Has ERFA been reformulated, can anyone suggest... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,661 members161,433 posts

Has ERFA been reformulated, can anyone suggest an NDT that they are benefiting from please?

Poonam1 profile image
22 Replies

Hi everyone

I hope you all had a lovely Christmas. I just wanted to ask if anyone has experienced zero improvement in their help whilst on ERFA and levothyroxine combination. Could it be that ERFA has been reformed. Is there another NDT that might be best to try with out it being reformulated? Your help would be appreciated.. I’ve put on a stone in a month and feel so unwell!

Best wishes for the New Year to all.

Poonam

Written by
Poonam1 profile image
Poonam1
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
22 Replies
SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator

You need to get FULL Thyroid and vitamin testing

As per my reply to previous post, vitamins need to be optimal

healthunlocked.com/thyroidu...

What vitamin supplements do you currently take

Are you on strictly gluten free diet

silverfox7 profile image
silverfox7

I’ve just looked at your previous post and wondered the same thing. I responded well to getting my vits etc optimal but it can take time to get it sorted depending how low things turn out to be. Again something that takes time to reverse but well worth the effort. Plus you can’t do it with multi Vits but need to address each in turn and get all optimal, not just in range. Once optimal you may be able to find a maintenance dose to keep it there. Ask your doctor to test Vit D, B12, folate and ferritin and post results for advice. I found two very low but once where they should be itcwas like a light had been switched on. It doesn’t happen overnight but well worth the effort.

Hypopotamus profile image
Hypopotamus

ERFA was changed a couple of years ago, and no longer worked well for many of us.

HashiFedUp profile image
HashiFedUp

I was doing really well on ERFA until about 10 weeks ago when i started feeling ill again after a new batch. Not sure what is happening to ERFA - maybe it’s me maybe it’s the ERFA. I have increased my ERFA dose and continue also with my Levothyroxine as well.

SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering

Stop the Thyroid Madness has the following comment about Erfa

stopthethyroidmadness.com/a... (scroll down)

CANADA’S “THYROID” aka ERFA, formerly by Pfizer and is now by Erfa. Note: beginning around May 2014 and continuing to today, many patients have reported Erfa was now causing a return of hypothyroid symptoms. Erfa denies a change, but there are too many negative reports from some patients now to think there hasn’t been a change, somehow.

Then it links to the following article:

stopthethyroidmadness.com/2...

waveylines profile image
waveylines

Yes Erfa used to be good but since they moved countries it nose dived. Many people reported swinging between hyper and hypo symptoms. I found it great before they moved then nose diced too. Id change ndt!

What to recommend is hard as so many ndts have gone south in the last few years. Theres a shortage of pigs thyroids too which isnt helping.

Im currently on Acella NP but that has been reported in the USA as having changed too & people are reporting symptoms. Im not sure what to suggest as Naturethroid went through a bad patch too. Sorry am not much help! Lol...

Poonam1 profile image
Poonam1 in reply to waveylines

Thank you waves lines

You’ve been extremely helpful. Thanks you to all that have replied, much appreciated. Have a wonderful new year !!

Netty510 profile image
Netty510 in reply to waveylines

Hi i was on np thyroid from u.s and it worked so good..yes they changed the formula. The new batch smells like cat piss and taste weird with spreckles in it..the ones your on now if yoir still feeling well are the old stuff..i also had to seitch over to erfa i had old bottles from 2017 but after taking it 3 to 4 weeks in.im starting to feel hypo..i thought if i raise it it woukd help but felt nauseous after 2 nd day of the raise..i never had had tht reaction in the past with erfa...i bought some thyroid-s from Thailand for backup that i may have to start today

waveylines profile image
waveylines in reply to Netty510

Yes Netty am still on the old NP which like you Ive found bril......for how much longer I can get it I dont know. Not yet encountered the cats pee smell or the burning session some have described. I will have to switch.....what to is the question! Lol....

Netty510 profile image
Netty510 in reply to waveylines

I know exactly how you feel...i got a few bottles of thyroid-s and some t3 on hand just in case...ill be starting thyroid-s the only ndt left that has some good reveiws so im hoping and praying

waveylines profile image
waveylines

Hope you gave a wonderful new year too Poonam1. Heres hoping its a far better year for a good ndt!!

Jodypody profile image
Jodypody

I have been on TR Man from Thailand and have to say it’s been the most consistent

SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering in reply to Jodypody

Do you have a good stock, it's no longer being produced. Thyroid-S is now the only Thai NDT left.

Jodypody profile image
Jodypody in reply to SeasideSusie

Oh heck. I’ve got about 600

Jodypody profile image
Jodypody in reply to SeasideSusie

I’ve got 5 months worth. Turns out it’s to do with Swine flu

SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering in reply to Jodypody

The shortage is possibly due to swine flu and shortage of raw materials. As far as TR Man and Thiroyd are concerned, it's been said that the Thai government want NDT to be licensed and that the manufacturers don't want to, I expect it's an expensive process. However, it's all conjecture, nothing confirmed other than both TR and Thiroyd stopped production earlier in 2019.

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to Jodypody

I suspect it is because of African swine fever virus rather than swine flu. Vast numbers of pigs have died in China and nearby countries.

Poonam1 profile image
Poonam1

I think there’s a shortage of Tr Mann too.. how much do you take in a daily basis and how please JodyPody?

Thanks

Jodypody profile image
Jodypody in reply to Poonam1

I take 3.5 grains in the morning

waveylines profile image
waveylines

TR Man & Thyroid S have stopped production. They were going to have to re-register with their body -US & have decided to not to. The thinking is that theyve sold out to big pharma..... no idea if that is true. Saw some Thyroid S online but they want over $300!

The options have narrowed down loads. I never got on with the synthetic thyroid hormomes even when Liothyronine was added in but I may have no choice at this rate.....

Its all extrememly worrying. 😩

Sorry to be so gloomy on New Years Eve!!!

Netty510 profile image
Netty510 in reply to waveylines

Hello wavylines..from what i heard is tr man and thyroyd are not making anymore but thyroid-s is just out of stock from high demand since its the last one available and prices are way up from it ...im not sure how accurate this is ..after trman and thyroyd stopped production prices went way up..i got mine luckily right before the spike 2 bottles

waveylines profile image
waveylines

Ah yes youre right Netty. Sorry for the mis-infomation. I got confused with the names....lol. I couldnt believe the price......more expensive than Armour now!!

I get my nhs on a green script so need to find something that a uk pharmacy stock or can get. Id heard that adding sugar and/or a bit of T3 works.

Happy New Year!!! Lets hope the 20's brings a fresh surge of good ndts!! 😏😉 well I can hope!

You may also like...

Erfa Thyroid NDT Ingredients please

question is there a list of ingredients for Erfa please. I am asking for myself plus a friend....

NDT has stopped working. Can anyone help?

Hashimoto's. I've been using NDT now for around 4 years. My symptoms have improved steadily over...

Has anyone switched from NDT to T3?

Hi all, Following on from my previous post my endo has said if I don't improve on my current dose...

Converting ERFA NDT from mg to grains - help please

My specialist has prescribed 1/2 grain twice daily of ERFA NDT but the prescription has arrived in...

URGENT HELP - Has anyone been successful at receiving NDT on the NHS

02 and T3 5.1 - The endo nurse is such a lovely guy and has advised me to go armed with evidence to...