Should Thyroid Patients Self-Medicate?An Edito... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

141,243 members166,489 posts

Should Thyroid Patients Self-Medicate?An Editorial from Mary Shomon

Clutter profile image
10 Replies

One of the most controversial issues facing thyroid patients in the US and worldwide is whether patients should medicate themselves to treat thyroid problems, and in particular, an underactive thyroid/hypothyroidism. When I say "self-medicate," I mean buying prescription thyroid hormone replacement medication without a doctor's prescription, and then taking that medication without a doctor's oversight.

(I am not referring to those patients whose doctors prescribe thyroid medication but then allow the patients to go up or down in dosage between visits.)

Continued in verywell.com/should-thyroid...

Written by
Clutter profile image
Clutter
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
10 Replies
Rapunzel profile image
Rapunzel

Top article Clutter - thanks for posting. A reminder of the pernicious effect of 'groupthink'. Whatever MDs are doing, the majority of GPs and, sadly, endos are also guilty of aping. At least in the US ranges for TSH have been revised. Many here will attest to being told than until their gold standard TSH is >10, there's no treatment. Beyond awful and the reason why so many of us self treat :(

I found this a fairly tame article from Ms Shomon, who I expect to champion we thyroidies a little better. Has she been 'got at' ??

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply toRapunzel

Rapunzel,

I think she's right to advise caution but as "it's not your thyroid" often leads to antidepressants rather than further investigation I can't see how self medicating leads to a missed diagnosis of something else.

crabapple profile image
crabapple

Thank you. A comprehensive summary of the current position, I think.

humanbean profile image
humanbean

I found the article disturbing. I worry about being denied the right to self-medicate as it is, without one of the famous advocates for thyroid patients saying how much she disagrees with it.

I'm in my mid 50s. Let's say, for the sake of argument, that I'm going to live another 25 years. I do not believe in that time scale that thyroid treatment will become what we would want it to be, I think it will get worse, particularly when democracy vanishes and corporate government takes over. So, anyone, particularly someone who should be on our side, disapproving of patients self-medicating makes me extremely angry.

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply tohumanbean

HB,

Not advocating self medication is not the same as disapproving of it. I read it that Shoman sees self medicating as an undesirable necessity for many.

I found what she said about FDA regulation of NDT disturbing if it's true.

humanbean profile image
humanbean in reply toClutter

Yes the FDA stuff was very disturbing. Medicine has really lost its way. It isn't about getting people well any more (was it ever, I wonder?) it is about making money.

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministrator

Perhaps we all need to revise our fundamental view of medicine?

I really don't know what the answer is, but sure as anything, our current systems (worldwide, not just the UK, Europe, USA) are not working.

It is a matter of luck whether what we as individuals need as medicine is cheap or expensive, a controlled drug or available in a supermarket. It certainly isn't logical, fair or anything else positive.

The issues go far further than medicines themselves, as the link below highlights.

bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-l...

I want to applaud Graham Smith for doing what he knew he needed to.

Glynisrose profile image
Glynisrose

Sometimes its imperative.

pamelashep profile image
pamelashep

Hi I have managed to get a private prescription for Armour Thyroid can you suggest companies I can buy it from. Thanks Pam P's not sure if this is correct procedure for asking questions. Thanks

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministrator in reply topamelashep

You would usually be better off writing your own new post - rather than responding to an existing post/thread. Click on Write a post in the banner at the top and go from there!

Have a look here:

thyroiduk.org.uk/tuk/treatm...

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Should I self medicate?

Had another disastrous conversation with (another!) endo at the clinic yesterday. They always ask...
Mickeydooley profile image

Self medicating - Your personal experience and advice appreciated

Fed up with my local NHS GP's approach to my hypo symptoms which led to a personal...
ILR2019 profile image

Mary Shomon has responded on the BMJ 'Bad Medicine: Thyroid Disease' article

Just went back to the BMJ article posted by GP Des Spence on 9th November 2012, to see if there had...
RedApple profile image
Administrator

Coronavirus and thyroid patients - an article from a Hungarian doctor

A recently published article by a Hungarian doctor. Apologies for anything lost in translation....