T4 or T3: Just had a chat with a GP. He says that... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,155 members160,837 posts

T4 or T3

fiftyone profile image
7 Replies

Just had a chat with a GP. He says that the medical profession believes overmedicating on T4 can damage the heart. I suggested that T4 has first to be converted to T3 before it becomes active and therefore the T3 measurement will determine whether the heart is in danger. He insisted it was the T4 level which was important. Which is correct?

Written by
fiftyone profile image
fiftyone
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
7 Replies
Min789 profile image
Min789

Yes I would like to know the answer to that too.

You are. And anyway, you need to define overmedication. A low TSH and slightly over range free T4 from medication (as opposed to hyperthyroidism) haven't been associated with heart problems, but low T3 has. Give GP the Dr Toft article.

Min789 profile image
Min789 in reply to Angel_of_the_North

Hi Angel of the North could you give me a link to Dr Tofts article stating low T3 is assosciated with heart problems?

Angel_of_the_North profile image
Angel_of_the_North in reply to Min789

The Dr Toft article is the one that says it is OK to have a suppressed TSH and over range free T4

Min789 profile image
Min789 in reply to Angel_of_the_North

Yes I have given a copy of that article to my gp. Don't think he's very confident to go with anything different to what he knows unfortunately.

fiftyone profile image
fiftyone in reply to Min789

I get the impression that GPs are guided by their own associations and official recommendations and don't go outside those boundaries.

You may also like...

Clarification about T4 to T3

about thyroid problems. I come across an article which says that the reason we still suffer with...

changing from t4 to t4/t3

? Drop in T4 with starting T3

dropped from 16.9 (12-22) which is 53% of range on 100 Levo only to 12.6 (12-22) which is 6% with...

Rundown of TSH, T3, T4

T3 meds 12 hours, before, only water, early appointment, Next was Aug 2021 which should have only...

T3 to T4 equivalence question

However I see on Dr Myhill's site she says it's equivalent to 5 x which I am a bit surprised by......