Can I choose which Covid booster to have and wh... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,791 members161,613 posts

Can I choose which Covid booster to have and which should I choose?

dizzy864 profile image
23 Replies

I had Pfizer jabs. After the first, I had a sizeable lump at the injection site. This was really tender. I also had mild flu like symptoms. These lasted ten days. I thought given my usual problems with meds I d got away with it very light!

My second jab, back in April was a different story. Within an hour pain had moved up my arm, across my shoulders, into my neck and down my other arm. I ve never experienced muscle aches so severe. I also felt really unwell - nauseous, really tired and " hungover" . It was six weeks before I even began to feel better. I did a yellow card. My upper arms and shoulders have not stopped aching since. Nothing like as bad as it was but a constant ache and pain when I reach to get anything. I have been diagnosed with long Covid following Covid in February last year. The muscle aches may be from that but I didn't have them before the second jab.

I was offered the booster last month but have ignored it. I can't face being so unwell again. Recent developments are causing me to stress about not having it. I contacted my GP, who was no help! He told me I could have Pfizer at the surgery or go a couple of miles to another centre and have Pfizer or possibly be allowed Moderna.

Do I have the right to insist on a particular vaccine?

Has anyone else suffered side affects? If so have you had the booster?

Which vaccine should I have?

I d really appreciate some advice

Written by
dizzy864 profile image
dizzy864
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...

The ability to reply to this post has been turned off.

23 Replies
Delgor profile image
Delgor

Hi Dizzy, It is my understanding that the booster jab should be different to the first two that you have had already and that has certainly been the case for myself and the others that I've seen on the forum poll here on Health Unlocked which Red Apple is running. It would be worth you taking a look because you will see that everyone's experiences are different so it would be impossible to advise you what is the best to have or whether you even get a choice. My first two were AZ and my booster was Pfizer which had me in bed for a day feeling fluey and ill with the usual sore arm but personally I'm still glad that I've had it with yet another variant of covid taking off in the UK. Hope this helps!

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to Delgor

Many people have had all three of the same make. Though it makes sense to my mind that we get a different make as booster. :-)

You are right - the polls have lots of information. :-) Links in my reply further down.

My vaccines were also AZ followed by Pfizer.

Fruitandnutcase profile image
Fruitandnutcase in reply to helvella

All three of mine have been Pfizer. No problems of any sort with any of them - first time I had a tiny blue mark where the needle went in - no blood involved and the next two I couldn’t even see where the needle went in. Some people I know have had sore arms for a while, others have been like me.

I thought the third one was either Pfizer or Moderna (or that was what was on my form when I booked it) but I don’t know for certain.

jimh111 profile image
jimh111

Pfizer is the default whether you had AZ or Pfizer previously. I believe those who had a bad reaction to Pfizer can behave AZ as a booster. Try ringing the number you book the jab on (I’ve forgotten it) and see what they say.

Zephyrbear profile image
Zephyrbear in reply to jimh111

I did ring that number to ask whether I could have the AZ booster as I had allergy concerns but was told they only used Pfizer or Moderna. She said a few people had had reactions to the PEG (polyethylene glycol aka antifreeze) in it which the AZ does not.I was told Pfizer or Moderna, take it or leave it… two of my daughters had Pfizer and they were both ill for a week after it. I have an MRI scan on my back coming up in December that I’ll have waited 10 weeks for whilst just walking is becoming more and more of a problem and I’m not jeopardising that for anything. I may have it afterwards…

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to Zephyrbear

PEG (polyethylene glycol aka antifreeze)

No - antifreeze is often Ethylene glycol, sometimes Propylene glycol and with various other substances possibly being included. Similar names but very different substances.

We are all too ready to accept and understand that a single atom difference between T4 and T3 has a huge impact. The difference between antifreeze and ALC-0159 is far, far greater. ALC-0159 has a molecular weight of around 2000 daltons; ethylene glycol around 62.

Pfizer/BioNTech Comirnaty vaccine contains:

6.1 List of excipients

((4-hydroxybutyl)azanediyl)bis(hexane-6,1-diyl)bis(2-hexyldecanoate) (ALC-0315)

2-[(polyethylene glycol)-2000]-N,N-ditetradecylacetamide (ALC-0159)

1,2-Distearoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DSPC)

Cholesterol

Potassium chloride

Potassium dihydrogen phosphate

Sodium chloride

Disodium phosphate dihydrate

Sucrose

Water for injections

Sodium hydroxide (for pH-adjustment)

Hydrochloric acid (for pH-adjustment)

medicines.org.uk/emc/produc...

Hedgeree profile image
Hedgeree in reply to helvella

Thanks for the explanation helvella. It is much appreciated.

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to Hedgeree

A page of information about the Covid vaccine:

cas.org/ja/resource/blog/un...

Includes many diagrams and discussions.

Consider that cellulose, which we all consume every day, is a long chain of, pretty much, sugar molecules. But it has very, very different physical and chemical and biological properties to any sugar.

jimh111 profile image
jimh111 in reply to Zephyrbear

Will reply below so that more people see my reply.

Mariazeta profile image
Mariazeta

I had astrazeneca twice before and i felt awful. I couldn't even care for my family. It lasted for about 2 weeks after each dose. I had the pfizer booster and i felt great except a minor pain on my arm and swollen lymp nodes. I wasn't tired or felt sick at all. My sister had moderna and she had high temperature and she fainted. Unfortunately all of them have side effects. They made me feel so drained 😪 Perhaps because i have an autoimmune disease. From what i know you can't choose another vaccine for your booster. It has to be Pfizer. Btw pfizer will have a new vaccine in about 3 months. So there is another booster coming. There is no ending

Polly91 profile image
Polly91 in reply to Mariazeta

Is there going to be a 2nd booster needed in 3 months ? I hadn’t heard that.

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to Polly91

We do not know for sure what is going to happen. The Omicron variant is being considered as a possible target for a revised vaccine. There is, in my view, no possibility of any new variant vaccine being available in three months - I think that would be when it i launched as a product. (They said 100 days to develop a new vaccine. They then have to produce and distribute it.)

Polly91 profile image
Polly91 in reply to helvella

Sorry HelvellaI didn’t quite follow your message. Are you saying you think the vaccine to the new variant will be ready in 3 months or that’s it not possible to have it ready in that time?

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to Polly91

They might have the design, and even the testing, done. But it won't be ready in quantity to actually deliver.

Manufacturing billions of doses is a major undertaking in any circumstances. Inevitably, it will take at least many months to produce the equivalent of one booster vaccine for everyone who is already vaccinated. Let alone the ongoing need for those who have not yet had a chance of any vaccine.

Of course, they might suddenly switch production from Mk 1 to Mk 2 - totally. But they are still struggling to deliver what has been ordered. Another booster requirement would increase that demand even further.

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to Mariazeta

If you have not yet done so, please consider replying to the polls - links further down this thread.

Hi Pfizer and Moderna are very similar so chances are that if you reacted to Pfizer then you would to Moderna, both being the same sort of vaccine. I believe they are offering the AZ in limited cases where people can't have the Pfizer, in case of allergies etc. You could try phoning 119 to ask.

Hi

I used to get a very sore red lump,after a flu jab. A nurse suggested taking an antihistamine as its a local reaction to the jab. Might be worth a try.

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK

This forum has three polls regarding Covid-19 vaccination experiences. These have been running for months and both have large numbers of replies.

Keeping these comments together makes it much easier to find them than having multiple separate questions. It also helps to avoid a large amount of duplication.

For this reason, we are adding this comment and closing posts to replies.

Please read the comments and, when you have had your vaccinations, enter your votes and consider whether you would like to add a reply regarding your personal experiences.

Some comments might help you.

Thyroid disorder and COVID-19 BOOSTER vaccination. **This Poll is NOT for the THIRD vaccination for IMMUNOSUPRESSED people**

healthunlocked.com/thyroidu...

SECOND Covid-19 Vaccine Shot - What was your experience?

healthunlocked.com/thyroidu...

Thyroid Disorder and Covid-19 Vaccination - What was your experience? ONLY respond when YOU HAVE actually received a Covid-19 vaccination.

healthunlocked.com/thyroidu...

suebob59 profile image
suebob59

I think you just get what is available on the day. I had a Moderna booster yesterday, the previous were AZ. I have none of the fluey symptoms as with the AZ, but the injection site is swollen and painful today.

jimh111 profile image
jimh111

A quick search shows slightly conflicting advice.

Gov.UK state that only Pfizer or Moderna are available but you might get AZ if your previous doses were AZ gov.uk/government/publicati... . (I wonder if this is to cover them for remote parts where they can't deliver Pfizer?).

British Heart Foundation say "AstraZeneca will only be offered to those who can’t have Pfizer or Moderna." bhf.org.uk/informationsuppo... So, perhaps there is an option for those who have reacted badly to Pfizer. It may take some persistence to get jump through the hoops. Would seem simpler to give the GPs a batch of AZ for them to ration for special cases but the NHS doesn't do common sense.

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to jimh111

No mention of Janssen (Johnson and Johnson). Which was, at one point, suggested as a different vaccine suitable for use as a booster.

tattybogle profile image
tattybogle

i have a more pragmatic solution to "can i choose which one i get ?"

there are several 'walk in' centres within reach of me.... i walk past them occasionally and have a look on the board in the lobby ... it says which vaccine if currently being used, or you could ask... so after i've read my tea leaves to decide which vaccine i think i want... i'll be 'walking in' to one that is using it that week.. or waiting till i find one that is.

I could be wrong , but i don't think there's much planning going on here.. i think it's got a lot to do with 'who's got a supply of what'

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK

This thread has started to discuss matters outside the original question and will be closed to further replies,

The ability to reply to this post has been turned off.

You may also like...

Covid booster and subacute thyroiditis

it's a goitre but I had a feeling that it might be something caused by the covid booster (I'm not...

spring covid booster

I had the booster for covid, it was Moderna, a month ago and since then my symptoms have been all...

Covid booster vaccination : Graves Disease

thoughts pl re having the covid booster vaccination when diagnosed with Graves Disease. I have...

GP tells me to choose which symptoms to live with

would have to choose between living with muscle ache OR palpitations. To which I replied.......

So, it’s not COVID...which is a relief...but why have I been feeling so bad?

hope it’s a good one!). I’ve spent the last 5 days feeling really down, with symptoms that I...