Oral Questions by Lord Hunt and Lord Borwick an... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,814 members161,641 posts

Oral Questions by Lord Hunt and Lord Borwick and others

lynmynott profile image
lynmynottPartnerThyroid UK
15 Replies

Lord Hunt and Lord Borwick asked pertinent questions in the House of Lords on Wednesday 6th July 2022, with further questions from Baroness Wheeler, Lord McFall, Baroness Brinton and Baroness Masham.

We are very pleased that the Minister, Lord Kamall, answered these questions clearly and decisively. Lord Kamall has previously had an understanding of the issue from meetings with him and thyroid charities and organisations as well as reading various reports including the latest 2022 T3 Prescribing Report which showed that 58% of CCGs were not abiding by national guidance.

You can read the Hansard Transcript of the questions and answers here:

tinyurl.com/2sznnmhs

If you have had your T3 withdrawn or refused, it might help to show this transcript to your clinician or Clinical Commissioning Group or Integrated Care Board and push your right to have it reinstated or to have a trial.

Written by
lynmynott profile image
lynmynott
Partner
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
15 Replies
tattybogle profile image
tattybogle

Watched it live ... :)

hope you had an ..erm... 'interesting' day in london, lyn ....

lynmynott profile image
lynmynottPartnerThyroid UK in reply to tattybogle

Yes, it was interesting! We sat up in the gallery. Lots of stairs! I was very tired yesterday but feeling better today...

PrincessAnnie profile image
PrincessAnnie

It’s all very well fighting for people who need it to be prescribed it but what about those that won’t even have a clue that they need it as they’re constantly being told”you’re in range”so there’s nothing wrong with you!Absolutely boils my blood the way thyroid issues are just dismissed if you’re showing “in range”yet still complaining of symptoms!

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator in reply to PrincessAnnie

You're right as many people who have hypothyroidism might not have a connection to the internet and have always relied upon the GP or Endo (If they've ever had a consultation) to restore their health.

DippyDame profile image
DippyDame in reply to PrincessAnnie

Totally agree!And....they can issue as many guidelines as they like about T3 but nothing will change until endos are knowledgeable enough and willing enough to prescribe therapeutic doses to patients who need that to function/survive.

Some of us here need high dose T3 to function but don't have a snowballs chance in h*** of being treated on the NHS.

So, we self medicate with the challenges of finding reliable supplies that that brings, and the concern that if we are hospitalised or go into care we will not be correctly medicated

Ah!....But we will be old and on our way out anyway I guess!

I would very likely be dead now had I not spent a huge amount of time reading and learning about T3 ,how it works and how to self medicate......and initially through heavy brain fog.

It was that, or a bedridden future....like my grandmother!

How many people are living (and dying) behind closed doors because they are not being correctly treated.

It beggars belief!

Lorraine Cleaver ( in Scotland) worked for years to try to change T3 treatment eventually it was decreed that patients who show a clinical need for T3 should have it prescribed.....at the discretion of an endocrinologist.

Well we know how that pans out!!

Lorraine was so disgusted at the outcome of years of excellent campaigning that the frustration in her final words on the petition website are unprintable here...and heartbreaking!

Fixing this mess lies with the decision makers at the top of the medical tree .....they hold the key to unlock this impasse. But, they don't seem interested in listening to fine words.....or solid scientific evidence.

I'm with you PrincessAnnie this whole mess makes my blood boil....and I'm getting far too old now to cope with boiling blood!!!!!!

PrincessAnnie profile image
PrincessAnnie in reply to DippyDame

I only wish I could do something about it🤬🤬

DippyDame profile image
DippyDame in reply to PrincessAnnie

Don't we all!

PrincessAnnie profile image
PrincessAnnie in reply to DippyDame

I’m going to email the first minister again,I got an email back the last time basically saying that T3 can be prescribed blah blah blah,totally ignoring my concerns about having to pay for a private blood test to even know my T3 was low in the first place,and it wasn’t even directly from her🤦‍♀️

mfinn profile image
mfinn

Can anyone explain what this means please? ' It has told me that it is open to new evidence with people able to consult and contact it about this.'

nellie237 profile image
nellie237 in reply to mfinn

I think it means "Sod off, we're not interested"

mfinn profile image
mfinn in reply to nellie237

Thanks. I think you're absolutely right!

Gingernut44 profile image
Gingernut44

Yet more and more “consultations” - this is just kicking the can further down the road.

arTistapple profile image
arTistapple

I know this is an old thread. However I have just read the report in full because it was connected to the current newsletter from Thyroid UK. In fact it is tremendously well written and organised report. However I see from the report that my area Newcastle and Gateshead apparently comply with the guidelines. I find this totally at odds with what appears to be happening on this patch. It sounds like lip service to me - they have answered the questions ‘correctly’ but not factually. My GP practice uses the phrase ‘Black List” with reference to Liothyronine and its public knowledge that the endo in charge is totally against prescribing T3. Indeed the actual statistics for prescribing appear to be nil or a couple of outliers only. How on Earth are they getting away with this? The endo in charge in this area has remarked publicly that T3 is not approved.

lynmynott profile image
lynmynottPartnerThyroid UK in reply to arTistapple

Since this report, a lot has changed and things have got worse. We are fighting though to make change...

arTistapple profile image
arTistapple in reply to lynmynott

Lyn, I would agree things look like they have got worse. I am glad however to know you guys are still on the case. It seem s to me that the main problem is that nobody ‘in charge’ is interested. It’s a malaise remarkably similar to the symptoms of undiagnosed hypothyroidism itself!

You may also like...

Oral Questions in the House of Lords

Lord Philip Hunt has secured a slot at the Open Questions session in House of Lords tomorrow -...

Evidence for meeting with Lord Hunt

what is happening with CCGs etc. in readiness for our meeting with Lord Hunt on 19th July. If you...

PQ by Lord Philip Hunt

Lord Philip Hunt asked a question about our survey report on behalf of thyroid patients. The answer

Debate in House of Lords!

I had a meeting with Lord Philip Hunt, Opposition Spokesperson on Health and Social Care, Higher...

T3 debate House of Lords

prescriptions. Also, re the House of Lords debate, I listened to, or read this a few months ago and...