Come back Lord O'Shaughnessy, your inaction mus... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

141,246 membersโ€ข166,490 posts

Come back Lord O'Shaughnessy, your inaction must surely be better than what we have in our current Health Secretary

MaisieGray profile image
MaisieGray
โ€ข30 Replies

When he was appointed successor to Lord O'S, Matt Hancock said in an interview that he was excited about the prospect of improving the use of IT in the NHS. Little did any of us know that this would evidence itself in what has been reported today:

In a bid to relieve pressure on the NHS, Health Secretary Matt Hancock urged Britons to use Amazon's ALEXA for health advice instead of seeing a Dr.

You couldn't make it up ........

Written by
MaisieGray profile image
MaisieGray
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
30 Replies
โ€ข
sy28 profile image
sy28

No available appointments with my nominated GP for over six weeks, meanwhile the surgery's updated website now offers cyber appointments in preference for visiting the medical centre.

MaisieGray profile image
MaisieGrayโ€ข in reply tosy28

I've been trying for 36 hrs to even get through on the phone .... The recorded message goes on for ever now, presumably to ease us into using ALEXA, but you can't actually get to speak to a human being. It is very telling that it includes a statement that "all calls are recorded for the purposes of training, quality and CONFLICT RESOLUTIONS". When on earth did it become necessary to presume all interactions with patients ended in conflict .....

RedApple profile image
RedAppleAdministrator

Oh, so Alexa can issue prescriptions now then! Seriously MaisieGray, where did you hear/read this?

humanbean profile image
humanbeanโ€ข in reply toRedApple

It was on the news today, and is reported on the BBC News website as well as by the Guardian and other news sources :

bbc.co.uk/news/health-48925345

theguardian.com/society/201...

RedApple profile image
RedAppleAdministratorโ€ข in reply tohumanbean

Thanks for the links HB. the excerpt above makes more sense when you see it in context. The Alexa aspect is offered for people with disabilities who can't access the usual internet sources. And as you say below, it is of course only going to give 'credible' info because it comes from NHS sources ;)

MaisieGray profile image
MaisieGrayโ€ข in reply toRedApple

I don't think it is in any way being made remotely credible simply because it draws some or any of its data from NHS Choices. I had my first ever telephone appointment on Monday, which was pretty dire and second rate compared with a face to face appt - compounded by the fact that the locum GP had a broad Nigerian-sounding accent, kept speaking away from the phone, sounded as if he was in an echo chamber, and I have a degree of deafness in any case; then I have spent all yesterday and today trying and failing to get through on the phone to speak to anyone at either surgery because he sent the blood request form to my local surgery but the X-ray request form to the surgery some miles away; and in any case apparently it's not needed in order to attend the X-ray unit so I'm trying and failing to explain why I shan't be picking it up, in order to avoid a critical note being added to my file along the lines of 'she tells us she's really ill but can't be bothered to go for the X-ray' (I actually went yesterday, minus the form). So just when I thought it couldn't get worse, the bloody Healthy Minister (what a joke that title is) tells us to use ALEXA. I have gone from a lifetime of being pragmatic and respectful of health practitioners within the NHS, to cynical, very angry, and thinking they are a bunch of uneducated stupid lazy sheisters, never mind that we were told yesterday about how operations are being cancelled as the overtime affects the surgeons' and anaesthetists' pensions ....

RedApple profile image
RedAppleAdministratorโ€ข in reply toMaisieGray

MaisieGray, "I don't think it is in any way being made remotely credible simply because it draws some or any of its data from NHS Choices. "

I totally agree, that's why I put a winking smiley after my words. I perhaps should have made it clearer that I was being sarcastic!

MaisieGray profile image
MaisieGrayโ€ข in reply toRedApple

That's okay RedApple , I was commenting in the same vein as yourself, I didn't think you were being a proponent of the scheme. I'm feeling particularly vexed today as a result of an incident this morning whilst attending for my blood draw, which I'll report separately if I can summon up the emotional wherewithal ๐Ÿ˜–

DippyDame profile image
DippyDameโ€ข in reply toMaisieGray

Hear hear! I won't relate my NHS tales of the rediculous here but I share your about-turn re the NHS.....as for their admin, my 5 year old grandson has more nous!

DebTex profile image
DebTexโ€ข in reply toMaisieGray

I am truly sorry that you have all that going on with your healthcare in the UK โ˜น๏ธ I am hoping for great improvement in it for you all. In the US we have abundant healthcare, but itโ€™s not always great, along with a lot of inept, nincompoop Drs. so I canโ€™t even imagine what you all are going through, Iโ€™m sorry ๐Ÿ˜

MaisieGray profile image
MaisieGrayโ€ข in reply toDebTex

Oh bless you, what a lovely thought. Thank you DebTex Wishing you all that you need too, on your side of the pond. ๐Ÿ™‚

DebTex profile image
DebTexโ€ข in reply toMaisieGray

Thank you too MaisieGray, sending the same wishes back to you, on your side of the pond!

Greekchick profile image
Greekchickโ€ข in reply toDebTex

Deb, itโ€™s bad news everywhere for healthcare. Canada has also begun to show big cracks in our system - we have good care but not enough of it. And of course , ineptitude goes with the territory. Have a good day today and letโ€™s hope things improve . Good wishes for all of us on both sides of the Atlantic. ๐Ÿ™๐Ÿป

DebTex profile image
DebTexโ€ข in reply toGreekchick

Thank you, letโ€™s all do hope for improvement on both sides, you take good care.

Trixie64 profile image
Trixie64

I saw him on BBC Breakfast this morning. What next?? Things are going from bad to worse.

RedApple profile image
RedAppleAdministratorโ€ข in reply toTrixie64

Trixie64, I think things went from bad to worse a long time ago. Now they are going from worse to utterly disgraceful. :x

Trixie64 profile image
Trixie64โ€ข in reply toRedApple

Couldn't agree more!

SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering

I wonder how is Alexa superior to Dr Google, considering patients get belittled for consulting Google.

humanbean profile image
humanbeanโ€ข in reply toSeasideSusie

I think it is considered better than Google because Alexa will get its information only from the NHS Choices website.

MaisieGray profile image
MaisieGrayโ€ข in reply tohumanbean

There are videos on YouTube of an African grey parrot in the US that has learnt to interact with Alexa, and is by far the more competent of the two; so I'll maybe set up video link appointments with the parrot instead. ๐Ÿ˜‚

Greekchick profile image
Greekchickโ€ข in reply toMaisieGray

You made my day, MaisieGray! Thanks for that. Let me know what the parrot has to say. ๐Ÿ˜‚

MaisieGray profile image
MaisieGrayโ€ข in reply toGreekchick

Take one peanut four times daily or as required ......

MaisieGray profile image
MaisieGrayโ€ข in reply toMaisieGray

For those not familiar with Alexa and wanting to learn more, and for a little light relief after my initiating doom and gloom here (sorry), here's Petra the African Grey parrot showing how it's done - plus the chance to see her all round skills as she relaxes at home ...... ๐Ÿ˜‰ m.youtube.com/watch?v=ewpte...

Marz profile image
Marz

healthunlocked.com/thyroidu...

Maybe time to re-visit the above post by Londinium and the associated videos explaining WIGO - what is going on ! Obviously Matt Hancock is preparing us all :-(

MaisieGray profile image
MaisieGrayโ€ข in reply toMarz

Thanks for the link Marz I must have missed that when it was posted.

Marz profile image
Marzโ€ข in reply toMaisieGray

You're welcome ! I mentioned in a reply the other day about surgeries being amalgamated and tick box consultations ! Apparently it has already started in Cornwall ( so far away from London )

DippyDame profile image
DippyDame

I can only suggest Mr H must be a Star Trek fan!

For ALEXA read EMH!!

"The EMH is a holographic computer program designed to treat patients during emergency situations, or when the regular medical staff is unavailable or incapacitated. EMHs are a standard feature onboard all Starfleet ships, but they are there only to supplement the living'

Sorry...spent too many hours watching Star Trek with my husband and sons!

Just a thought.....

MaisieGray profile image
MaisieGrayโ€ข in reply toDippyDame

You know things are bad when the prospect of a holographic computer program sounds infinitely preferable to what's on offer ...... ๐Ÿ˜‚

greygoose profile image
greygoose

lol

TaraJR profile image
TaraJR

To be accurate, Matt Hancock replaced the previous Secretary of State for Health Jeremy Hunt.

Lord O'Shaughnessy was Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for Health, and was replaced by Nicola Blackwood.

However I agree about the Healthcare situation!

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Jeremy Hunt now Foreign Secretary

Matt Hancock appointed health secretary Matt Hancock, currently the culture secretary, replaces...
helvella profile image
Administratorโ€ข

Covid: UK government requests guidance on vitamin D use

As always, expect to see zero consideration for those who have any issues in taking vitamin D....
helvella profile image
Administratorโ€ข

Petition

Isnโ€™t it time someone started a petition on the Parliament Web site? 100k sigs and a debate is...
helenshubby profile image
โ€ข

NHS to sell DNA tests to healthy people in push to find new treatments

An interesting story which begets many questions. Not least what counts as a "serious genetic...
helvella profile image
Administratorโ€ข

Women's Health Strategy - Call for Evidence - Consultation

The Government have published a call for evidence to collect the views on womenโ€™s health - the...
lynmynott profile image
Partnerโ€ข