Betaine HCI , is this the best product for low ... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

141,246 members166,490 posts

Betaine HCI , is this the best product for low stomach acid ?

C70rol profile image
16 Replies

Hi everyone. I have been taking apple cider vinegar for my low stomach acid for some time now and it has suited me fine. But recently , I've felt it isn't enough. As my bowels are much more loose in the mornings and I need to go A couple of times. plus my stomach feels a touch bloated for a couple of hours after.

I would also say that I have adrenal insufficiency at present, that's dragging on, so perhaps I need more hydrochloride acid to strengthen the digestion?

Anyone else find that Betaine HCI works well for them ?

Written by
C70rol profile image
C70rol
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
16 Replies
ShinyB profile image
ShinyB

Hi, I take it before a meal, plus digestive enzymes. I also take a supplement called Beta Plus because I had my gallbladder removed. They seem to all help but I can't hand on heart say I know they are making a difference! I thought I would reply though as that will take your post back up the forum, so that more people might see it. It's easy for posts to get overlooked, so never worry about posting again if you've not received any replies after a day or so :)

C70rol profile image
C70rol in reply toShinyB

Hi shinyB

thanks for replying,

which make of Betaine do you use,

ShinyB profile image
ShinyB in reply toC70rol

Mine is Doctor's Best, Betaine HCl Pepsin and Gentian Bitters.

PPower profile image
PPower

C70rol,

I was also taking apple cider vinegar and then switched to Betaine hcl with pepsin. I had been going up to 8-10 times per day! My symptoms disappeared immediately and it really has worked (been taking it about 2 wks. now). I take it with each meal after 2-3 bites. I've only had to take one pill with a meal but some people have to have more. Definitely worth trying!

C70rol profile image
C70rol in reply toPPower

Hello PPower,

thanks very much for replying, and I'm sorry to be late in my reply to you,but my internet has been off since yesterday evening and has just come back on!!!!....

I ordered (by phone), some Betaine HCI from Higher Nature today, because I wanted to get started on something ! But can you tell me which brand you use, and is it better to have the Pepsin with the Betaine ?

PPower profile image
PPower in reply toC70rol

C70rol,

I'm using Metabolic Maintenance but I'm sure there are plenty that are good. I hope it's as successful for you as it has been for me!

C70rol profile image
C70rol in reply toPPower

Sounds interesting! Is that the brand name ? I've never heard of it before ,

PPower profile image
PPower in reply toC70rol

Yes, that's the company name. I got 100 capsules of Betaine HCL with Pepsin. I had never heard of them before either but my acupuncturist/gut specialist recommended them.

Dee8686 profile image
Dee8686

Is this a symptom of low stomach acid? Frequent bowel movements?

PPower profile image
PPower in reply toDee8686

Dee8686, well, I just ad a stool test and it showed that I have poor fat malabsorption (high steatocrit) and that would suggest inadequate secretion of stomach acid or bile. The symptoms can vary with individuals but that is one of them.

Dee8686 profile image
Dee8686 in reply toPPower

Hmm I had a stool teat done too and my steatocrit was <15%. Not sure what that means!

PPower profile image
PPower in reply toDee8686

Dee8686, <15% is good and that is what's considered "normal." Mine is 29 which is high.

Dee8686 profile image
Dee8686 in reply toPPower

Ok that’s good to know thanks! I do have to go to the loo quite often sometimes though so just wondered if low stomach acid might be linked!

PPower profile image
PPower in reply toDee8686

You could start out by taking apple cider vinegar, 1 t in some water, before a meal. See if that helps.

Credo profile image
Credo in reply toPPower

Hi Ppower,

I was diagnosed with a gallstone this year,after two years on Lanzaprozole and peptac, but surgeon said as I have no pain, there was no need to remove it. But last week I had to go to A&E with severe pain.Doc gave me pain relief and said stone had probably moved into bile duct. He said he would write to my surgeon that he had seen me that night, but what I really want is the stone removed . I now have been told that these meds stop absorption of my Thyroxine. I have stopped antacids, and now take apple cider vinegar, helps slightly. But now will order Betaine HCL.

humanbean profile image
humanbean

Betaine HCl should be bought with Pepsin included. The Pepsin is required to digest protein. Apparently poor digestion of protein is a common problem when stomach acid is low.

If you want lots of reading on the subject of low stomach acid...

For anyone who decides to take Betaine HCL and Pepsin, these are interesting and useful, particularly the last two links - and they are all quite short :

scdlifestyle.com/2012/06/hy...

scdlifestyle.com/2012/03/3-...

scdlifestyle.com/2012/03/ho...

scdlifestyle.com/2013/10/4-...

For an explanation of how basic digestion works and why having low stomach acid is a problem (these links aren't aimed at people with thyroid issues, but they explain how and why low stomach acid causes so many problems) :

chriskresser.com/what-every...

chriskresser.com/the-hidden...

chriskresser.com/more-evide...

chriskresser.com/how-your-a...

chriskresser.com/how-your-a...

chriskresser.com/get-rid-of...

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

low stomach acid tips

Does anyone have any tips to help low stomach acid please? I am trying to up my vitamins and...

Low stomach acid

Hi , I have read that most people with hypothyroidism / hashimotos have low stomach acid . Does...
Sandra49 profile image

Low Stomach Acid and dosage of betaine hcl

Hi I've been awake the last couple of nights with 'acid throat' discomfort. I did the...

Low or high stomach acid? this is the question!

I recently spoke to my Gp saying I think I have low stomach acid rather than too much (symptoms are...

Low Stomach Acid

Hi all, I posted previously saying I was prescribed ~Omeprazole for reflux. Greygoose has...
hilary33 profile image

Moderation team

See all
PurpleNails profile image
PurpleNailsAdministrator
Jaydee1507 profile image
Jaydee1507Administrator
SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.