Dr Lowe and T3 - I've posted in the past. - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,781 members161,589 posts

Dr Lowe and T3 - I've posted in the past.

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator
5 Replies

You might find this of interest if you've not read it before. It was published 14 years ago, yet we've not come much further on our journey with optimum treatment being given. Also the refusal of the professionals to believe that some can be harmed with levothyroxine.

Excerpt from link below:

T3-Binding to Transthyretin. In the 1950s, limited information led some researchers to conclude that transthyretin only transports T4 into the brain. Based on this conclusion, they believed that brain cells get their T3 only by converting T4 to T3. Some doctors adopted these two beliefs. And based on the beliefs, they wouldn’t let their patients use T3 alone. These false beliefs probably contributed to conventional doctors’ rigid use of T4-replacement (patients’ use of T4 alone with their dosages adjusted by their TSH levels). All of this happened despite studies in the 1950s and early 1960 that showed T3 alone was highly effective for patients who failed to benefit from T4 alone or T4/T3 therapy.

Let me illustrate the types of problems that resulted from doctors holding these false beliefs. I used to co-treat patients with a neuropsychiatrist in Houston, Texas. More than once, he expressed frustration at an experience he occasionally had. After he prescribed T3 for depressed and cognitively-impaired hypothyroid patients, endocrinologists would switch them to T4-replacement. The endocrinologists would argue that without taking T4, the patients’ brain cells wouldn’t have enough T3. But soon after being switched to T4, their depression and cognitive dysfunction returned. So, when the patients went back to the neuropsychiatist to complain, he switched them back to T3. Quickly, their depression and cognitive dysfunction cleared up again.

"web.archive.org/web/2010103...

Written by
shaws profile image
shaws
Administrator
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
5 Replies
m7-cola profile image
m7-cola

Thank you for reminding us that some medics have remained stuck for decades in their treatment of thyroid problems!

Baobabs profile image
Baobabs in reply to m7-cola

Yes I agree and how soul destroying it is to trawl your way through Endo after Endo hoping that the next one may have seen the light ....................... But hasn't.

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator in reply to m7-cola

They pursued relentless Dr Gordon Skinner and what other doctor in this country (or in the world) would have had 10,000 testimonials sent to the GMC to state how he 'saved their lives?

Who pursued Dr S? Certainly not patients who were queing up to consult with him and travelling from all over the UK.

Dr Peatfield also had similar treatment and resigned his licence so that he was not struck off but he could still advise sick people who were in limbo.

LindaC profile image
LindaC

And for reminding us of the amazing work of the wonderful John Lowe :-)

If only 'they' would get out his work and look closely at it... but they don't care, since 'being right' - like children shouting out in class - seems their limit. :-(

UrsaP profile image
UrsaP

Thank you shaws Tagging linda96

You may also like...

I've only taken T3 for the past three days

Can't believe I've been prescribed t3 in Wales!

the endo I've waited 6 months to see and can not believe that the consultant listened to me and how...

Depressed and bipolar patients with normal TSH should be prescribed T3 supplementation...

and associated dysfunction that is present in depressed patients, it is clear that timed-released...

Giving the Dr John Lowe middle of the night single T3 dose a go!

know who you are ;-) and... is there anyone else using single dose T4, T4/T3, T3 or NDT ? And how...

DR appt later today low T3 suppresses TSH