Hedgeree profile image
Hedgeree in reply toTiggerMe

Ah right. I imagined them growing slowly under a UV lamp but that would have cost implications. Zapping makes economic sense for the grower/manufacturer.

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministrator

Some fungi are sold with vitamin D claims - and I think they have already been exposed to UV. I do not know if further exposure forms more vitamin D.

The form of vitamin D varies - D2, D3 or some claim D4. (I have not gone down that rabbit hole!) Often a mixture.

If you'd like to spend the rest of the day or week reading, you could follow this link!

scholar.google.com/scholar?...

posthinking01 profile image
posthinking01

Hi seems like a good idea but as someone who suffers with candida which is a yeast/fungal problem and mushrooms are fungal - be careful you are not just allowing the mushrooms to produce more nasties.

Phil865 profile image
Phil865 in reply toposthinking01

That's what I was wondering about as well. I too have intestinal candida overgrowth issues. Seems it is in everybody. Because of that I cut out raw mushrooms to be safe.

mstp profile image
mstp

I didn't hear that which is a bit remiss of me ad I am doing the ZOE Nutrition Programme at the moment. My mushroo.s will be sitting outside next time it's sunny!

Britpol profile image
Britpol

Apparently, fresh bread left in the sun also acquires vitamin D . Is that true?

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministrator in reply toBritpol

Might be true. But I suspect simply not much point for most of us! The amount doesn't appear to be enough so we need other sources. And, if we end up taking it as a supplement anyway, we might as well increase that dose a bit!

Plus, in northern parts, where there is little solar UV much of the year, it would have to be by UV lamp - not sun.

Interesting, though. :-)

nutritioninsight.com/news/e...

RedApple profile image
RedAppleAdministrator in reply toBritpol

Yeast is used in breadmaking. Yeast is a fungi so this would likely be the reason for vit D increasing in sunlight in the same way as mushrooms.

posthinking01 profile image
posthinking01 in reply toBritpol

Not sure whether this is a good idea as once again yeast could be re-activated in heat.

I went to a talk by James Wong (ethnobotanist) some years ago about food. He also said this, but I seem to remember he said take mushrooms out of the fridge for 20 mins before using to increase the vitamin D content.

Stourie profile image
Stourie in reply toRatherbegardening

I’ve never put mushrooms in the fridge. Wouldn’t have entered my head to do that 😊 Jo xx

Batty1 profile image
Batty1

I make mushroom meatballs, mushroom pulled pork sandwiches and mushroom burgers pretty often always knew they had vitamin d but I never heard about putting them in the sun before cooking… hmm

Phil865 profile image
Phil865

This is a fascinating topic. Thanks for posting and I will read up more on fungi sun tans.

thyr01d profile image
thyr01d

Great post Pollypet, as a vegan (expect you know we can't have products, like cornflakes, containing D3 which is so often the supplemented vitamin because it's from sheep) this is really good news. Did the programme mention which vitamin D was produced?

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministrator in reply tothyr01d

Not all D3 is from sheep. Some, at least, comes from lichen.

The paper is more complicated than you might think as D2, D3 and D4 are all potentially made by UV exposure of fungi. You really need to check each species of fungi, for a start.

thyr01d profile image
thyr01d in reply tohelvella

Thanks so much for this Helvella, this information has made a difference to our lives!

Pollypet profile image
Pollypet in reply tothyr01d

Indeed - D2

thyr01d profile image
thyr01d in reply toPollypet

Thanks Pollypet :)

Verbena_67 profile image
Verbena_67

Yes! I have heard this, and thanks for reminding me!

Nonamefree profile image
Nonamefree

Hi everyone. I've never commented before but I've learnt a lot from reading the daily posts. Thank you all. I watched a TV program series where they went round the factories showing how things were done, and one week it was mushroom packaging for supermarkets. The mushrooms are picked, sorted, measured into their trays, and then go onto a closed conveyor belt which has overhead UV lights to give them the vitamin D before the trays are sealed. Didn't tell you how much Vit D unfortunately, but I found it interesting.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Vitamin D

Hi all, I'm struggling with taking vitamin D. When I take it it makes the whirring noise in my...
Hookie01 profile image

Low vitamin d results

Letter from the doc today to confirm vit d is low suggested I sit in the sun between April and sept...
Emlico profile image

Vitamin D insufficiency?

Hi, my mum has an underactive thyroid and I got her to have some blood tests done and it came back...
Ctb567 profile image

Vitamin D

I have been taking Fultium-D3 800IU Capsules, prescribed by my doctor, for about three years after...
Tezza profile image

Vitamin D

Hi Guys, I've been taking vitamin D for almost 2 years and only recently started taking K2 with it...
Yulia2010 profile image

Moderation team

See all
SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator
Jaydee1507 profile image
Jaydee1507Administrator
RedApple profile image
RedAppleAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.